This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.
The Galápagos Islands, off the coast of Ecuador, are in an oceanic transition zone between the central and eastern equatorial Pacific. The islands are directly affected by both weak and strong El Nino events, whether the warm water initially forms in the central Pacific and moves toward the east coast of Ecuador and Peru, or whether it form along the coastal area and movers toward the central Pacific.
In 1983, the meteorological station of the Charles Darwin Research Station (CDRS) recorded the total precipitation for 1983 was 2768.7mm (Glynn, 1990). This is compared with normal years in which measurable precipitation averages 361 mm (excluding values from 1983, 1997-98). On the other hand, the total precipitation for El Niño 97-98 was also unusually high (3407.6mm). Figure 1 shows the notable peak which occurred in 1983, during which El Niño reached its greatest intensity.
Figure 1. Annual precipitation measured at the Charles Darwin Research Station (CDRS), 1965 - 2010. Source: CDRS (2011)
The mean monthly sea surface temperature measured by the same station reached 28.6 Celsius in the mouth of March 1983 compared to normal years in which the mean temperature of this month is 23.3 Celsius (excluding values from 1982-83, 1997-98). Figure 2 displays mean annual sea surface temperatures observed at the CDRS between 1965 and 2010. The peak observed in 1983 and 1997 is clearly visible and 1997's is the highest mean annual sea temperature observed during 55 years of observations. Figure 3 shows the changes in mean annual air temperature observed at the CDRS. Again, high temperatures peaked in 1998 (or 1983), when the annual mean was 23.8 Celsius, compared with an average annual mean of 23.8 Celsius in normal years (excluding values from 1982-83, 1997-98).
Figure 2. Mean annual sea surface temperature measured at the CDRS, 1965 - 2010. Source: CDRS (2010)
Figure 2. Mean annual air temperature measured at the CDRS, 1965 - 2010. Source: CDRS (2010)
El Niño in 1982 - 83
The El Niño of 1982-83 brought changes that in certain cases can still be observed by CDRS and some researchers. The following paragraphs detail some of these changes.
Some visitor sites in Galápagos National Park became inaccessible due to the exuberant growth of vegetation, the destruction of paths and the lack of safety at landing sites (Smith, 1999). Additional factors such as an increase in populations of the stinging little fire ant (Wasmannia auropunctata).
The fauna of Galápagos was affected in various ways be the El Niño event of 1982-83. Some birds and marine mammals, as well as marine iguanas, suffered visible decreases in their populations (Gibbs et al, 1987; Toepfer, 2007). According to Toepfer (2007), it is principally due to the following factors: (i) mortality, especially caused by the absence of food and by increased incidence of illness; (ii) reproductive failure, probably related to lack of food; (iii) displacement to other locations. The effect was particularly notable in the colonies of blue-footed boobies (Sula nebouxii) on Española Island, in the populations of endemic flightless cormorants (Nannopterum harrisi) and Galápagos penguins (Spheniscus mendiculus), as well as in the populations of marine iguanas (Amblyrhyncus cristatus) throughout the archipelago (Gibbs et al, 1987).
Immediate effects were noted in the vegetation of the Galápagos Islands, where plant populations exploded in normally arid areas and demonstrated unusually rapid and exuberant growth in the highlands of some islands (Smith, 1999; Holmgren et al, 2001). Research carried out in the months following the end of the 1982-83 El Niño event showed that the abundance and distribution of various species of plants than on their numbers; the conclusions of these studies indicated that no long-term effects were expected in some species (Smith, 1999). However, there would be alterations in the type of vegetation in certain ecosystems.
Changes in the vegetation varied according to the life zone and type of plants present. Generally, species of the arid zones reacted with much greater speed to the abundance of rainfall. Herbs and climbing plants particularly took advantage of this new resource and expanded very rapidly (Smith, 1999). Similarly, enhanced germination occurred in seeds that had apparently been dormant in the soil for several months or years (Smith, 1999). Based on the research of Smith (1999), notable mortality occurred among adult individuals of the giant cacti in the genus Opuntia, as well as large Scalesia trees, which could not support their weight when their roots rotted due to excessive rainfall. As a result of accelerated growth rates measured by Holmgren et al (2001), plants in the most humid zones were less sensitive to increased precipitation than were plants in the arid. As in the arid zones, those humid zone species that benefited most from increased precipitation were herbs and climbers. Again, Scalesia was the genus that suffered greatest mortality of adult individuals.
During the 1982 - 83 El Niño event, observers noted increased abundance of introduced organisms that depend on the quantity of precipitation, such as the little fire ant Wasmannia auropunctata (Wetterer et al, 2003). The little fire ant demonstrated a particularly elevated rate of expansion, moving north on Santa Cruz Island at the rate of approximately 0.5km per year. Besides, the number of introduced rat (Rattus rattus) increased markedly in areas of the islands populated by humans (Abdelkrim, 2005).
Scientists have identified five regions in the equatorial Pacific that they consider to be worthy of special attention with regard to the observations and monitoring of El Niño processes. Their locations are shown in Figure AAA. Researchers are increasingly focusing on environmental changes in the Niño3.4 region in order to identify the onset of an El Niño event. Each region provides different kinds of information about either El Niño or the Southern Oscillation.
Figure AAA. Map depicting four regions in the equatorial Pacific Ocean identified as important locations for monitoring the wind and sea surface temperature changes associated with the El Niño process. Source: Australian Government Bureau of Meteorology (2011).
Niño1 is the region of coastal upwelling off the coasts of Peru and Ecuador. It is sensitive to changes in the ocean and the atmosphere, both seasonally and especially during El Niño episodes. Coastal upwelling processes in Niño1 are particularly sensitive to changes in air-sea interaction in the central and eastern equatorial Pacific.
Niño2 represents the Galapagos Islands region of the equatorial Pacific. Equatorial upwelling processes in this area are also sensitive to seasonal, as well as El Niño-induced, changes in the marine environment. Niño2 is a transition zone between the central and eastern equatorial Pacific, sensitive to changes in either Niño1 and Niño3, or both.
Niño3 is in the central equatorial Pacific, where there is a large El Niño signal but not much sensitivity to seasonal changes in air-sea interaction. It is in this region where information on changes in surface wind has been used by Mark Cane and Stephen Zebiak to project the likely onset to El Niño events. According to Cane (1991), "a warming in this region is thought to influence the global atmosphere strongly. It is probably the best single indicator of an ENSO episode likely to affect global climate".
Niño3.4 is relatively new region in the tropical Pacific increasingly used by more researchers to correlate changes in sea surface temperatures and surface winds there to climatic anomalies around the globe. Many researchers now use changes in Niño3.4 instead of Niño3 in their El Niño forecast modeling activities. It overlaps the Niño3 and Niño4 regions, as shown in Figure AAA.
Niño4 encompasses part of the western equatorial Pacific known as the warm pool. Here, sea surface temperatures are the highest in the Pacific. During an El Niño event, there is a relatively small change in sea surface temperatures (cooling). However, that small change is important, because the warmest water at the ocean's surface and the cloud producing processes that tend to follow it move away from the western Pacific toward the central and eastern Pacific. Hence during El Niño there are dry conditions in several countries in the western Pacific and very wet conditions in northern Peru and southern Ecuador.
Australia has suffered severe droughts in its northern and eastern regions during many El Niño years. These droughts have reduced crop yields, killed livestock, eroded soils and encouraged destructive bush fires.
El Niño event of 1982-83 coincided with a drought that may have been the worst for 100 years. The 1982 winter rains (June - September) failed over the south-eastern grain and pasture areas of Australia. In northern New South Wales and southern Queensland, the summer rains (December 1982 - February 1983) also failed.
The American Heritage dictionary defines an anomaly as a deviation from the normal order and as something unusual or irregular. El Niño is an anomaly in terms of changes in sea surface temperatures and in sea level pressure. The 1982-83 El Niño can, therefore, be described as an anomalous anomaly. In addition to being unusual, it is considered by the scientific community to be the most extreme this century.
The sea surface temperatures associated with this El Niño were way above normal in the central and eastern equatorial Pacific (reaching 4 degree Celsius or more above normal in some areas). Those concerned about natural disasters and their socioeconomic impacts also considered it to have been a very extreme event, because of numerous destructive climate anomalies that occurred around the world at the time. In the wake of this particular El Niño event, many world leaders, the public, and the media, for the first time, were forced to pay more consistent attention to this phenomenon.
In 1982, several months prior to the onset of the 1982-83 El Niño, some researchers published an article on what they considered the "typical" El Niño. The canonical El Nino, as they called it, was in fact a composite of the features of several El Niño events that took place from the early 1950s to the late 1970s. Until then, it appeared that El Niño events had generally followed a similar pattern of growth and development from onset to decay. In less than a year, however, that notion was challenged with the occurrence of an unexpected out of phase onset of the 1982-83 event. According to Harrison and Cane,
"The warm event in the Pacific in 1982-83 was unusual in many respects. Rather than exhibiting surface warming first along the northeast coast of South America in the spring, sea surface temperatures first significantly exceeded climatological values along the equator in the eastern central Pacific during late summer."
(Harrison and Cane, 1984, p.21)
In addition, Rasmusson and Arkin (1985), in reviewing what had happened in 1982-83, wrote that the timing of the warming of water in the central Pacific was typical and that the warming along the Peruvian coast followed instead of preceded that warming. In any event, the coastal warming occurred at the normal time of the year.
The 1982-83 El Niño differed in both timing and location from the set of post-World War II events used to compile the characteristics of a "typical" event. For example, anomalously warm sea surface temperatures appeared first in the central Pacific instead of off the coast of Peru. The warm sea surface temperatures moved eastward toward the South American coast, instead of first appearing along the coast and then moving in a westward direction away from it. It emerged later in the year (between June and August) than the expected typical El Niño. The winds along the Peruvian coast did not weaken as expected when the El Niño began, even though a weakening of the westward flowing winds was considered to be a necessary, although not sufficient, condition to spark El Niño's onset.
Case study - Peru
The waters along the coasts of Peru, Ecuador and northern Chile are normally some of the most productive in the world. Nutrient-rich currents rising from the sea-bed support vast populations of microscopic plankton, which in turn provide food for fish and other wildlife. The system is delicately balanced, with dead plankton falling to the sea floor and decaying to provide the nutrients for future upwellings. During an El Niño, plankton populations drop dramatically, disrupting the food chain and leading to starvation among marine life forms. Over the past 40 years, two of the major industries of Chile and Peru, fertilizer and fishing have been directly affected by these changes.
In the first half of this century, fertilizer made from the droppings of guano sea birds living on off shore islands was central to the Peruvian economy. The sea birds fed on anchoveta fish. Guano fertilizer was exported in bulk, and used domestically to improve crop yields. The changes I sea conditions caused by the 1957-58 El Niño led to a massive drop in anchoveta numbers. Millions of guano birds starved to death and their number dropped from 30 million to 16 million. A few years later, Peru began to expand its anchoveta fishing industry. Competition from fishermen for the anchoveta and stresses caused by El Niño caused a further decline in the number of guano birds and ended the dominance of the guano fertilizer industry in Peru.
The fishing industry continued to grow and, by the late 1960s, Peru had become the world's leading fishing nation by weight of catch, with anchoveta making up the bulk. By 1970, 1400 modern boats were bringing in 14 million tonnes of anchoveta a year, one-fifth of the world fish catch. However, the 1972-73 El Niño devastated the Peruvian anchoveta fishing industry and brought the El Niño phenomenon onto the world stage for the first time. During the onset of the 1972-73 El Niño, the warming of the Pacific coastal waters drove large numbers of anchoveta close to the shore
Interest in the impacts of the El Niño phenomenon, as such, goes back at least to the middle decades of the 1800s. At that time, its adverse effects on the guano birds (i.e. seabirds such as cormorants, gannets and pelicans) and on guano production (bird droppings used as a fertilizer for agriculture) had already been observed. Guano deposits that had built up over millennia were "mined" along the Peruvian coast throughout the second half of the nineteenth century, despite the decline in European demand for it. By 1900, Peruvian authorities were alarmed that this valuable export commodity (guano) was being mined at an alarming and unsustainable rate, that it was being mined at a rate faster than it was being produced. As a result, in the first decade of the twentieth century, the Peruvian government established a Guano Administration Company to oversee the protection of the guano bird population and to control the mining of guano (Figure 3.1 and 3.2).
Guano birds along the Peruvian coast live off of the fish populations that dwell near the ocean's surface (these are called pelagic fish), primarily the anchoveta, which is a fish of anchovy family. The cold oceanic conditions in Peru's coastal waters were usually optimal for anchoveta populations but are occasionally perturbed by El Niño. El Niño-related changes in physical, biological and social conditions can be devastating for the anchoveta, and in turn to seabird populations. Some of these processes are described briefly in the following paragraphs.
The rotation of the earth, combined with the winds that tend to blow toward the equator and offshore up the west coast of South America, pushes coastal surface water westward away from the continent and toward the central Pacific. As a result, cold water is drawn up from the ocean's depths to replace the warmer displaced surface water. This process is referred to as coastal upwelling. Coastal upwelling processes create regions in the ocean that are biologically highly productive oases (Figure 3.3).
The upwelling of deep cold ocean water brings a variety of chemicals in to the sumlit later near the ocaen's surface. They are converted through photosynthesis to nutrients for phytoplankton which are at the bottom of the marine food chain. The plants are eaten by zooplankton and fish populations, which in turn are consumed by guano birds.
The coastal upwelling phenomenon usually occurs along the western coasts of continents in both the Northern and Southern Hemispheres. Coastal upwelling regions from around the globe make up about 0.1% or the ocean's surface area but provide around 40% of all the commercial fish captured globally. The cold water that upwells along the coast tends to suppress rain-producing processes in the atmosphere and as a result, upwelling regions are usually found adjacent to coastal deserts. So, although coastal deserts appear to be harsh and barren environments from a societal perspective, the productivity that they did not get on land they found in their adjacent coastal waters. The location of major coastal upwelling regions are shown in Figure 3.4.
Biological productivity in the marine environment can be measured in terms of fixation of carbon by photosynthesis. The productivity of an upwelling ecosystem is measured in part by the amount of nutrients that is brought into the sunlit layer near the surface. According to David Cushing (1982),
"Each upwelling region moves poleward as spring gives way to summer and each is two or three hundred kilometers broad in biological terms, even if the prominent physical processes are confined to a band within about 50 km of the coast." (Cushing, 1982)
Of these highly productive marine ecosystems, Peru's is considered to be one of the best not only in terms of the rate of fixation of carbon but of tonnage of fish caught as well (mostly anchoveta during non El Niño periods). Before 1960, Peru was not noted for its commercial fishing activities, even though its commercial fish catches had doubled each year in the 1950s. However, from the mid-1960s to the first couple of years of the 1970s, it had become the world's number one fishing nation.
When El Niño events occur, coastal upwelling processes in the eastern Pacific are altered to such an extent that behavior within and among species becomes modified in major ways. Anchoveta, for example, disperse and migrate as well as dwell deeper in the ocean. Patterns of reproduction and migration change for the various fish species, with some reproducing less in the temporarily altered marine environment. Warm water species temporarily invade the waters of the western equatorial Pacific. Some fish populations such as sardines fare well in the new but temporary warm surface water environment. More specific to Peruvian interests, the standing stock of anchoveta becomes reduced for a variety of reasons, including higher mortality and lower fertility.
As a result of changes in the behavior of the anchoveta, the fish population becomes much less accessible to the guano birds, which causes the starvation and death of hundreds of thousands to millions of birds, depending on the magnitude and intensity of the particular El Niño episode. Figure 3.6 provides an example of the adverse impacts on Peruvian guano birds of the combination of El Niño events and heavy commercial fishing pressures over the span of a few decades.
The Guano Administration Company, created in 1909 by the Peruvian government to manage the guano resource, and its main supporters among the Peruvian agricultural elite managed for many decades to block the development of large scale commercial anchoveta fishing ventures. Apparently, they were able to argue successfully within the nation's highest political circles that there were not enough fish in Peru's coastal waters to sustain both a viable guano-mining industry and a viable anchoveta fishing sector. Birds and fishermen would be competing for the same resources in order to "survive". It is important to note that the Peruvian anchoveta captured by humans. They were caught to be processed into fishmeal for use as an animal feed supplement for export primarily to the rapidly expanding North American poultry industry. The anchoveta was also a source of fish oil for Peru's domestic market.
In the early 1950s, however, the enterprisers interested in developing a Peruvian commercial fishery finally convinced politicians at the time to allow them to establish a commercial fishing industry, winning out over those who opposed its development. The arguments of Peruvian investors
The primary methods used to forecast the impacts of a La Niña event are (A) computer modeling or (B) quantitative or qualitative analyses of past La Niña events and their environmental and societal impacts. These are the approaches of choice by scientists to identify the possible consequences of an ENSO extreme cold or warm event. However, less scientific ways to get the impacts that a La Niña might bring to a given region include projections based on what is likely not to occur under La Niña or normal tropical Pacific sea surface temperature conditions. One could identify El Niño teleconnections considered to be very reliable and then assume that, in the absence of an El Niño, there would be a much lower chance for those El Niño-related anomalies to occur.
For example, the El Niño-associated extreme drought situations in Indonesia, Papua New Guinea and in Australia or the forest fires in Borneo (Indonesia) are much less likely to occur during a La Niña event. So while one might not be able to forecast what will happen during a La Niña event, one can identify what is less likely to happen in some location during La Niña. Here are some examples:
Northern Brazil is less likely to have a drought
Southern Brazil, Uruguay and Argentina are less likely to receive good rains for crop production.
Southern Africa is not likely to have a severe regional drought
East Africa is not likely to have severe flooding
Indonesia, Philippines, Papua New Guinea and Malaysia are likely to have average to above average rainfall
Indonesia is less likely to suffer from uncontrollable tropical fires
Central Chile is not likely suffer flooding
Strong, nutrient-rich coastal upwelling and arid conditions would reappear along the Peruvian coast
The Atlantic hurricane season will become more active
India's monsoon is less likely to fail
Precipitation in the southern part of China is less likely to be excessive
While the mere mention of the possible onset of a La Niña can spark reactions from decision makers in various countries or corporations where those decision makers believe that there is a strong La Niña impact, it is important to keep in mind that: Firstly, a sharp drop in sea surface temperatures in the tropical Pacific as happened in 1998 does not assure that a strong La Niña will follow; Secondly, a La Niña does not always follow an El Niño; Thirdly, La Niña events vary in intensity (weak, moderate, strong and very strong) and that each level of intensity generates its own set of world-wide teleconnections.
El Niño and the Walker Circulation
During an El Niño event, the Walker Circulation becomes modified in a major way. The westward flowing surface winds across the equatorial Pacific basin weaken and in the western part of the basin they reverse and flow eastward. This enables water in the warm pool in the west to spread eastwaed.as the warm water shifts eastward, the sea level in the east increases. With the slowing down of the westward winds, the surface waters of the central and eastern Pacific become warmer. As this occurs, the thermocline also begins to shift, moving upward toward the ocean's surface in the west and deepening in the central and eastern equatorial Pacific. As the thermocline moves downward along the Peruvian coast, upwelling continues but the water brought up to the surface is warmer and less rich in nutrients (Figure 5.4b, p.70).
Meanwhile, the water in the western equatorial Pacific becomes a few degrees cooler, as the surface and subsurface waters in the central and eastern Pacific warm up. Because convective activity (cloud formation) follows the sea's warm surface water, clouds increase in the central and eastern Pacific, while they decline in the west. This displacement in convective activity generates droughts in Australia, Papua New Guinea and Indonesia, typhoons in the central Pacific, and heavy rains along the normally arid coast of northern Peru. These conditions can last from 12 to 18 mouths, until the westward flowing surface winds once again begin to strengthen, causing warm water to flow back toward to the region of the western Pacific warm pool. The sea levels at both ends of the basin begin to change direction now rising in the west and falling in the east, as does the depth of the very important but out of sight thermocline. Strong upwelling returns to the equator and to the eastern Pacific boundary of coastal Peru.
Figure 4.2a,b summarizes the west-to-east interaction between the atmosphere and the ocean in the equatorial Pacific under normal conditions and under El Niño conditions. The precise timing of the beginning of any particular El Niño event may not be well known, although there are several hypotheses about how to detect it. Once started, however, the processes that keep El Niño going, as well as the processes that end it, appear to be better idea some months in advance about its potential impacts on some ecosystems and societies around the globe. This was the case for the 1997-98 event. Even though forecasters missed forecasting its onset, they were relatively more successful in identifying some of its worldwide impacts.
Weather and climate variability
Every year around the world, there are extreme climate-related issues with droughts occurring in some places and floods in others. The summer of 1988 witnessed a severe drought on the agricultural heartland of North America, meanwhile an extremely low stream flow in the basin of the Mississippi River. A few years later, in the summer of 1993, a period of rainstorm led to major flooding along the upper Mississippi and lower Missouri River and many of their tributaries in the United States (Figure 1.1).
Figure 1.1 Great flood along Mississippi River, USA, 1993. Source: NASA (2005).
In early 1990s, newspaper headlines announced that drought-related food shortages in southern Africa put about 80 million Africans at risk of famine. In August 1992, Hurricane Andrew destroyed southern Florida leaving an estimated US$30 billion in destruction. In early 1995, extreme flooding occurred in western Europe, that shaking the confidence of countries such as the Netherlands in their ability to prevent natural catastrophes, and challenging their false belief that scientific and technological developments had buffered their societies from the consequences of such periods of extremely heavy rainfall (Annamalai, 2007).
Despite the fact that climate fluctuates on seasonal, annual, decadal, century and even longer time scales, in some years there are many extreme meteorological events and resulting in societal problems, such as droughts, floods, fires, frosts, ice storms or blizzards. One such period was 1972-73, when severe droughts occurred in widely dispersed locations such as Australia and Indonesia, Brazil and Central America, India and in parts of sub-Saharan Africa, at the same time, heavy flooding occurred in Kenya, southern Brazil, and parts of Ecuador and Peru (Roberts, 2009). At the time it was suggested that some of these widely dispersed climatic extremes might have a common geographic origin in changes in sea surface temperatures in the tropical Pacific Ocean (El Niño or EN), and changes in atmospheric pressure at sea level across the Pacific basin (Southern Oscillation or SO). These combined changes have come to be commonly referred to as El Niño events in the popular media and as ENSO (El Niño Southern Oscillation) events in much of the scientific literature.
Very briefly, an El Niño event can be described as the appearance from time to time of warm sea surface water in the central and eastern Pacific Ocean near the equator. Folklore suggests that the term "El Niño" was used by Peruvian sailors and fishermen as a label for the annual appearance of warm water along the western coast of their country by December of each year. In some years, the warming along the coast did not dissipate within few months but lingered for more than a year (Kumar, 1997). This was also called "El Niño". In recent decades, the term "El Niño" has been broadened to include all kinds of anomalous sea surface warming in the equatorial Pacific. Scientists now believe that El Niño events are associated with many anomalous weather extremes around the globe.
ENSO and worldwide climate
The associations or linkages between El Niño events and unusual changes (called anomalies) in normal climate patterns around the globe have been referred to as "Teleconnections" (Bell, 2009). These include known, as well as perceived, connections between ElNiño events and changes in distant weather or climate-related processes. For example, there appears to be an association between El Niño events and droughts in various parts of the globe: north Australia, southeastern Africa, northeast Brazil, parts of India, central America and so forth. There also appear to be linkages between El Niño events and a reduced number of tropical hurricanes occurring in a given tear along the east coast of the USA as well as in the locations of tropical cyclones off the east coast of Australia, where they tend to shift equatorward by several hundred kilometers.
THE SCIENTIFIC BACKGROUND OF ENSO
The importance of upwellings
Upwelling has a profound effect on ocean temperatures and life along coastlines. As the ocean temperatures decrease with depth, therefore, upwelling brings cold water to the surface, and this water is rich in nutrient. These nutrients are an important food source for marine organisms living near the surface. These organisms, in turn, area a source of food for fish and birds, and millions of people across the world depend upon the abundance of life in and near regions of upwelling ceases because of a change in wind patterns, the result can be catastrophic for coastal regions. One example of this, which turns out to have implications for weather and climate worldwide, is El Niño.
AIMS & OBJECTIVES
Aims: To find out the potential environmental and economic impacts of El Niño Southern Oscillation
Objectives: 1. Assessment of historical impact of ENSO
2. Assessment of current situation
3. Potential impacts of future ENSO events
Impacts associated with the 1982-83 El Niño
Most of the major weather anomalies occurring in 1982 and 1983 around the world, especially droughts and floods in the tropics, were linked by one observer or another to the occurrence of an El Niño. Several articles, maps, and charts relating to El Niño appeared in the popular press, suggesting the extent of the worldwide, continent-wide, national, and local impacts of this El Niño. Caution must be used, however, in attributing any particular anomaly or impact to a specific El Niño. Furthermore, the severity of societal impacts will vary according to the level of societal vulnerability to such extremes. Climate-related anomalies can also result from a variety of local and regional conditions, even in the absence of El Niño events. The following examples of the alleged societal impacts of the 1982-83 El Niño are taken from newspaper reports:
Indonesia was plagued with severe drought, resulting in reduced agricultural output (especially rice), famine, malnutrition, disease, and hundreds of deaths. This drought came at a bad time, in the sense that this country had been making great strides toward self-sufficiency in food production. In the few years immediately preceding the 1982-83 El Niño, Indonesia had begun to emerge as a rice exporter. This drought, however, coupled with worldwide recession, huge foreign debts, and declining oil revenues, set back Indonesia's economic development goals for the near term.
In 1982-83, Australia was in the midst of its worst drought this century up to that time. Agricultural and livestock losses, along with widespread bush fires mainly in the southeastern part of the country, resulted in billions of dollars of lost revenue. The El Niño exacerbated this situation. An Australian journalist wrote that the drought was not just a rural catastrophes, it was a national disaster.
The eastern part of the USA was favorably affected by its warmest winter in 25 years and the fewest hurricanes of the century up to this date. According to an estimate by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, energy savings were on the order of US $500 million. (The opposite was the case, however, during the cold winter that accompanied the 1976-77 El Niño.) Also in 1982-83, the USA was adversely affected by devastating coastal storms and mudslides along the southern California coast, flooding in the states, reducing corn and soybean production. Salmon harvests along the United States Pacific Northwest coast were also down sharply due to reduced coastal upwelling and a general warming of the ocean's water, which pushed salmon populations further north into Canadian waters and into the hands of Canadian fishermen.
South America experienced many and varied impacts. In addition to the highly publicized damage to infrastructure such as roads, railroads, and bridges, and agricultural production in Peru and Ecuador as a result of heavy flooding during the 1982-83 El Niño, there were severe droughts in southern Peru and Bolivia. A major drought continued in Northeast Brazil, adversely affecting food production, human health, and the environment. The drought prompted migration out of the region into the Amazon and into the already crowded cities along the coast and to the south. There were also destructive floods in southern Brazil, northern Argentina, and Paraguay.
Large expanses of Africa were affected by drought. For example, the West African Sahel was, once again, plagued by a major drought. Although the human and livestock deaths resulting from this drought appeared to be lower than those that occurred during the 1972-73 El Niño, the situation with food production was considered extremely poor. The view that the Sahel was in the midst of a long term trend of below average rainfall that began in 1968 gained some credibility.
Southern Africa has witnessed some of its worst droughts, including that of 1982-83, during this century. For example, in 1983 the Republic of South Africa, a major grain producer in the region, was forced to import about 1.5 million tonnes of corn from the USA to replace what was lost in their drought. Zimbabwe, a regional supplier of food, was also devastated by drought and was forced to appeal for food assistance from the international community. Likewise Botswana, Mozambique, Angola, Lesotho, and Zambia, and the so-called Black National Homelands in the Republic of South Africa had their economies devastated by the drought of 1982-83.
In addition to these impacts, the El Niño of 1982-83 was blamed for droughts in Sri Lanka, the Philippines, southern India, Mexico, and even Hawaii, along with severe, unseasonal typhoons in French Polynesia and Hawaii. It was also credited with having a role in suppressing hurricane activity along the Atlantic seaboard. In 1983, many of these events were record-setting extremes: the worst typhoon, the most intense rainfall, the warmest winter, the longest drought, and the fewest hurricanes making landfall on the eastern USA, all occurred in this year.
El Niño has also been associated with indirect societal and environmental effects. However, indirect effects are even more difficult to attribute to an El Niño, as they could be the result of other causes. In 1982-83, these effects tool the form of dust storms and bush fires in Australia, the Côte d'lvoire, and Ghana. In the USA, the 1982-83 event was blamed for such health effects as encephalitis outbreaks in the East (the result of a warm, wet spring providing the proper environment for mosquitos), and increase in rattle-snake bites in Montana (hot, dry conditions at higher elevations caused mice to search for food and water at more densely populated lower elevations; the rattlesnakes followed the mice), a record increase in the number of bubonic plague cases in New Mexico (as a result of a cool, wet spring that created favorable conditions for flea-bearing rodents), an increase in shark attacks off the coast of Oregon (because they followed the unseasonably warm sea temperatures). Even an increase in the incidence of spinal injuries along California's coast was blamed on El Niño (as a result of swimmers and surfers being unaware that the floor of the ocean along the coast gad bee changed as a result of the violent wave action that accompanied coastal storms).
There has been an overwhelming tendency to focus on the adverse impacts of El Niño on human activities. However, with regional shifts in temperature and precipitation, one can expect that some regions as well as some human activities will benefit from those shifts.
The impacts of La Niña
Researchers have created a rule is that the impact of La Niña are generally the opposite to those of El Niño. For example, droughts tend to accompany El Niño events in Australia, Indonesia and the Philippines, whereas heavy rains and flooding tend to accompany La Niña in these locations. Southern Africa tends to be drought-plagued during El Niño, but very wet during La Niña episodes. Figure 5 shows a correspondence between peaks in Multivariate ENSO Index (MEI) and annual mean rainfall at Australia.
Figure 5. Multivariate ENSO Index (MEI) and annual mean rainfall at Australia. Positive MEI value (>0.5) indicates an El Niño event, negative value (<-0.5) indicates a La Niña event. Source: Australian Government Bureau of Meteorology (2010).
The actual worldwide impacts of cold events depend on the intensity of particular La Niña. Some researchers have suggested that the 1988-89 La Niña was a strong one (Moon et al, 2003; Quan et al, 2004; Wheeler, 2008), while others have suggested that the 1988-89 La Niña was only moderate (Wang et al, 2007). Much more research needs to be done on how best to classify the intensity of La Niña events (or El Niña events). The composite maps shown in Figure 5.7a and b are produced by National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), provide a statistically based generalization of the potential impacts of ENSO cold extremes. By noting the months in which impacts are likely occur.
Which extremes can be blamed on El Niño or La Niña?
Societal contributions to atmospheric greenhouse gases through the burning of fossil fuels (coal, oil and natural gas, etc.), tropical deforestation and the use of fertilizer (NOx) and refrigerants (chlorofluorocarbons or CFCs), have been linked to a global warming of the atmosphere. In the summer of 1988, a major drought took place in the Midwest United States, which has since been referred to as the most expensive natural disaster in US history. Some researchers quickly blamed the severity of that drought on human-induced global warming, for example, James Hansen (1988) suggested that the effects of global warming on regional and local climates world become more frequent as well as more visible in the near future. The 1988 drought, he argued, was consistent with what one might expect from gobal warming. At that time, however, a hypothesis was proposed by atmospheric scientist Kevin Trenberth: the Midwest drought was a result of La Niña conditions in the equatorial Pacific (Linden, 1988).
Was the 1988 Midwest drought really produced by prevailing La Niña conditions thousands of kilometers away? If that were the case, then there would have been a good change that a major Midwest drought would accompany the 1998-2000 La Niña. However, can such a conclusion be made with confidence? While there is some evidence that a La Niña summer in North America is likely to be hotter and drier than normal, there is not enough hard evidence to make that fairly specific geographic teleconnection with certainty.
Care must be used in identifying previous La Niña (or El Niño) events that are to be used as analog years. Because there have been relatively few La Niña events in the past 60 years, we do not know the full range of ways that La Niña might affect regional climates indifferent parts of the world. Identifying a specific La Niña year from the historical record that might be considered to be similar to an impending La Niña year raises expectations about the increased likelihood of a repeat of the societal impacts that occurred during those previous years. If the selection of an analog year is wrong, however, then those expectations about potential damages world have been false expectations, because these damages are not likely to occur.
Identifying El Niño/La Niña years is very important for those who look for El Niño/La Niña analogs to forecast with some degree of reliability the impacts that might occur and to develop strategies to cope with the societal impacts of the ENSO cycle. There are long time series of sea surface temperature, sea level pressure, thermocline depth and outgoing long-wave radiation to identify the ENSO warm or cold events.