This dissertation has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional dissertation writers.
Chapter 1: Introduction
Outsourcing is one of the growth industries of our time (Winterton 2000). Today, the outsourcing of selected organisational activities is an integral part of corporate strategy (Lankford and Parsa 1999). Outsourcing has become a significant facet of modern hotel management (Sieburg 1992). Unfortunately there is shortage of prior research in the hospitality management literature concerning outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes in hotel sector.
This paper seeks to present critical analysis of factors, varieties, aims and results of outsourcing within hotel industry.
The first chapter will begin with stating the problem which is vital in hospitality industry. It will then continue with the presentation of background literature and the purpose of study. Thirdly, rationale will be explained. Subsequently research questions will be raised. Furthermore a definition of terms will identify the key words within the study and how the writer defines them within it. A number of limitations will indicate specific areas in which the research will not be definitive. Finally a summary of the chapter will be provided indicating the main points discussed.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Historically as the kind of contractual relations and commercial activity outsourcing has appeared in 1962 when the successful businessman Ross Perro, whose firm EDS carried out calculations for banks, renting night time on mainframes, has brought «General Motors» annual economy in 44 % - more than 4 billion dollars (Nureev 2002). Over the last few years, the idea of outsourcing noncore business functions has gained huge popularity (Winterton 2000). Nowadays different types and forms of outsourcing are putting into practice and developing in various businesses.
Tourism in its turn is a rapidly growing phenomenon and has become one of the largest industries in the world. But also hospitality industry is very unique, and very sensitive to every internal and external changes. And such innovation as outsourcing should have affect the industry in general and the development of hotel sector in particular.
As it has been mentioned above, outsourcing within hotel industry has been the subject of minimal literature research. And a question: whether outsourcing will work in hotels and make notable profit still opened for reasoning and conclusions. And if yes or no, how it will be affected by financial crisis which came less than year ago. Just that very case of crisis can cardinally change the relation of business to outsourcing. After all in a crisis situation it is more important not tactical, but the strategic part of the business.
In general, up to now the quantity of questions more than answers. And it is very important to understand, why hotels outsource. And what form for them is most attractive and far-sighted.
1.3 Background Literature
According to Lankford and Parsa (1999), outsourcing is defined as the procurement of products or services from sources that are external to the organisation. This leads to allowing outsiders to take responsibilities for some aspects of financial management (Winterton 2000). After definition and explanation of previous authors, it is possible to say that outsourcing is something similar to service and support services though it is differs essentially from them. It is not short-term service, on once, given by one company to another. Outsourcing gives longer support, not single. Outsourcing is transfer of certain processes or functions from one company to another. The Company - "recipient" should specialise in this branch. From here it is possible to create one of outsourcing's principles: «I leave to myself only that I can do better than others, I give to the external executor that it does better than others». Other principles and the most practical types and forms of outsourcing will be considered in second chapter.
Outsourcing has become an important strategic tool in today's competitive business environment (Zhu, Hsu and Lillie 2001). As any tool of business it has its own advantages and disadvantages.
Outsourcing offers several advantages, such as enabling existing staff to concentrate on core activities on organisational specialisations, focusing on achieving key strategic objectives, lowering or stabilising overhead costs, and thereby gaining cost advantage over the competition, providing flexibility in response to changing market conditions, and reducing investment in high technology (Kliem, 1999; Quinn 1999 cited Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. 2000). Thus it is possible to ear-mark three big advantages of outsourcing in general, not only for hotels and hospitality industry. The first advantage – outsourcing allows to pay almost all attention and resources to the core direction of the business and to charge to foreign company noncore functions. Thereby, company will have competitive advantage. Also redistribution and optimisation of human resources of the company will be possible. The second advantage is decreasing of material input. Very often attractions of the foreign executor essentially cheaper than the maintenance of own department for execution of certain job. It is caused by lower price cost of outsourcer's job since the chosen direction is its specific specialisation. And the third advantage – using outsourcing, companies can get technologies and the decisions of higher quality level which might be absent at the organisation. Besides this there is a possibility of using specialised functions which only experts can perform. Also it is important to remember about transfer of all responsibilities of the assigned functions to outsourcer.
But besides these pluses there are also some disadvantages of outsourcing. Schniederjans and Zuckweiler (2004) introduce very helpful summary of those. They suggested that it is possible to divide this lacks in four groups:
1) Managerial implications. Such as loss of control over critical functions and suppliers.
2) Financial implications. Such as failure to realise cost savings.
3) Operational implications. Such as dependence on suppliers and responsibility for quality of their work.
4) Human resource implications. Such as lower morale of permanent employees.
Thus after confrontation these disadvantages and meaning of the process it is possible to ear-mark one of the most important shortcoming of outsourcing. It is possible to criticise it for loss of workplaces. As the result of such process, the company can release many workplaces, replacing the in-house workers with more professional (or cheaper) from other company. As the result of this, first of all, workers are getting in the worst position because very often there is no labour contract or any guarantees about their future job between them and the employer.
Remembering all the minuses, lacks and disadvantages but aspiring to benefits, pluses and advantages of outsourcing hotels should understand the reasons, right time and business situation when to outsource. According to William and Faramanz (1999), firms should consider outsourcing when it is believed that certain support functions can be completed faster, cheaper, or better by an outside organisation. Tasks that are not core competencies of the hotel – human resources, payroll and benefits, information systems, even food service – are ripe for being contracted out. Moreover, Blake (1997) gave three main reasons for organisations for turning to outsourcing:
• Where others do it better
• To focus on their core business
• To reduce their cost base.
Therefore the hotels should use outsourcing to concentrate on the primary activity, instead of to be engaged in management of dining rooms, cleaners or catching of computer viruses. Another factor to exploit the outsourcing within hotel industry is the situation when the external provider of services is capable to provide economy and/or higher level of services because of specialisation or cheaper labour. Outsourcing can help to save resources of the hotel. One more not very visible objective to use outsourcing within hotels is to study from the service provider.
Consequently, Milgrom and Roberts (1992 cited Lamminmaki 2005) said that understanding hotels' motivation for outsourcing is important, as organisation is as important as technology, cost, and demand in determining success.
To conclude this part of the chapter, it is useful to remember statement of Kotler (1988): “Entrust others that what they will make easier and more cheaply”.
1.4 Purpose of Study
The purpose of this study was to examine factors that influence on hotel sector for outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes. By analysing existing studies related to outsourcing in general, it can be valuable in applying to the outsourcing within hotel sector where there is little research. In additional, there are few management accounting studies concerned with the hotel sector (Collier and Gregory 1995). Furthermore, the research will evaluate advantages and disadvantages of using outsourcing for hotels. This study will critically assess the innovative part of outsourcing for hotels and what type and form of internal business processes is going to be more successful for them.
Specifically, literature will be within the hospitality sector. Moreover, how will outsourcing affect costumers and their needs will be analysed. Finally, based on the findings of the study, solutions for the hotel sector will be provided.
This research is about outsourcing or internal business processes within hotel industry. And it is significant for several reasons:
1. Hospitality industry is one of the fastest developing industries. And In many countries, tourism industry is the leading industry, which stimulates development of other sectors.
2. Outsourcing – relatively new business idea but it has been used already in numerous sectors of economy including hospitality.
3. Using outsourcing or internal business processes hotels can cut their production cost.
4. There is a high potential to improve quality of hotel's services.
5. Most of the hotels have to find some new ideas for their development and reduction of risks during the financial crisis period. And outsourcing could be one of them.
1.6 Research Questions
This study aim is to answer following Research Questions:
1. What is considered ‘outsourcing process' within the hotel sector?
To begin with, it is vital for the research to explain and to make it clearer, what is outsourcing in today's economy. Also it is important to elucidate if this term is innovative method for the business or it is just a new expression of existing already processes within hotel sector.
2. What are the advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing for hotel sector?
As any type of business relationship, outsourcing should have not only advantages and positive moments but also disadvantages and obstacles. To be more objective, it is vital to compare both to be able to make a conclusion whether outsourcing is a big opportunity for the hotels or it will bring more difficulties rather than profitability.
In addition, it is significant to understand the specific type of action of outsourcing within hotels and its the most widespread forms
3. What are the factors for outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes within hotel sector?
Internal and external factors of using outsourcing for the hotels will be examined. And the research will emphasise specific reasons of starting using outsourcing within hotel industry. Moreover, ‘financial crisis' as one of the factors will be discussed.
4. What are the main aims of outsourcing within hotel sector?
And last but not least, it will be achievable to acquire the main aims and results of outsourcing within hotel sector.
Additionally, after analysing the interview and questionnaires, preferred types and the specific benefits from outsourcing for the hotels will be seen.
1.7 Definition of Terms
Core business: Core business means the commercial activity from which the company derives most of its profits (www.resourceconservation.mb.ca). According to Alexander and Yong (1996), there are four main points to define ‘core' activities:
Activities which traditionally performed in-house;
Activities which critical to business performance;
Activities which create current or potential competitive advantage;
Activities which will drive further growth, innovation, or rejuvenation.
Financial Crisis: There is no precise definition of "financial crisis," but a common view is that disruptions in financial markets rise to the level of a crisis when the flow of credit to households and businesses is constrained and the real economy of goods and services is adversely affected (opencrs.com).
Outsourcer: The service provider (outsourcer) is responsible for delivering the contracted services, resolving day-to-day operational problems and managing the request and implementation of routine changes in accordance with the framework of contracts, standards (Kent 1998).
Outsourcing: Greaver (1999) defined outsourcing as the act of transferring some of an organization's recurring internal activities and decision rights to outside providers, as set forth in a contract. Later Beaumont and Sohal (2004) explained outsourcing as having work that was formerly done inside the organisation performed by an external organisation. The vendor (hereafter the outsourcer and outsource are, respectively, referred to as vendor and client) may be an independent entity or a wholly owned subsidiary.
This study will limit itself to surveying and interviewing hotels only from two countries – Greece and Russia and most probably will not represent the complete situation of European hotel industry as well as worldwide hotel industry. Moreover it will not represent the whole situation even in both chosen countries for the reason that researcher sampled only those who have agreed to be sampled.
The convenience sampling procedure decreases the generalisation of findings. This study cannot be generalised to populations but may relate to other defined contexts with caution.
For the purpose of this study the mixed approach was used, which include utilisation of both quantitative and qualitative data analysis which are always connected with sensibility, reliability and validity. But on the other hand it has also its advantages such as expansion and collaboration.
Furthermore, this study will concentrate on outsourcing within hotel sector, but at the same time there may be other factors that influence and affect business processes in the hotels.
This chapter has introduced the thesis by outlining the topic of this study, the statement of the problem, background literature, purpose of this study, its rationale, presented research questions, definition of the terms and limitations of the study.
In this first chapter the study's main focus was identified as examining and understanding the importance of outsourcing within hotel sector. A critical examination of meaning of outsourcing, its advantages and disadvantages should be able to assist in determining how the hotel industry can be affected or altered by using outsourcing process. Finally, this study would determine reasons and forms of outsourcing which are the most recent, available and useful within hotel sector.
Afterward, Chapter Two will discuss the theoretical framework and conceptual models of factors for outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes within hotel sector. The analysis will be connected with four Research Questions. Finally, next chapter will classify particular insufficiencies in the literature leading to the need of the present study.
Chapter 2: Literature Review
The purpose of this chapter is to critically analyse the existing literature on outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes within hotel sector. Based on the research questions discussed in the first chapter of the given study, four general areas have been established.
More specifically this chapter will begin with a general description of related texts and then gradually concentrate on the precise areas in which the study has a focus on.
The studies in the four major areas provided the theoretical foundation for the research conducted in this study. The areas are:
1. Consideration and explanation of outsourcing processes within the hotel industry. This area relates to Research Question #1 - What is considered ‘outsourcing process' within the hotel sector?
2. Advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing for the hotel industry. This area relates to Research Question #2 - What are the advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing for hotel sector?
3. Factors and motives of using outsourcing processes within hotel industry. This area relates to Research Question #3 - What are the factors for outsourcing or maintaining internally business processes within hotel sector?
4. Aims and results of outsourcing for hotel sector. This area relates to Research Question #4 - What are the main aims of outsourcing within hotel sector?
The general areas were supported by the literature are all directly related to this study. The purpose of the literature review for the author was to obtain a greater understanding and depth of knowledge by having critically analysed all areas pertaining to the Research Questions.
These Research Questions are achievable as the researcher has a close and continual contact with the industry and has sufficient access to the information in numerous hotels in Greece and Russia.
2.2 Review of General Area I:
Consideration and explanation of outsourcing processes within the hotel industry This section provides the theoretical framework for Research Question # 1.
The hotel industry is one of the formidable business in the world but it does not mean that they are strict in incorporating business strategies in their business (http://www.outsourcing-weblog.com). Also, according to Burgess (2007), financial controllers in their turn consider that departmental and general managers do not have enough business skills – and finance skills in particular – to optimise costs and revenues and hence maintain profits. Thus outsourcing practice might be a very useful and successful way in order to help owners of the hotels nowadays as well as in future.
According to Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. (2000), outsourcing practice dates back to eighteenth-century England and has been in continuous use in numerous industry sectors. However, the term ‘outsourcing' – English neologism has appeared in the American explanatory dictionaries only in the beginning of 80th (Ostrovsy 2009). Since then this expression is strongly located in a business lexicon of the majority of the world languages. Traditionally, outsourcing has concentrated on activities which are remote from the heart or nerve centre of the company (Brown 1997).
Greaver (1999) defined outsourcing as the act of transferring some of an organisation's recurring internal activities and decision rights to outside providers, as set forth in a contract. Consequently, outsourcing it is one of interaction form between two organisations which is determined by the contract. And following this contracts experts of one company accomplish duties of other company.
‘Out-sourcing' — can be understood as ‘use of another's resources'. Moreover, according to Lankford and Parsa (1999) outsourcing is defined as the procurement of products or services from sources that are external to the organisation. In other words outsourcing is a transfer of some functions of the organisation to external highly skilled executors — outsourcers. Also it is refusal of own business process, and acquisition of services in realisation of this business process at specialised organisation.
For the hotels outsourcing is a transfer to the external contractor of some business functions or parts of business processes of the company. The contractor (outsourcer) adapts his universal means and knowledge, considering this specific business of the customer, and uses them in interests of the customer for payment, more often defined in the cost of services, instead of shares of profit.
According to Beaumont and Sohal (2004), wide variety of business process is now outsourced. The use of outsourcing is becoming more sophisticated; more organisations are outsourcing responsibility for business processes. Glickman et al. (2007) in his turn noted that outsourcing is becoming more widely accepted and the argument for outsourcing versus in-house operations is gaining more support. As a result Beaumont and Sohal (2004) confirmed that today outsourcing is a fashionable management technique.
Hence, it is possible to mention that the outsourcing market endures rapid growth. The growing demand and supply mutually accelerate each other. Specialised outsourcing companies of cleaning and service of hotels are developing. Outsourcing leads to growth of some professions for hotel sector. More often, it is either low paid and not enough prestigious jobs (such as tidying and cleaning), or very specialised trades where maintenance of necessary professional level of employees or their work-load for the organisation is problematic (an example can be service of computer systems and IT).
Consequently, as Glickman et al. (2007) stated, outsourcing has become a widely accepted practice that provides substantial cost-saving benefits for different organisations in general and hotels particular. And hotels will always outsource some activities (the supply of water and electricity) but insource others (Beaumont and Sohal 2004).
Therefore, there is a question: what kind of activities should hotels outsource key business processes or non-core functions?
As outsourcing is a means of improving the performance of the company (Brown 1997). And the overlay supplier is providing financial expertise which is difficult and expensive to create within a corporate treasury. The overlay provider, by offering the expertise to a broad range of clients, is able to provide it to each client at a lower cost than it would be for them to create their own capability (Winterton 2000). Today outsourcing is considered as the business technology which is transferring to outsourcing companies processes and functions from the in-house business and hence, it is possible to make a conclusion, responsibility for result of performance of these processes as well. So, for how big can be this shifting off responsibility for the hotel sector?
The majority of authors consider that core activities should stay in-house, whilst non-core activities can be outsourced, in order to preserve core competencies (Prahalad and Hamel 1990, Bettis et al. 1992, Lacity et al. 1995, Quinn and Hilmer 1994, Rothery and Robertson 1995, Kelley 1995, Peisch 1995, Mullin 1996 cited Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. 2000). From here it is possible to draw a conclusion that the sense of outsourcing comes to the simple formula: to concentrate all resources to that kind of activity which is the core for the company, and to transfer the other (supporting, accompanying) functions to the reliable and professional partner.
But Struebing, (1996) argued that especially relevant is the outsourcing of key business processes and financial functions. Nevertheless, Lankford and Parsa (1999) in their turn stated that focus on core business activities, companies can no longer assume that all organisational services must be provided and managed internally. Competitive advantage may be gained when products or services are produced more effectively and efficiently by outside suppliers. Thus, outsourcing is a direct transfer of non-core business processes of the company to the external organisation – outsourcer, for their further performance within the limits of the signed contract. And there may be big benefit for the company if transferred business processes are the exact specialisation of outsourcer.
Consequently, outsourcing is management strategy because of which hotels can optimise in-house processes and, without distracting on minor functions, completely concentrate on core activities. As a matter of fact outsourcing is attraction of external sources with the purpose of the decision of internal problems of the hotel. Outsourcing can also be characterised, as the sale to hotels services for maintenance of their activity, i.e. outsourcer can take on the balance almost all non-core activities of the hotel. As a result of that the client can give all his time only to the core business, thus occurs minimisation of risks concerning to not profile kinds of activities (a corporate meal, IT-service, transportation service, installation works, cleaning etc.).
In hotels, outsourcing has been used for many years for some operational tasks such as cleaning, but only recently (Cline and Warner 2001, Lamminmaki 2006 cited Burgess 2007), has been considered for accounting, following the example of other industries (Burgess 2007).
Holiday Inn for instance created its hotel reservations business as a separate entity based on its relationship with IBM's ISSC to serve the entire hotel and hospitality market (Venkatraman, 1997).
Other examples of outsourcing within hotel sector could be: cleaning, laundry service, human resource management, employees meal, IT-service and support, marketing, statistics, security service, creating web-sites, organisation of celebrating and conferences via an event company and many others which are not core competences of business, and could very easily and more economically be contracted out to service companies (Winterton 2000).
Nevertheless, according to Lamminmaki (2006), an activity will tend not to be outsourced if it results in a subcontractor being placed in a position enabling it to (wittingly or otherwise) inflict damage on the reputation of the hotel's business.
Now it is an appropriate and good point to understand how innovative the outsourcing model is. In general, outsourcing is just the variety of cooperation.
Outsourcing of the hotel activities is definitely not a new phenomenon. In 1963, for example, Storey (2001 cited Glickman et al. 2007) examined outsourcing in the military (Glickman et al. 2007).
From the previous part of the chapter it is possible to mention that benefit of outsourcing consists in more quality and less spend of accomplishment of the transferred function. Higher quality explained by availability of highly paid professionals who have a wide experience in the given problematic. As outsourcer has big amount of works in the specific sphere, he has a possibility to receive solid experience and on its basis to create various workings out for completing the transferred function. When the work is outsourced, the overlay traders are immersed in the market (Winterton 2000). Outsourcer is engaged in this sphere, and not for only one company. Hence, professional specialisation is taking place. And as a result expenses' decrease and accordingly, the effect of accumulation begins: the bigger and better specialisation – the easier management, easier management – cheaper the whole process. Moreover, Glickman (et al. 2007) noted that outsourcers who provide the same functions to a number of different hotels are able to purchase larger quantities at lower prices. Thus, expenses become lower using outsourcing, than at independent accomplishing of matching function.
On the other hand one of the biggest problems of this statement is that using by the hotel highly paid professionals will not allow to achieve this with small money. And it is really not so easy to operate this process. So actually, what kind of innovation is here? There were always contract and subcontract works, there was a specialisation of both workers and enterprises, there was a strict selection of suppliers. And can it be differently with modern development of techniques and business? The settled word ‘outsourcing' goes today as a new method of work. And this word has become extremely useful.
Also, it is relevant to know what place outsourcing takes in the quality management. In standards ISO series 9000:2001 (http://ds1.twirpx.com) this word (not even this but only the verb) ‘outsource' has been found by researcher just once in point 4.1. That is why it is especially appropriate to remember the statement of Lonsdale and Cox (2000) with the note that it is some kind of substitute for the once fashionable enthusiasms for conglomeration, horizontal integration, vertical integration, and internal integration.
Consequently, considering outsourcing as the business phenomenon of the modern world, it is possible to allocate its pluses and minuses. Also it is possible to separate core services and to understand, by what principles they work and what bring as a result to the hotels: benefit or losses. In addition, it is possible to analyse a situation of loosing work places because of outsourcing processes within the hotel sector, increasing percent of unemployment or, on the contrary, allows hotels to develop and grow faster, increasing their weight in the market.
2.3 Review of General Area II:
Advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing for the hotel industry
This section provides the theoretical framework for Research Question # 2.
According to Beaumont and Sohal (2004), outsourcing is used because it supposedly advantages the organisation. The advantages and disadvantages can be categorized as strategic or tactical, long-term or short-term, and tangible or intangible.
The advantages in outsourcing can be operational, strategic, or both. Operational advantages usually provide for short-term trouble avoidance, while strategic advantages offer long-term contributions in maximizing opportunities (Lankford and Parsa 1999). When services are outsourced, it may become easier to handle problem situations because it is possible to go straight to the provider and have them work out the problem instead of having to figure out what went wrong internally (Glickman et al. 2007).
For hotels, benefits are substantial: reduced costs, expanded services and expertise, improved employee productivity and morale, and a more positive corporate image (Lankford and Parsa 1999). Moreover, the hotel does not enlarge staff, removes from itself cares on personnel recruiting, and saves on social taxes. At the same time if hotel organise his processes in correct way, quality of work of the personnel remains high. Also hotels can leave taxes, administrative costs, worries about replacing equipment, warehousing, maintenance, and staff turnover to the contractor's experts (Glickman et al. 2007). Using outsourcing the company interested in the price and quality of given services only, and financial risks are transferred to the service provider.
According to Di Romualdo and Gurbaxani (1998), sharing costs and risks of commercialisation with outsourcing partners can help maximise return investment. And to raise quality and reliability because during solving the similar problems outsourcing companies have already stored a wide experience and can use the newest technologies and the highly skilled personnel.
Moreover, outsourcing can decrease the product/process design cycle time, if the client uses multiple best-in-class suppliers, who work simultaneously on individual components of the system, as each supplier can contribute greater depth and sophisticated knowledge in specialised areas and thus offer higher quality inputs than any individual supplier or client (Quinn and Hilmer, 1994). Consequently, each hotel as a client pays only a part of time of each of experts with the purpose of reducing a total cost of services.
What is more, Kliem (1999), Quinn (1999 cited Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. 2000) noted that outsourcing offers several advantages, such as enabling existing staff to concentrate on core activities on organisational specialisations, focusing on achieving key strategic objectives, lowering or stabilising overhead costs, and thereby gaining cost advantage over the competition, providing flexibility in response to changing market conditions, and reducing investment in high technology. Crucially, outsourcing can provide companies with greater capacity for flexibility, especially in the purchase of rapidly developing new technologies, fashion goods, or the myriad components of complex systems (Carlson 1989, Harrison 1994 cited Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. 2000).
Thus, it is possible to draw a conclusion that outsourcing has a number of advantages which are attractive to hotels using it:
• Allows to receive better quality services and/or cheaper;
• Improves innovative possibilities of hotels due to interaction and partnership with the suppliers of high level who have the big intellectual potential and rich innovative experience;
• Provides the big flexibility of the company in case of sudden change of a market situation or consumer preferences: to find new suppliers with necessary possibilities and resources easier and cheaper, than to reconstruct internal activity of the hotel, liquidating one resources and creating the new;
• Accelerates achievement of resources and skills;
• Allows to concentrate business on those processes which are effectively carried out by staff of the hotel, and those which are strategically expedient for keeping under its control.
For small hotels advantage of outsourcing will be expressed in economy of expenses and office (working, useful) areas. Furthermore, the search of the employee possessing qualification and a practical operational experience in all demanded areas can be quite long, and cost of hiring of such employee will be rather big.
On the other hand, the company which is specialised on providing of certain services, faces first with arising problems in some concrete area. This company invests as in improvement of decisions of problems and development of new technologies, as in constant improvement of professional skill of the personnel. Narrow specialisation in a subject domain allows it to provide reliable and qualitative execution of transferred for outsourcing task. And because of caring out the same-type operations for set of clients the supplier can keep competitive prices of his services.
To provide the same quality internally, considerable investments into personnel development, the equipment, the software, and also on the maintenance of the personnel involved in business process are necessary for hotels. The service provider, in its tern, does not need to search for new people, to equip for them office and to wait while they completely will accustom to the company. Because of this the essential economy can be reached. After analysing all factors listed above, the bowl of scales can be inclined to the site of outsourcing.
However, Glickman et al. (2007) mentioned that outsourcing can provide many benefits if properly applied, but with these benefits come associated risks. As with any other business decision, there are pros and cons to be weighed in the choice of whether to outsource (Winterton 2000). Researchers suggest the following disadvantages as the risks of outsourcing.
Kliem (1999) stated that becoming dependent on outside suppliers for services, losing control over critical functions, lowering the morale of permanent employees are the weaknesses of outsourcing process. Though, Lankford and Parsa (1999) noted that the fear of losing control is a major emotional stumbling block to outsourcing. Furthermore, Beaumont and Sohal (2004) selected five the most common minuses: ascertaining relevant costs, maintaining the relationship, loss of distinctive competencies, change problems and loss of flexibility. Moreover, outsourcing can generate new risks, such as the loss of critical skills or developing the wrong skills, the loss of cross-functional skills, and the loss of control over suppliers (Quinn and Hilmer 1994, Domberger 1998 cited Kakabadse, N. and Kakabadse, A. 2000).
As a result, it is possible to conclude that there are some points which every owner of each hotel has to understand before he will decide to outsource.
Inexpediency of transfer of some functions of the large hotels since it can lead to distribution of the confidential information, fall of level of efficiency in getting of the necessary data for management of the hotel. Confidentiality loss conducts to loss of competitive advantages of the hotel.
Psychological feature: it is hard to entrust the in-hose information to the external company.
Transfer of a part of functions on outsourcing, can lead to losses of some kind of activities of the hotel which in cooperation with a core business helped to achieve the organisations success and popularity among consumers.
Also it would be important to notice that having transferred to outsourcing a considerable quantity of duties, the hotel's expenses can essentially increase,
And also important to remember that the excessive amount of services removed to outsourcing conduct to a complete dependence of the hotel from external executors that is extremely adversely reflected the company as a whole.
The probability of losses is great in case of the absence of appropriate quality of given services.
Also it is necessary not to forget that any commercial organisation can be declared bankrupt and outsourcing firms are not an exception. Because of that the hotel may have additional difficulties of search and selection of new outsourcer.
Furthermore, absence of the appropriate control of the quality of the performance of works which have been outsourced is big disadvantage as well.
According to Glickman et al. (2007), to outsource or not, is based on financial considerations. But Kliem (1999) stated that the disadvantages of outsourcing outweigh the advantages.
To avoid this situation, hotels should be very careful, attentive and considerate to choosing external supplier when they decide to outsource. Behara et al. (1995) suggested to follow and analyse next points during identifying possible impacts out of the outsourcing process:
o Impact on company competitiveness;
o Identifying services to be outsourced;
o The number of suppliers to be used;
o Ability to return to in-house operations if required;
o Supplier reliability;
o Supplier service quality;
o Coordinating with the supplier and evaluating performance;
o Flexibility in the products offered by the supplier;
o Providing the latest/advanced technology and expertise.
Moreover, Quinn and Hilmer (1994) stated that small specialised suppliers often offer greater responsiveness through new technologies which have undermined the need for the vertically integrated organisation and have also helped achieve economies of scale. One of the decisions to reach such outcome might be co-branding
According to Hemmington and King (2000), today there are many hotel and restaurant companies that have adopted this approach to hotel dining including: Hilton with Benihana and Trader Vic's; Holiday Inn with TGI Friday's and Denny's; and Marriott with Pizza Hut, TGI Friday's and Ruth's Chris Steakhouse. There are five key dimensions of the hotel restaurant outsourcing relationship as follows: core competencies, brand compatibility, organisational culture, operational tension, and system of review, evaluation and control (Hemmington and King 2000).
Thus, it is possible to conclude, that depending on a type of services which hotels are outsource, there are next possible variants:
a) Transferring of administration functions (management);
b) Transferring of services' functions (housekeeping);
c) Transferring of internal processes functioning (marketing and promotion);
d) Refusal of own resources and their external use (laundry equipment).
Besides, depending on a form of services which hotels are outsource, there are next possible variants:
The outsourcing contract when the staff of a hotel and/or equipment is given to a service provider for supervising for the period of contract action;
The outsourcing contract when the staff of a hotel and/or equipment is borrowed from an outsourcing company for the period of contract action;
The outsourcing contract when both hotel and outsourcer are partners in commercial activity.
Frequently outsourcing within hotel sector is a long-term decision. Lankford and Parsa (1999) suggested that companies should not focus solely on short-term needs; this is a major event that one wants to avoid repeating. Firms need to take a long-term view of the move to outsourcing. Even, if the contract is short-term, i.e. service appears once and another need for it does not arise. It can be, for example, renovation of the hotel's rooms. Further it is possible to work repeatedly with the same outsourcer if quality of service was good, but it will be again short-term service. Even in that case it will be long-term view because hotel will be able to use these rooms in the future for quite long period of time.
Therefore, outsourcing within hotel industry is rather difficult and complicated decision. It has its own advantages and disadvantages, various forms and types, the contract actions might be short and long. What is more, there are big amount of outsourcers who provide services with different quality level. For successful outsourcing process hotels have to analyse a lot of internal and external factors, its own business level and place in the market. And only after this analyses and understanding the real need to outsource owners and managers of the hotels may start to search for the best service supplier.
2.4 Review of General Area III:
Factors and motives of using outsourcing processes within hotel industry
This section provides the theoretical framework for Research Question # 2.
The competition growing up every year on the market of services demands from the hotels to increase the production efficiency and to minimise the expenses. The main aim of the owner of a hotel – to make business effective, i.e. generating the maximum profit with an optimum level of expenses. But the resources and equipment economy is not enough, also the large part of expenses is payment of workers of the hotel. To solve this problem is possible with the help of outsourcing, allowing to transfer a part of processes of the hotel to the external company.
According to Burgess (2007), owners are looking for secure investments that make a good return. As well as stable, safe properties in which to invest (Barnard 2005). And outsourcing can be used to get such return and enhance business (Phillips and Kirby 2002). The range of choices for treasury outsourcing is broad and deep (Winterton 2000). Sometimes for instance decisions to outsource are taken in order to improve motivation within the firm (Chalos and Sung 1998). Furthermore, managers know that the job will be done on time and in a predictable fashion. And if it isn't, they can get somebody else without going through the hassles of hiring and firing employees.
Up to now it is possible to find out four main purposes for outsourcing within hotel sector:
1. Concentration of activity on the core business processes;
2. Refusal of the infrastructures which are not bringing in the income for a hotel;
3. Optimisation of number and level of employees of a hotel;
4. Availability to use newest technology.
According to Burges (2007), there have been many changes affecting the hotel industry in recent years. Thus, hotels should consider outsourcing when it is believed that certain support functions can be completed faster, cheaper, or better by an outside organisation (Lankford and Parsa 1999). When a hotel decides to outsource some of its operations, the decision is typically driven by considerations of scale economies, costs, the lack of capable/skilled workers to provide the service, and a desire to improve the quality of service. (Gupta et al. 2005, Finlay and King 1999 cited Glickman et al. 2007). However, according to Manion et al. (1993), there are some questions should be asked by the managers of a hotel when they decided to outsource and chose the supplier:
What are the proposed savings measured against?
Does the outsourcer have economies of scale not available to you?
Is the guaranteed price a good deal?
Can the outsourcer buy equipment and hardware cheaper?
What it is that they do that gives to the hotels competitive or strategic advantage? (Blake 1997).
After all these questions have been answered and decision has been made owners of hotels might understand that outsourcing according to Winterton (2000), is a pretty scary idea. It feels like giving one's chequebook to a tradesman and letting him write his own cheque. Hence, the fundamental decision is whether or not to outsource a business process or function. This is the most important of a sequence of actions and decisions listed in maintaining the relationship (Beaumont and Sohal 2004).
Currently, it is possible to suggest more specific reasons when hotels outsource:
• There are vacant places for the short period (holidays, business trips of principal employees);
• There is a need of the personnel for seasonal works (New Year, summer period);
• There is a necessity to accomplish the project, but there are no qualified personnel (marketing research, wed-site creating)
One of the most important steps for hotel's managers is the competent conclusion of the contract with fixing of all necessary points of decreasing of financial, human and other kinds of risks. Nevertheless, every manager has to realise that there are no any outsourcers exist who would provide unique, qualitative and cheap services at the same time.
World financial crisis which has forced hotels to count each cent and try to receive highest possible efficiency and return from all business processes can become one more factor pushing hotel sector to outsourcing. And the maintenance of the big departments of non-core orientation became inadmissible wastefulness.
2.5 Review of General Area IV:
Aims and results of outsourcing for hotel sector
Chapter 3: Methodology
Chapter 4: Results
Chapter 5: Conclusions and Recommendations
ALEXANDER, M. and YOUNG, D., 1996. Strategic outsourcing. Long Range Planning. 29 (1), 116-119.
BARNARD, R., 2005. Budget, Breaks and Business – The Three Drivers for UK Tourism in 2005 [online]. PKF. Available from: http://www.hotelschool.cornell.edu/research/chr/news/newsroom/item-details.html?id=4024279 [Accessed 4 June 2009]
BEAUMONT, N. and SOHAL, A., 2004. Outsourcing in Australia. International Journal of Operations and Production Management. 24 (7), 688-700.
BETTIS, R.A., BRADLEY, S.P. and HAMEL, G., 1992. Outsourcing and industrial decline. Academy of Management Executive. 6 (1), 7-21.
BLAKE, S., 1997. Management Summary: International Strategic Sourcing Survey 1996. PA Consulting Group. June, 18-19
BROWN, M., 1997. Outsourcing. Management Today. January, 56-60.
BURGESS, C., 2007. Do hotel managers have sufficient financial skills to help them manage their areas? International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. 19 (3), 188-200.
CARLSON, B., 1989. Flexibility and theory of the firm. International Journal of Industrial Organisation. 7 (1), 179-203.
CHALOS, P. and SUNG, J., 1998. Outsourcing decision and managerial incentives. Decision Science. 29 (4), 901-919.
COLLIER, P. and GREGORY, A., 1995. Investment appraisal in service industries: a field study analysis of the U.K. hotel sector. Management Accounting Research. 6 (1), 33-57.
CLINE, R. and WARNER, M., 2001. Hospitality e-business: the future. Bottomline. 16 (4), 26-33.
DI ROMUALDO, A. and GURBAXINI, V., 1998. Strategic intent for IT outsourcing. Sloan Management Review. 39 (4), 67-80.
FINLAY, P.N. and KING, R.M., 1999. IT outsourcing: a research framework. International Journal of Technology Management. 17 (1,2), 109-128.
GLICKMAN, T.S., HOLM, J., KEATING, D., PANNAIT, K. and WHITE, S.C., 2007. Outsourcing on American campuses. International Journal of Educational Management. 21 (5), 440-452.
GREAVER, M.F., 1999. Strategic Outsourcing: A Structured Approach to Outsourcing Decisions and Initiatives. New York: AMACOM
GUPTA, A., KANTHI, H. and MIKOUZIA, N.C., 2005. Outsourcing in higher education: an empirical examination. International Journal of Educational Management. 19 (4,5), 396-411.
HARRISON, B.T., 1994. Lean and Mean: The Changing Landscape of Corporate Power in the Age of Flexibility. New York: Basic Books.
http://opencrs.com/document/RL34412 [Accessed ]
http://www.outsourcing-weblog.com/50226711/hotel_outsourcing.php [Accessed ]
http://www.resourceconservation.mb.ca/news/pdfs/RCM%20corporate%20sponsorship%20evaluation%20framework.pdf [Accessed ]
KAKABADSE, N. and KAKABADSE, A., 2000. Critical review outsourcing: a paradigm shift. The Journal of Management Development. 19 (8), 670-728.
KELLEY, B., 1995. Outsourcing marches on. Journal of Business Strategy. 16 (4), 38-42.
KENT, D.L., 1998. The role of service level agreements in IT service delivery. Information Management and Computer Security. 6 (3), 128-132.
KLIEM, R.L., 1999. Managing the risks of outsourcing agreements. Information Systems Management. Summer, 91-93.
KLEIN, P., 1999. Outsourcing's third wave. Informationweek. 15 Novembver, 126-127.
KOTLER, P., 1988. Marketing management, analysis, planning, implementation, and control. U.S.A., Prentice-Hall International ed. U.S.A.
LACITY, M.C., WILLCOCKS, L.P. and FEENY, D.F., 1995. IT outsourcing maximises flexibility and control. Harvard Business Review. 73 (3), 84-93.
LAMMINMAKI, D., 2005. Why do hotels outsource? An investigation using asset specificity. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management. 17 (6), 516-528.
LANKFORD, W.M. and PARSA, F., 1999. Outsourcing: a primer. Management Decision, 37 (4), 310-316.
LONSDALE, C. and COX, A., 2000. The historical development of outsourcing: the latest fad? Industrial Management and Data Systems. 100 (9), 444-450.
MANION, R., BURKETT, D. and WIFFEN, B., 1993. Why it makes sense to break the I. S. shackles and five reasons why it may not. I.T. Magazine. 25 (3), 14-19.
MILGROM, P. and ROBERTS, J., 1992. Economics, Organisation and Management. Prentice-Hall. Englewood Cliffs, NJ.
MULLIN, R., 1996. Managing the outsourced enterprise. Journal of Business Strategy. 17 (4), 28-32.
NUREEV, M.V., 2002. Outsourcing today. Business Chelyabinsk, 17 September, p.3.
OSTROVSY, E., 2009. The best time for outsourcing. Business Block, 693 (25), 22-23.
PEISCH, R., 1995. When outsourcing goes awry. Harvard Business Review. 73 (3), 24-30.
PHILLIPS, P. and KIRBY, D., 2002. The Impact of Electronic Business on Accountants: A Shareholder Value Perspective. Certified Accountants Educational Trust. Available from http://www.icmap.com.pk/a2_ieba.pdf [Accessed 9 June 2009]
PRAHALAD, C. and HAEML, G., 1990. The core competence of the corporation. Harvard BusinessReview. 68 (3), 79-91.
ROTHERY, B. and ROBERTSON, I., 1995. The Truth about Outsourcing. Aldershot: Gower Publishing.
QUINN, J.B., 1999. Strategic outsourcing: leveraging knowledge capabilities. Sloan Management Review, 40 (4), 9-22.
QUINN, J.B. and HILMER, F.G., 1994. Strategic outsourcing. Sloan Management Review. 35 (4), 43-55.
SIEBURGH, J., 1992. The time is right for outsourcing. Lodging Hospitality, 48 (6), p. 57.
STOREY, W.W., 2001. Contract performance by industry. The Journal of Government Financial Management. 50 (1), 18-21.
STRUEBING, L., 1996. Outsourcing is the answer – or is it? Quality Progress. 29 (3), p.20.
VENKATRAMAN, N., 1997. Beyond outsourcing: managing IT resources as a value centre. Sloan Management Review. 38 (3), 51-64.
WINTERTON, A., 2000. Why outsourcing could be good for you. Balance sheet, 8 (6), 17-19.
ZHU, Z., HSU, K., LILLIE, J., 2001. Outsourcing – a strategic move: the process and the ingredients for success. Management Decision, 39(5).
Organizations на organisations
specialized на specialised