Social implication of controlling function of management accounting

Published: Last Edited:

This essay has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers.

Social implication of controlling function of management accounting.

Table of Contents


Social implications on management accounting

Social approach




In the study we have focussed on the control function of the management planning, which will be assessed on its social implications. Controlling entails making sure that execution does not diverge from benchmarks. Controlling comprises of three stages, which consist of

(1) Ascertaining performance yardsticks,

(2) Evaluating genuine performance in opposition to criterions, and

(3) Taking remedial stroke when essential.

Performance standards are generally assured in financial values like returns, expenditures, or incomes however may in addition be known in other idioms, like pieces manufactured, amount of faulty creations, or echelons of excellence or customer service.

Social implications on management accounting

As per Morgan and Buurrell, statements concerning human temperament denote the association among individuals and their surroundings. Individual’s behaviour and understandings can be observed as being entirely resolute and constricted by their exterior surroundings or, in contrast, persons can be sighted as being possibly self-directed and free-willed, plus proficient of generating their own surroundings.

in proportion to the contingency theory, the social effect of the organization is abstracted in terms of apparent ambiguity (Garengo & Bititci, 2007). The superior social ambiguity is additional complicated it is to shape the structure for effectual performance assessment and control function. There are social factors particular for meticulous categories of associations or industries that have an effect on the control function of management accounting (Rayburn, Rayburn, 1991). The social factor is described as having as a minimum two elements- stagnant/vibrant. These aspects demonstrate the extent to which the causes of the social remain essentially the equivalent over the period or are in a constant procedure of alteration (Rayburn, Rayburn, 1991). In brief it could be known that the contingency theory asserts that the efficiency of the organization is dependent in the lead of the constituents of a range of sub-systems and management accounting is one of those sub-systems, which has various functions, out of which controlling is one function of management.

The competence and efficacy of management accounting rely on to what stage it guarantees amount, estimate and response through the control functions and procedures of the organization. This constructs a fact that the social environment is the salient variable that influences management accounting. The social environment could be portrayed by the altitude of indecision. However the social characteristics could not be explicated by employing the contingency theory single-handedly as they moreover have an effect on management accounting ultimately by means of in-house associational aspects.

Social approach

The social approach to the functions of accounting considers the wide spectrum of the theorists. The common thread of their style of their theories is that the control function of management accounting can be socially formulated and also is helpful generating the social values. The accounting functions like control’s development is very significant to be left to vagaries of the market. Though it is necessary to know how society uses and provides information for the control function, therefore this approach asks for a declaration of the normative values on the basis of which the control function can be set. The social aspect of the management functions is concerned with the reason behind generation of accounting information.

The approach suggests that there are basic 2 principles:

  1. Solution for all the social issues that prevail in the control function of the business, require active participation and involvement.
  2. The level of measuring corporate benefits is not sufficient for a broader control function of the business, so it needs a better scheme to operate.

He followers of the social approach deem that all the control function managers need to disclose adequate information to ensure that the people (society) out of the business also get involved into the business functions. The control function of accounting possesses the potential to be socially useful regulation. So, the social implications must be given a consideration to how it can be optimally developed (Houchin and MacLean, 2005).

Let me consider a control function of a business like budgeting, it is both a planning as well as a control tool:

-The level of prominence on fulfilling the budget - i.e., the level to which the assessment of professional performance is first and foremost based upon the business-unit executives' ability to frequently convene the budget on a short- term basis

-The total of information aspect needed for budget controls - i.e., the degree to which subordinates are obligatory to give in statements that converse performance-to-engagement, recognize discrepancies and suggest comprehensive counteractive actions if it emerges that the budget objectives are not being fulfilled

-The power of budget-related infrastructures - i.e., the level to which budgets are employed to make easy information swaps right the way through the organization and society to force investigation and contest, and to lend a hand to corporate administrators to individually engross themselves in the management and controlling activities of their business-entity executives (Simons, 1995).

In accumulation, three characteristics of financial inducements that are attached to budget accomplishment are deemed (Gupta and Govindarajan, 1986):

  1. the scope to which the business-entity supervisor's reimbursement is performance reliant (bonus opposed to fixed earnings
  2. How the bonus is resolute (considered by employing a modus operandi tying the bonus to budget-founded performance or by employing prejudice or prudence in assessing performance or tying it to pay off employees); and
  3. what the bonus is founded on (business-entity performance in opposition to corporate performance).

Per se, the pronouncements recommend that control over foreign business entities is less demanding with regard to the sum of time and endeavour spent on talking about controlling matters. Furthermore, the dividends of administrators in command of the overseas entities depend further on stern modus operandi, as deviating to being unrestricted. These effects could be made clear, in some measure, by environmental detachment. On the other hand, the countrywide social measurements disclose that business-element administrators in elevated-authority detachment or high indecision prevention societies disregard (or search for) more intrusion by corporate administration in business-entity controlling concerns. Quite the reverse, controlling processes materialize to be additional unrestrictive when compacting with administrators in unusual social civilizations. At the end of the day, the consequences put forward that control aloofness too shapes the quantity of prudence that can be employed in bonus fortitude.

The project administration employs accounting information from various social sources. Understanding of project explanations is usually not uncomplicated awaiting a plan is concluded, and then it is excessively delayed to control project organization. Yet following achievement of a development plan, the accounting outcomes might create a lot of confusion in the society. So it is evident for the management to be acquainted with the ways to interpret the accounting information for the control of the organisation. In the procedure of bearing in mind management troubles, on the other hand,

The partial object of task control is worthy of prominence. Business control practices are first and foremost be determined to recognize divergences from the organisation plan more willingly than to put forward probable regions for cost reductions. This feature shows the highly developed level where the control aspect is vital. The phases for achievement of maximum cost reductions, planning and design phases are vital. However social factors like tax, financial and economic policies of the country, business approvals etc delay the planned/designed operations of the business. This leads to increase in the actual cost, as in comparison to the planned one. So, the role of control function is fulfilment of the original design plan and also showing the divergences from the planned/ designed activities. There is no need to search for further plans or cost savings, rather the firm can look into social implications that have lead to these deviations. Control function is all about knowing the causes of deviations, if any. It is only when the rescue function is needed, that he main alterations will usually take place in the plan.

Ultimately, the concerns connected with incorporation of information will necessitate some conversations in the community. The organisational control performances and purposeful worries are confidentially concurrent, however the procedures utilised in a lot of examples do not make easy all-inclusive or incorporated contemplation of management activities. For instance, an agenda information as well as cost account is more often than not held in reserve independently. As a consequence, project controllers themselves have to create a wide-ranging outlook from the diverse statements on the plan plus their own pitch surveillances. In meticulous, the controllers are over and over again compelled by the society to conjecture the cost blows of programme transforms, more willingly than being afforded with supports for this progression. Communication or incorporation of a variety of types of information from all aspects of society can provide several constructive principles, even though it does need extraordinary consideration in the organization of project control methods.

A budding business meets head-on not only an in-house alteration, but furthermore increasing social complexity (Merchant, Chow and Wu, 1995). Consequently, managers and controllers of premature-phase businesses commence official organization control systems, which are “prescribed (on paper and consistent) information-based course of actions and accounts, utilised by the controllers to scrutinize and persuade the performance plus activities in a business.” (Sondergaard, 1994) Such management control systems facilitate managers not simply to deal with with ever-increasing information necessitates, but moreover keeping away from loss of control as of lack of scrutinizing (Modern, 1995). On the other hand, management control systems are expensive and prolonged to establish and work. As an end result, premature-phase businesses are probable to decide their primary set of management control system discriminatingly.

One more example of social implications is combining the overseas business entities into one faction grounds the group of overseas trade units to be non-harmonized, which may blow up its nationwide society discrepancy. Hence, noteworthy disparities in the management control system variables sandwiched between the restricted and overseas clusters have to be construed with vigilance for the reason that they may be counterfeit (sourced by inconsistency increase) and not easy to construe (for the reason that they pertain to an standard society of the distant cluster of business entities). Nevertheless, at face value, the judgment that control function issues are handled more rigorously with home business entities than with distant business entities without doubt appears reasonable (Fowler, 2009).

While the social aspects have a tendency to argue for an “improved” employing of control functions within the society so that the society can be enhanced, the critical theories observe the control function as one of the reasons behind a lot of issues that we encounter within the society so that the society and analyses the requirement for control function in its present (or in fact any) structure.

Consistent with the contingency theory, the social setting of the organization is abstracted in vocabulary of professed uncertainty. The immense social indecision is extra complicated it is to build up the structure for successful performance control function. There are social aspects explicit for meticulous forms of businesses or industries that have an effect on the control function of management accounting (Rayburn, Rayburn, 1991).


Associations look forward to control the atmosphere when it performs in an inappropriate manner and clashes with procedures in business (Burnes, 2005). Complication learning exposed that associations vigorously act in response to the environment and are truly ingredient of the procedure that produces that environment. It auxiliary exposed that complication results in associational arrangements, performance management system (PMS) being one of them, their expected response – to make things easier or suck up the ecological impact.


  • Burnes, B. (2005a). Complexity theories and orga- nizational change. International Journal of Manage- ment Reviews, 7 (2), 73–90.
  • Fowler, C. (2009). Performance management, budget- ing, and legitimacy-based change in educational or- ganizations. Journal of Accounting & Organizational Change, 5 (2), 168–196.
  • Garengo, P, Bititci, U. (2007). Towards a contingen- cy approach to performance measurement: an empir- ical study in Scottish SMEs. International Journal of Operations & Production Management, 27 (8), 802– 825.
  • Gupta, A. K. and Govindarajan, V (1986) 'Resource sharing among SBUs: strategic antecedents and administrative implications'. Academy of Management Journal, 29(4): 695-714.
  • Houchin, K., MacLean, D. (2005). Complexity The- ory and Strategic Change: an Empirically Informed Critique. British Journal of Management, 16, 149– 166.
  • Merchant, K. A., Chow, C. W. and Wu, A. (1995) 'Measurement, evaluation, and reward of profit center managers: a cross-cultural field study'. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 20(7/8): 619-38.
  • Morden, T (1995) 'International culture and management'. Management Decision, 33(2): 16-21.
  • Rayburn, J. M., Rayburn, L. G. (1991). Contingency theory and the impact of New Accounting Technology in uncertain hospital environments. Accounting Audit- ing and Accountability Journal, 4 (2), 55–75.
  • Simons, R. (1995) Levers of Control: How Managers Use Innovative Control Systems to Drive Strategic Renewal. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
  • Sondergaard, M. (1994) 'Hofstede's consequences: a study of reviews, citations and replications'. Organization Studies, 15(3): 447-56.