The stages of recruitment and selection
Recruitment and selection is a critical process for an organisation, it is because the mistake that occurs during the recruitment and selection can pass the costs to an organisation and detract the organisation effectiveness. Recruiting and hiring the people to the position where they can perform effectively is the objectives of an organisation (Dowling, et al, 1999).
Beaumont (1993) cited that there are three main issues that have increased the potential importance of the selection decision to organisation (Beardwell and Claydon, 2007):
The trend and changes of demographic in the labour market result in a more diverse workforce, thus, it increase the pressure on the notion of fairness in selection.
The need for a multi-skilled, flexible workforce and the emphasis on team working - individual behaviour and attitudes is more concerned.
The emphasis between corporate strategic and people management - links between selection processes and outcomes to an organisation goals.
In the Harvard Business Review, it indicated selection decision lead to 80 percent of turnover which is a costly mistake (the costs comprise money spent on recruitment, selection and training) (Meyer, 2008). Therefore, it is important to ensure the selection methods that used are appropriate to the jobs. Other than that, the performance of the managers often partially relies on their employees. Employees that employed to fill up the position with inappropriate skills and knowledge is an obstacle to improve the effectiveness of organisation.
Moreover, there is a legal compliance that the organisation needs to comply. Equal Employment Law (EEO) has introduced the laws of non-discrimination during selection process for protected groups (Dessler, 2005).
Thus, the selection process is increasingly important to help the organisation hire the employees with the right skills and knowledge that link to its position. The ethical issues in selection process are highly concerned. The issues include individual rights and privacy, the potential of abuse authority and control and unfair offer provided for different types of applicants (Beardwell and Claydon, 2007).
Recruitment and Selection
Figure 1: The stages of recruitment and selection
Pool of Applicants
Human resource planning
(Bratton, J. and Gold, J. (2007) Human Resource Management - Theory and Practice, 4th Edition, Palgrave Macmillan, New York, p241)
The process of recruitment and selection are influenced by external and internal factors. Organisations can either internal recruiting or external recruiting based on the requirement of the positions (Griffin, 2003). After that, organisation can use various recruitment methods such as advertising, applicant forms, and websites and so on. The recruitment methods that used must be effective in attracting potential people. Subsequently, organisation can use various selection methods to select the right people to the position, thus, it can contribute to the organisation effectiveness. Finally, organisation can evaluate the effectiveness of the selection methods through job performance of the applicants (Bratton and Gold, 2007).
Basic Testing Concept
Bratton and Gold (2007) pointed out effective selection process largely depends on its reliability and validity.
Reliability - refers to the consistency of the performance measure. There are various methods to test the reliability of the selection.
Validity - refers to the extent to which a selection technique actually measures what it supposes to measure that related to performance on the job.
Furthermore, Neo, et al. (2003) added additional criteria to measure the effectiveness of selection process:
Generalisability - is known as the degree to which the validity of selection method established in one context extends to other contexts. It is because the test validity often extends across situations and subgroups.
Utility - is the extent to which the information presented by selection methods enhances the effectiveness of an organisation.
Legality - the selection methods that chosen should comply with the existing laws and legal procedures.
Organisation uses various sophisticated selection techniques to reduce the risk of hiring inappropriate employees. However, the methods that used must have a connection with the jobs. A survey of selection methods that frequently used by UK organisation indicated that the most general approach is the interview with curriculum vitae and application form (68%) and 58% are using competency-based interview. Other techniques that been used by organisation contain of structured interview, critical behavioural, reference before interview, and various tests.
Application blanks often the first step used by organisation to select applicants. In order to gather all the relevant information, application will be the efficient method as compared to others (Griffin, 2003). Application forms often provide four types of information for employers:
Education backgrounds and experiences of an applicant enable the employers to make judgements on substantive matters (Bratton and Gold, 2007).
The information that in the application forms can help the employers to draw conclusions about the applicant's previous progress and growth.
The employment history of applicants can help the employers to predict the applicant's stability.
Employers can predict which candidates will succeed on the job based on the information in the applicant forms.
(Example 1) BellSouth use several different forms of application blanks, which tailored to the needs of different components of organisations. The application forms can inform the BellSouth what the applicants have done and what they can bring to job and the organisation (Miner and Crane, 1995).
Application blanks should not contain the questions, which are not related to job, such as race, gender or national origin. Furthermore, employers have to ensure that they comply equal employment law when setting the application forms. There are several questions that the employer should aware (Dessler, 2005):
Education - This question may illegal because the dates of attendance and graduation may reflect the age of applicants. Furthermore, this question should not be asked if it is not a job's requirement (Miner and Crane, 1995).
Arrest Record - Employers must be able to provide a business-related reason, which require the applicants to provide such information. Otherwise, the court will held that employers violate Title VII by disqualifying applicants because of an arrest record (Beardwell and et al., 2004).
Notify in cases of emergency - This question generally requires applicants to provide a person's information such as name, address, and phone number. Moreover, it often asks the relationship between the person and the applicants, which could show the applicant's marital status or lineage (Dessler, 2005).
Membership in organisations - The memberships of applicants in clubs, organisation, or societies often reveal the applicants' race, religion, physical handicaps and so forth (Dessler, 2005).
Physical handicaps - It is unlawful to require the applicants' to reveal their physical handicaps or health history unless the employers can provide the specification that the health issues may affect the job performance (Miner and Crane 1994). Most of the people refuse to disclose their mental health problem on the application forms because of the stigma and fear of discrimination (www.news.bbc.co.uk). (Example 2) For example, in the application form of GAP, a question "Do you consider yourself to have a disability" has slightly ruin the disability applicants. If they are rejected, they may think that the organisations reject them because of their disability.
Marital Status - Generally, the application form should not ask the question about the status of the applicants, age of spouse, the number of children and so on (Bratton and Gold, 2007).
Housing - Questions about the housing probably may lead to discriminatory. It can adversely affect the minority group (Dessler, 2005).
Photograph - It is unlawful to request the applicants to submit the application form with photograph because their photograph will imply their age. Thus, it may result in age discrimination (www.timesonline.co.uk).
(Example 3) Today, many bosses are still asking banned questions such as age, length of experiences, and religious. The Employment Protection Act prohibited the employers to ask the questions such as religious, age, race, beliefs, gender, religion, sexuality, disability (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
(Example 4) Asda - the giant supermarket, did not state the question of date of birth on the application form because they found that it is a discrimination act if they require applicants to give their data of birth. Moreover, they emphasised that they will recruit people of all ages - from 16 to over 70 (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
Interview is the oldest method of selection. There are 2 types of interview (Dessler, 2005):
Unstructured interview - there is no set format to follow, which enable the interviewer to use various direction. Thus, unstructured interview enable the interviewer to ask follow-up questions and pursue points of interests as they develop (Ferris, et al., 2002).
Structured interview - is the interview based on planed questions and responses (Bratton and Gold, 2007). Thus, the structured interview tends to more valid and reliable because all of the applicants are asked for the same questions.
Several types of interview content can use for different purpose:
Stress interview - is aimed at identify hypersensitive applicants and those with low or high stress tolerance. Thus, a series of rude question will be asked during stress interview (Dessler, 2007).
Situational Interview - is an interview procedure where managers pose a specific situation to applicants and ask them how they would react to this situation (Leopold, et al., 2005). The applicants are given a situation; managers can request the candidates to provide the answer based on their imagination or previous experiences (Neo, et al., 2003).
Behavioural Interview - concentrate on how interviewee reacted to the actual situation in past and uses it to predict their behaviour in the future (Cole, 2005). (Example 5) Citizen's Banking Corporation in Flint Michigan used behavioural interview to select the applicants (Dessler, 2005).
Job-related Interview - the question that asked in the interview is job-related questions that focus on relevant past job-related behaviours (Dessler, 2005).
Interview can be administrated in different ways:
Sequential interview - interviewee will be asked by a group of interviewer sequentially and interviewee will be evaluated by each interviewer on a standard form (Dessler, 2005).
Individual Interview - involves face-to face interview, thus provides opportunity for the interviewer to stay close with interviewee (Armstrong, 2006).
Panel interview - a group of interviewer will interview the interviewee simultaneously, thus, it will increase the stress of an applicant (Miner and Crane, 1995).
Mass interview - a group of interviewer will ask a group of interviewee simultaneously (Dessler, 2005).
Computerised interview - interviewee's oral or replies are received in response to computerised oral, visual, or written questions (Dessler, 2005).
Some criticised the use of interviews has an adverse impact on selection because interview tend to subjective and stereotyping (Beardwell and Claydon, 2007). Furthermore, interview is used to predict the performance of applicants, which can result in lack of validity. The lack of reliability of an interview often happens as it is measuring the same things for different applicants (Armstrong, 2006).
When designing and preparing the question for an interview, managers should be able to differentiate the questions which is related and important to the job. Most of the managers tend to ask the questions, which is not related to the job. The questions that often asked by managers can be construed as being biased on the ground of sex, race, disability or other interviewee's life should be avoided. For example, 'Are you planning to have any more children?', 'Are you married?', 'would it worry you being a member of an ethnic minority here?' (Armstrong, 2006).
Furthermore, it is unlawful to ask the question about the previous compensation packages that offered by the previous employers before providing a compensation packages for the applicants (Beardwell, et al., 2004). It is illegal for employers to ask whether the applicants have ever received workers' compensation for a previous injury or illness.
4.2.1 Problems of Delving Applicant's Life
According to Greenberg and Baron (2000), prejudice is a negative attitude toward applicants according to their membership in a particular group. Most of the managers reject applicants due to the prejudicial attitude toward the applicants, which lead to the discrimination happens. Interview, background and references investigation and various tests that applied can be as a selection tool can be result in discrimination.
Discriminations can be either divided into (Cole, 2005):
Overt discrimination is discriminate employees based on their sex, race, and nationality and so on.
Covert discrimination is an unfair treatment according to employee's characteristic that belong to such as gender. For example, managers often refuse female applicants because women are emotional.
There are two types of discriminations (Beardwell, et al., 2004):
Direct discrimination often occurs when applicant is treated unfairly as compared to others due to their sex, marital status, race and so on (Leopold, et al., 2005).
Indirect discrimination generally happens when requirements are imposed that are not necessary for the job. For example, the types of test that applied as selection methods for the job must be based on job requirement. Otherwise, direct discrimination will be resulted.
4.2.2 The Issues Arise From Interview
The use of interview as selection method has been open to criticism on grounds of discriminating against the applicant on the factors that are beyond their control. The questions such as age, ethnic origin, sexual orientation that asked during interview process can give rise to the issues of discrimination, morality and invasion of privacy.
Age Discrimination Act makes it unlawful for the employers to specify age when selecting staff. It is unlawful to use terms such as 'youngish', 'recently qualified' and 'under forty' unless employers are able to provide a clear business-related reason for the specification of the requirement. Most of the organisations commonly discriminate the people for employment who are between 40 and 65 years of age (Beardwell and Claydon, 2007).
Managers usually have the assumption those older employees unable to perform the work efficiency because old people tend to work in slow motion. Furthermore, some organisation's compensation system is based on the age - the older people with experience often receive higher pay than younger people. Thus, managers tend to ask the age of applicants during the interview and try to reject those older employees indirectly. It is unethical and unlawful to reject applicants based on age.
(Example 6) A recruitment advertisement with the phase 'youthful enthusiasm' had resulted in discrimination. Mr. McCoy claimed that he has a lot of experience and knowledge of timber trade, thus, he is able to handle the job well. But, he was rejected after two interviews. Mr. McCoy was being asked age related questions during the interview. The court held that it is unlawful to apply age as one of the selection factors. Thus, Mr. McCoy won the case (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
According to Paul Newton, regardless of any other criteria, employers reject the applicants once they notice applicants' data of birth. This may lead to indirect discrimination, thus, it is unethical for the employers to state the age questions in the application form (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
(Example 7) In the case of O'Connor v. Consolidated Coin Caterers Corp, an employee claimed for discrimination of age over 40 because she was replaced by an employee 16 younger than her. As a result, the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 (ADEA) judged that Consolidated Coin Caterers Corporation was accused of age discrimination (Dessler, 2005).
(Example 8) Megan Thomas claimed that she was unfairly dismissed after being informed she was not old enough to deal with its members. The London Employment Tribunal held that Megan Thomas was discriminated against because of her age (www.caterarsearch.com).
Other than that, interview's questions should not include the sexual life of applicants. Gay and lesbian employees often use plenty of time and stress trying to conceal a big part of their identity.
(Example 9) A gay vice president of a large office-equipment manufacturer in Chicago had the opportunity to promote as a CEO of the company; however, he fears his chances will be ruined as the management aware that he is sexual orientation (Greenberg and Baron, 2000).
(Example 10) Nonetheless, the vice president of human resource for Lotus Development Corp. reiterated that extending fringe benefit that tailored for sexual orientation employees is an important key to the organisation success in attracting highly talented technical personnel (Armstrong, 2006).
(Example 11) In the case of Smith v Liberty Mutual Insurance Co., (1978) the plaintiff was rejected employment because of his sexual life. However, the courts claimed that employers have to guarantee equal job opportunities regardless of their sexual life (Huang and Kleiner, 2000).
Race or Ethnic Minority
Generally, managers will enquire the race or nationality of applicants during the interview process. Organisations tend to refuse to hire applicants, who are different from them. It is because organisations believe different race or nationality of an applicant probably can influence the thinking and the way of the applicant performs his/her job. However, it is unlawful to discriminate against any applicants because of their ethnic origin (Dong and Kleiner, 1999).
(Example 12)Toyota was accused of breaching the racial discrimination law - an industrial tribunal noted that Vijay Madara unfairly dismissed from training courses in car plant (www.bbc.co.uk).
(Example 13) In 1993, the Supreme Court of the state of Washington held that Seattle bank was accused - race discrimination against a Cambodian-American employee who was fired due to his accent (Greenberg and Baron, 2000).
(Example 14) Western Digital Corp. Was accused for race discrimination as the company favoured white men during job cuts last year at its Irvine headquarters. Qualified hardworking Chinese, Japanese, Koreans, Filipino, Vietnamese and many other Asian people are often denied job opportunities or discriminated against for reasons that are not related to their performance and abilities. However, it is unlawful to deny the employment opportunity of an individual regarding to his/her ethic origin and race (Dong and Kleiner, 1999).
The application form should not comprise the question about gender because some of organisations may refuse to hire female to the vacant position. Female applicants tend to rejected by organisation because managers always think that female applicants less productivity than male applicants. Moreover, female applicants less flexible than the male applicants because female applicants often take care of family and unable to transfer from one country to another. Indeed, only 3.0 percent of senior managers and 5.7 percent of corporate directors of Fortune 500 companies are women (Greenberg and Baron, 2000).
(Example 15) Australian Iron and Steel Pty Ltd applied a 'last on, first off' redundancy policy at its Port Kembla steelworks. The High Court held that the policy had discriminated the women indirectly, even though, on the surface, it appeared to be neutral policy. It is because the past discriminatory hiring practices that favoured men, a higher proportion of female workers were rejected (Cole, 2005).
(Example 16) The Lord Chancellor - Lord Irvine has been accused of indirect discrimination on the grounds of sex. The court found that he tends to hire white men to be his special adviser and reject the women and black people (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
Furthermore, question of marital status and the number of kids should not ask during the interview. It is because the married people may feel that they are discriminated if they are not hired by managers. Married people tend to close to the family and take care of the family. For instance, most of the married people will take day off if their children are sick (Beardwell, et al., 2004).
Nonetheless, married female normally are ready to pregnant. Thus, if the organisations reject the applicants, they may think that the organisations discriminate them as a married people. It is because organisation has to pay for the pregnancy leave and more benefits for the pregnant women.
(Example 17) During the interview, Ms Tobin was rejected by the store manager because she was pregnant. The tribunal claimed that the store manager was not ready to hire MS Tobin when the store manager was informed that she was pregnant. Thus, Ms Tobin was awarded 2,500 in compensation for injury to her feeling (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
(Example 18) The manager of John Martin Group in East Lothian refused the request of the Mr Walkingshaw to work as a part timer after having children. Thus, Mr Walkingshaw thinks that he was treated differently from the women in the company who had requested for part-time work. The tribunal claimed that Mr Walkingshaw had been discriminated against because of his sex (www.hrmguide.co.uk).
(Example 19) British Airways' pilot - Jessica Starmar claimed that she was discriminated against because of her sex. She has been rejected to work as part timer so she can look after her children. (www.newsbbc.co.uk).
Background and References Investigation
References and biographical data investigation are used universally in UK, along with the interview (Ferris, et al., 2002). Often, more than one applicant is eligible for the jobs, thus, the managers will try to check and verify the job applicant's background information and references (Armstrong, 2006). Furthermore, background and reference investigation can help the organisations to predict individual's absenteeism because employers believes that the factors such as personal or family related characteristics can affect absenteeism indirectly (Rosenblatt and Shirom, 2005).
Background investigation and references check with the purpose of obtaining the factual confidential information of the applicants and opinion about his/her character and suitability for a job. (Example 20) BellSouth, for instance, using background and reference check as one of the selection tools. The director estimates that 15% to 20% of applicants secrete their own confidential information. He reiterated that it is general and common to find someone who applies and looks good, but with all types of criminal history (Dessler, 2005).
(Example 21) APCOA Inc. (a Cleveland based company that operates parking facilities at 400 urban sites and 70 airports in 42 states) carries out background checks include driving records, credit history, criminal record, and education and employment verification. The types of background checks vary across the position in the company (Neo, et al., 2003). For instance, the level of education check is needed with the purpose of hiring an accountant. In contrast, there is no requirement to have education check for a cleaner.
Telephone references provide advantages for the managers because people are more likely to give honest opinion orally than writing (Armstrong, et al, 2006). (Example 22) Northwestern Bell's district managers found that reference check can inaccurate because previous employers mostly said that "this is the greatest individual the world has never seen". (Example 23) Intuit Corporation, the Menlo Park, California, Software Company that produces Quicken, attempts to get rid of these problems by asking references in large amount such as 10 references (Neo, et al., 2003).
4.3.1 Problems Arise from Background and References Investigation
It is important to have background and references check because dangerous will be result if previous employer didn't provide relevant information. (Example 24) In Florida case, an employee was terminated due to allegedly bringing a handgun to work. After that, he went for other company and fired by his employer for absenteeism. Subsequently, he returned to the second company and shot a supervisor, HR director and 3 staff before committing suicide (Dessler, 2005).
(Example 25)Airlines sued by employees for invasion of privacy because providing negative references and documented poor performance. Thus, most of the employers fear to provide inaccurate references. Consequently, the American Airlines pilots mistakenly thought there was engine failure and the commuter plan he was piloting crashed near North Carolina (Jones and George, 2003).
(Example 26) A previous employee of California telecommunications company had hired BadReferences.com to check whether his previous employer give some bad-mouth on him towards his current company. Finally, the employee won $45,000 in compensation due to the defamation (Dessler, 2005).
Although it may be unethical for employer to check the criminal records of applicants, it is necessary to check the criminal records of the applicants in order to avoid second tragedy happen. (Example 27) In case of Ponticas v. K.M.S. Investments, an apartment manager with passkey entered a woman's apartment and assaulted her. The courts found that employers negligent in not properly checking the manager's background before hiring (negligent hiring). Hence, employer liable when employees with criminal records to commit crimes (Deresky, 2005).
Furthermore, the background and reference investigation may lead to the invasion of privacy. Employers have no authority to have a criminal or credit check, unless, employers are able to give a job-related reason for carrying out the certain investigation. (Example 28) In Australia, Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission claimed that applicants are protected from being rejected because of their criminal record (www.hr-topics.com).
Organisation should not further background and reference investigation on sexual issue. It is because this type of question can ruin the sense of self respect of the applicants (especially applicants, who are homosexual). The applicants, who are homosexual, may fear of being 'discovered'. It is unethical and unlawful to refuse the applicant on the basis of sexual orientation.
Other Selection Methods
Preemployment Information Services
Nowadays, most of the companies are using preemployment information services to delving into an applicant's life. It employs databases to accumulate information about matters such as workers' compensation and credit histories. However, companies should select the firm that complies with all relevant rules and regulation such as the Fair Credit Reporting Act and uses only legal data sources (Dessler, 2005).
Based on the information that provided, some companies may discriminate the employees according to their race, religion and disability. Thus, the 1990 American with Disabilities Act (ADA) forbid employers from making preemployment inquiries into existence or severity of a disability. Further, it is unlawful to offer the job compensation to the applicants after reviewing the applicants' previous compensation claims (Dessler, 2005).
Physical Ability - can be used to examine the applicant performance, predict occupational injuries and disabilities (Neo, et al., 2003). Physical test can used to avoid the employees filling the compensation claim for pre-existing injuries. Neo, et al., (2003) identified 7 classes of tests: muscular power, muscular endurance, cardiovascular endurance, flexibility, balance and coordination.
Physical test has adverse impact on applicants with disabilities. Under Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), employer has no right to reject an applicant with disabilities if he/she is qualified and able to perform the basic job function with reasonable accommodation (Dessler, 2005). Moreover, physical test often applied to the jobs that require some physical feature such as production job applicants (Greenberg and Baron, 2000).
Furthermore, some employers may reject the applicants for high stress job who have health problems such as heart problem. It is because employers may think that the employees with heath problem may not able to carry out the job successfully. However, it is unethical to reject employees because of their health problem.
(Example 29) PC Paul Weaver wins disability discrimination case - he was rejected (because he was suffering from a debilitating condition) to join a scheme, which is developed to give long-serving officers an alternative to be retained by Force beyond their usual retirement age (www.rjw.co.uk).
(Example 30)Greiner Engineering, Inc of Irving, Texas provided its employees in wheelchairs simply by substituting a lighter weight door in its rest rooms and by raising a drafting table with some bricks under legs (Greenberg and Baron, 2000).
(Example 31) In Scotland, there are two applicants was rejected because of colour-blindness and they found that colour blindness only found in men. Thus, the physical test of colour blindness accused of sex or disability discrimination. Mr Dixon had lost the similar claim under disability discrimination legislation because Tribunal claimed that it is important to hire officers with the colour-blindness condition (www.news.bb.co.uk).
(Example 32) In Volkswagen's Wolfsburg plant, they are practising a policy of integrating people with disabilities into workforce. Thus, they had employed an employee - Mr Janz, who is blind.
4.4.3 Genetic Screening
Genetic Screening - attempt to measure the employee's physical by using blood testing. In 1990, 15% of US companies had intended to use genetic screening as a tool of physical testing. However, there is strong debate over the ethics of basing employment decision on unchangeable traits as the use of genetic screening has increased. Applicants are unable to improve or change as the companies are using genetic screening as a selection tool. Furthermore, companies also will be forced to design a hassle-free workplace (Kramar, et al., 1997).
4.2.4 AIDS Test
(Example 33) IBM and Johnson and Johnson has provided applicants with AIDS or HIV positive with equal opportunities as applicants with others serious illness. It is because a scientific research indicated that people with AIDS or HIV infection do not pose a risk of transmitting the virus via normal workplace contact. Further, regulation restrict employers to use AIDS testing as a part of physical examination and the employers must keep the employee's information confidentially (Kramer, et al., 1997).
AIDS test often prohibited because organisations refuse the applicants with AIDS/HIV. Furthermore, the privacy and confidential information of applicant has been disclosure. They may feel one inferior because they are AIDS/HIV. AIDS is a frightening and threatening disease, but people with AIDS/HIV should not be treated differently from any other disease (Armstrong, 2006).
(Example 34)AIDS test is illegal under South Africa's labour laws. However, some of the mining companies have been rejecting HIV-infected Mozambican Workers. They applied the AIDS test for Mozambican miners, and then repatriating those found to be infected (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
4.4.5 Drug Tests
Drug test often aimed at designing a safety workplace for both employees and consumers. However, American Civil Liberties Union argued that the drug test is invasive and violate individual's privacy. Some argues that drug testing procedures are humiliating and insulting the applicants (Dessler, 2005). A research indicated that the drug residues such as those from cannabis may remains in the body for a long period of time has no adverse impact of work performance (Kramar, et al., 1997).
Many claimed that using drug tests can reduce on-the-job accidents. Nevertheless, a research showed that drug test is only an excuse for safety purpose because 95% of the on-the job accidents are result by fatigue and alcohol (Neo, et al., 2003).
Nevertheless, a research indicated that a drug does not have any impact on work success. According to statistics from British Crime Survey and Labour Force Survey, they found that the average wages of drug users was slightly high than the non-drug users (ww.news.bbc.co.uk).
Furthermore, drug testing only can indicate the drug residues are present, it can't measure the impairment. As a result, an impairment testing programs are introduced to measure whether a worker is alert and mentally capable of performing critical tasks currently - and does not get into whether this is due to illegal drug, alcohol or simple fatigue (Neo, et al., 2003) (Dessler, 2005).
In order to work the ethical issues that arise from drug testing, employers are suggested to adopt a disciplinary policy - written down clearly the terms and condition if the employee breaches the drug policy (Kramar, et al., 1997). Test must be applied in an intrusive-free environment and the result must be held in strict confidence.
(Example 35) Nordstrom - the large department store chain, conduct the Reid Survey to screen for violent tendencies, drug use and dishonesty. Essentially, the test was only one of many aspects that went into final hiring decision, thus, there were some people who were not recommended by Reid test (Dowling, et al., 1999).
Drug test has raised the issue of applicant privacy. The living styles of an applicant vary among the applicants. Managers probably believe that drug taker are less productivity and always need drug to motivate themselves to work hard. However, drug test is invalid (Kramer, et al., 1997).
(Example 36) In the King's Troop, Royal Horse Artillery, the duty of the soldiers is to guard the Queen. However, there are five soldiers have been fired from Army after accusing of a drug test. The Ministry of Defence it is unlawful to take drug during the working time (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
Honesty Test (Polygraph test) and Graphology
Honesty test are widely used by the US large companies as a selection tool because it is a reliable device that measure physiological changes like increased perspiration (Kramar, et al., 1997). Thus, employers can prevent from hiring a theft via honesty test. Further, honesty test doesn't have great adverse impact on demographic group because there is no large differences attributes to race or sex (Neo, et al., 2003).
Graphology test is defined as the analysis of handwriting to determine the applicant's personality and characteristics. However, using graphology has potential for social stereotyping and superficial judgements (Beardwell and Claydon, 2007). Thus, the use of graphology as a selection tools to find out the applicant's personality is highly suspecting (Dessler, 2005).
(Example 37) Merrill Lynch Asset Management had employed the graphology test to select the applicants for the available position. However, they had stopped the use of graphology test because they found that the graphology test is low in validity (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
Honesty and graphology test has advocated the issues of applicant privacy. Major problem of privacy of the individual arise in employment related to honesty test. Due to the issue of privacy, New South Wales and the US government have introduced a new regulation to prohibit the use of honesty test for employment purpose (Kramar, et al., 1997).
Paper-and-pencil test is one of the honesty tests, which designed to forecast job applicants' proneness to dishonesty and other forms of counterproductivity. Employers ought to be caution when questioning applicants because some questions may give rise to invasion of privacy (Dessler, 2005).
Honesty test often used to test the integrity of police officers. (Example 38) In London's Metropolitan Police, the police officers have to face the random undercover "integrity tests", which developed to combat corruption and racism. The test is to check on the colleagues suspected of abusing their positions or breaking the law. There are 50 officers suspended and 20 charged under the integrity tests (www.news.bbc.co.uk).
Smith and Robertson (1986) defined psychological test is "a carefully, systematic and standardised procedure for evolving a sample of responses from candidates which can be used to assess one or more of their psychological characteristic with those of a representative sample of an appropriate population."
Psychological tests often used by organisation to measure the applicants' ability or characteristics. It includes:
Intelligence tests - attempt to assess the general intellectual ability such as memory, vocabulary, verbal fluency and numerical ability (Dessler, et al., 1999).
Personality tests - attempt to classify individual's personality traits and charateristics (Armstrong, 2006). Robberts (1997) identified the five-factors model to categorise individual's personality:
Sociable, gregarious, assertive, talkative, expressive
Emotionally stable, nondepressed, secure, content
Courteous, trusting, good-natured, tolerant, cooperative, forgiving
Dependable, organised, preserving, thorough, achievement-oriented
Curious, imaginative, artistically sensitive, broad-minded, playful
(Neo, R., Hollenbeck, J. R., Gerhart, B., and Wright, P. M. (2003) Human Resource Management, 4th Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York)
According to Neo, et al., (2003), people with high conscientiousness tend to have more stamina at work. For example, (Example 39) CEO of H.J. Heinz - Tony O'Reilly with high conscientiousness - report working 80 - 90 hours a week and only sleep 5 - 6 hours each night.
(Example 40) Dell, Motorola and General Electric use personality test to help screen even top-level candidates to measure and predict such tangibles (Dessler, 2005).
A research found that there are 80% of all organisations were using personality test as selection methods to recruit managers and graduates (Leaopold, et al., 2005). It is because Fortune article showed that majority of the CEOs fail is due to a 'lack of people skills' (Neo, et al., 2003).
(Example 41) In order to empower the workers to be more creative, Hewlett Packard turned to personality test when selecting CEO. It is because the personality test goes beyond skills and experiences (Neo, et al., 2003).
Jackson (1996) argued that there have been some discrimination issues from tests. McHenry (1997) provided an example of unfair test on personality that included the question, 'I think I would make a good leader.' This was answered 'true' by twice as many men as woman, hinting that men are twice as likely to become good leaders (Bratton and Gold, 2007). Therefore, Armstrong (2006) reiterated that care must be taken to offer equal opportunity for applicants.
Cognitive abilities tests (aptitude test) - are tests of general individual mental abilities, such as (Neo, et al., 2003):
Verbal comprehension - is an individual's ability to understand and use written and spoken language.
Quantitative ability - is an individual's ability in term of speed and accuracy to work out the arithmetic problems.
Reasoning ability - is an individual's ability to find out solutions for many diverse problems.
Abilities tests have adversely impact on female. A research about the gender issues distort the result of test indicated that males tend to score higher than female in cognitive test (Dessler, 2005).
(Example 42) Barclays Capital provides cognitive tests instead of interview in selecting graduate and undergraduate candidates (Dessler, 2005).
Attainments test - is the measurement of abilities or skills that have been obtained by training and experience (Armstrong, 2006). (Example 43) Purdue Test for Machinists and Machine Operators tests the job knowledge of experienced machinists with questions like 'What is meant by 'tolerance'?' (Dessler, 2005).
Work Samples and Simulations
4.6.1 Work Sample
Work samples test tend to measure how applicants actually performs the job's basic tasks. Work samples test doesn't delve into applicant's privacy or psyche because the applicants only will be given the task, which are closely related to their basic job's function. Therefore, an intrusion of privacy towards an applicant can be avoided (Dessler, 2005) (Appendix 1: Examples of physical, verbal and mental work sample tests, p39).
Assessment centres are widely used by organisation in today complexity and high demand of work. It enables the organisation to aware the extent to which applicants match the culture of the organisation (Armstrong, 2006).
(Example 44) AT&T is the first company that used assessment centres. There is about 10 - 15 applicants participate in a variety of activities to assess their organisation skills, communication skills, and conflict resolution skills (Jones and George, 2003).
(Example 45) Lloyds TSB, apply the assessment centre as the last step of the selection. During assessment centres, applicants are observed by assessors, a cases study presentation, group exercises and a role play. In order to verify the online test, Lloyds also require applicants to complete numerical reasoning test (Bratton and Gold, 2007).
(Example 46) European Passengers Services Ltd had applied various selection methods such as structured interview, communication exercise, personality inventory, customer service questionnaire in selecting customer service assistants. Assessment centre includes various methods, thus, it can achieve high validity (Bratton and Gold, 2007).
(Example 47) Knowledge Company in Fairfax, Virginia requires applicants for an engineering job to submit drawing and plans for its certain product. The work that submitted will be evaluated by experts (Neo, et al., 2003).
5.0 Data Protection Act 1998 (DPA)
Personal information is a valuable commodity that helps employers to recruit and select the applicants more accurate. Thus, there are many selection methods used to find out the applicant's life and test their abilities. However, there are many issues such as discrimination and invasion of privacy problem occurs due to employer delves the applicant's life. DPA often used to protect the privacy of the applicants. The common law of torts provide some protections for employees against revealing information about the employees to people outside the company. Employers need to acquire the information and manage the information appropriately based on DPA 1998. Employers should comply with the DPA's eight principles (Malhotra, 2004):
Personal data will be obtained and processed fairly and lawfully. In the case of processing sensitive personal data such as ethnic, religion, criminal history, sexual life and religions, the data must processed fairly or lawfully.
Personal data will be held only for specified and lawful purposes. Personal data should only be obtained from the interview, test or background investigation for lawful purposes, and must not be further processed.
Personal data will not be used for any reason other than the specified purpose. Employers are required to process the data that are compatible with the purpose of obtaining the data.
Personal data for specified purpose will not be excessive in amount. Employers are not allowed to obtain the personal data that are not useful for the vacant positions.
Personal data will not be kept longer than necessary. Personal data of applicants processed for any purpose or purposes must not be kept for longer than is necessary for that purpose.
Personal data processed in accordance with individual's rights. The processing of personal data should be in accordance with the right of the applicants under the Act. The applicants, who taking the test, have the right to the confidentiality of test result and the right to informed consent regarding use of the result.
Personal data must be accurate and will be kept secure. Personal information of the applicants that selected must be kept up to date.
Personal data should not be transferred to countries outside the European Economic Area without adequate protection. Employers should not transfer or supply the applicant's personal data to the territory outside the European Economic Area, unless the country has the adequate level of data protection.
There are numerous selection methods exists in the business world where employers can use them to select the most appropriate applicants for vacant position in the organisations. The choice of selection methods typically influenced by several factors: the types of jobs, the skills and knowledge that required for the jobs, the costs of the selection methods, the minimum requirement of the jobs and the firm's strategy. However, employers should be able to provide the reason that the selection methods that used are related to success or failure on job and the tests don't unfairly discriminate against applicants.
During the interview process, employers are not permitted to ask the questions about the ages, sexual life and other sensitive questions; unless, the employer can provide a clear business-related reason for the specification of the requirement. It is because these questions probably may lead to the discrimination issues happen in the workplace. Furthermore, it is unethical for the employers to have a background and references investigation about the compensation packages that offered by the previous employers before offering compensation packages for the applicants. The unfair compensation packages may resulted due to different treatments that provided by the employers to the employees.
According to the aforementioned (a variety of selection methods and the problem of selection methods that discussed), employers are allowed to use a various types of selection methods in testing the applicant's personality, abilities and life. However, the selection methods that used must be useful and related to the vacant positions. It is unethical for the employers to test the applicant's ability where there is not a part of the job's requirements. Nevertheless, in certain circumstances, it is necessary for the employers to conduct various tests for the vacant positions in selecting the applicants. It is because problems of lack of skills and knowledge of applicants may lead to the job implementation backfire or bad consequences such as serious injure.
Delving applicants' life not only arise the discrimination issues but also bullying workplace such as unfair treatments, physically or verbally abused and so forth. Therefore, employers shouldn't disclosure others' personal information that obtained from the selection methods in the workplace. The information that obtained from the selection methods should be kept confidential and handled based on the Data Protection Act guidelines.
In conclusion, employers have the right to interview, background and reference investigation and test the applicant to verify their capability and qualifications. If the employers did not use the appropriate selection methods for the vacant position, adverse effects such as workplace injure will be resulted. Employers should follow the DPA1998 when processing the applicant's data.
Dong, N. T. And Kleiner, B. H. (1999) Journal of Equal Opportunities International - Asian Discrimination In The Workplace, Vol. 18, Issue: 5/6, p11-p15
Huang, C. And Kleiner, B. H. (2000) Journal of Equal Opportunities International - New Development Concerning The Discrimination and Harassment of Gay in the Workplace, Vol. 19, Issue: 6/7, p66-p69
Rosenblatt, Z. and Shirom, A. (2005) Journal of Educational Administration - Predicting Teacher Absenteeism By Personal Background Factors, Vol.43, Issue: 2, p209-p225
Armstrong, M. (2006) Human Resource Management Practice, 10th Edition, Kogan Page Limited, United Kingdom, p409 - p468
Bratton, J. and Gold, J. (2007) Human Resource Management - Theory and Practice, 4th Edition, Palgrave Macmillan, New York, p239 - p270
Beardwell, J. and Claydon, T. (2007) Human Resource Management -A Contemporary Approach, 4th Edition, Pearson Education Limited, Great Britain, p189 - p222
Beardwell, I., Holden, L. and Claydon, T. (2004) Human Resource Management - A Contemporary Approach, 4th Edition, Pearson Education, London, p189 - p277
Cole, K. (2005) Management Theory and Practice, 3rd Edition, Pearson Education, Australia, p646 - p684
Dessler, G., (2005) Human Resource Management, 10th Edition, Pearson Education, New Jersey, p193 - p265
Dowling, P. J., Welch, D. E. And Schuler, R. S. (1999) International Human Resource Management - Managing People in a Multinational Context, 3rd Edition, South-Western College, Mason, p69 - p109
Dessler, G., Griffiths., Lloyd-Walker., and Williams., (1999) Human Resource Management, Prentice Hall, Australia, p75-p123, p253-p344
Ferris, G. R., Buckley, M. R. and Fedor, D. B. (2002) Human Resource Management - Perspectives, Context, Functions and Outcomes, 4th Edition, Pearson Education, New Jersey, p161- p243
Griffin, W. R. (2003) Fundamental of Management - Core Concept and Application, 3rd Edition, Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, p212-p242
Greenberg, J. and Baron, R. A. (2000) Behaviour In Organizations, 7th Edition, Prentice Hall, New Jersey, p128-p167
Jones, G. R. and George, J. M. (2003) Contemporary Management, 3rd Edition, McGraw Hill, New York, p362-p401
Kramar, R., Macgraw, P., Schuler, R., (1997) Human Resource Management in Australia, Addison Wesley Longman, Australia, p304-p351
Leopold, J., Harris, L., and Watson, T., (2005) The Strategic Managing of Human Resources, Pearson Education, London, p 127 - p 139, p140 - p177
Malhotra, N. K. (2004) Marketing Research - An Applied Orientation, 4th Edition, Pearson Education, New Jersey, p676
Miner, J. M. and Crane, D. P. (1995) Human Resource Management, HarperCollins College, New York, p344-386
Neo, R., Hollenbeck, J. R., Gerhart, B., and Wright, P. M. (2003) Human Resource Management, 4th Edition, McGraw-Hill, New York, p216 - p241
Nieto, M. L., (2006) An Introduction To Human Resource Management - An Integrated Approach, Palgrave Macmillan, New York, p171 - p141
Meyer, D., (2008) Nine Recruiting and Selection Tips to Ensure Successful Hiring - http://humanresources.about.com/od/selectemployees/a/staff_selection.htm [4th March 2009]
Toyota worker wins racism case (2003)- http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/2677385.stm [11th March 2009]
UK Politics Irvine Accused of Indirect Discrimination (20th May 1999) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/349130.stm [25th March 2009]
Man Wins Age Discrimination Case (10th January 2008) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/7180732.stm [25th March 2009]
Few Briton Aware of 'Ageist' Law (8th November 2002) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/2417325.stm [6th April 2009]
Mother Wins Discrimination Case (5th November 2007) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/glasgow_and_west/7078880.stm [6th April 2009]
Mentally Ill' Suffer Discrimination (24th April 2000) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/720475.stm [6th April 2009]
Asda To Scrap Birth Date Queries (28th August 2006) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/5292034.stm [6th April 2009]
Police Accused of Discrimination (3rd September 2007) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/glasgow_and_west/6976651.stm [6th April 2009]
South Africa Investigates Aids Discrimination Charges (17th August 2000) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/885117.stm [6th April 2009]
UK Police to be 'Tested' for Corruption (27th November 1998) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/223447.stm [6th April 2009]
Soldiers Sacked Over Drug (26th August 2008) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk/7582005.stm [7th April 2009]
Health Drug Users 'do better at work' (5th November 1999) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/506074.stm [7th April 2009]
What Your Writing Says About You (27th August 2001) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/1505903.stm [7th April 2009]
Bosses Still Ask Banned Questions (14th January 2008) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/7187032.stm [15th April 2009]
Male Mechanic Wins Sex Discrimination Cases (20th November 2001) - http://www.hrmguide.co.uk/diversity/male_mechanic.htm [15th April 2009]
Long-Serving Police Officer Wins Disability Discrimination Claim (9th November 2007) - http://www.rjw.co.uk/news-events/press/long-serving-police-officer-wins-disability-discrimination-claim [15th April 2009]
Employee Wins Age Discrimination Cases (15th November 2007) - http://www.caterersearch.com/Articles/2007/11/15/317291/employee-wins-age-discrimination-case.html [15th April 2009]
BA Pilot Wins Discrimination Case (22nd April 2005) - http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/dorset/4471851.stm [15th April 2009]
HREOC Launches New Guidelines on Criminal Record Discrimination in the Workplace (11th November 2005) - http://www.hr-topics.com/australia/criminal-record-discrimination.htm [29th April 2009]
Recruitment Minefield (18th October 2006) - http://business.timesonline.co.uk/tol/business/entrepreneur/article604935.ece [30th April 2009]
If you are the original writer of this essay and no longer wish to have the essay published on the UK Essays website then please click on the link below to request removal: