This dissertation has been submitted by a student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional dissertation writers.

Abstract

The development of computer technology and information network technology has brought massive challenges to financial services organizations. Online banking, which provides financial services to customers via Internet, plays an increasingly important role and still has tremendous potential for development. At the same time, the global and local competition between financial institutions has become more intense. Therefore, as the biggest commercial bank in China, it is very important for the managers of the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC) to build a long-term customer relationship.

This project has five objectives to achieve:

The first objective is to test whether there is a difference between customer expected and perceived service quality in ICBC online banking services. Secondly, the study aims to examine the relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction in ICBC online banking services. The third objective is to examine the relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty in ICBC online banking services. The fourth objective is to examine the relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in the online banking services of ICBC, investigate the current situation and give some evaluations. Finally, find out how the dealing with customer complaint in ICBC customer service department influences customer loyalty.

Based on the objectives, after decides the type of investigation and research approach, five pairs of hypotheses are formulated to test the relationship between variables. The results of this study indicate that there are high positive relationship between customer perceived service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty. There is also a medium positive relationship between handle customer complaint and customer loyalty. According to these, the ICBC online banking must establish a long term strategy to improve the perceived service quality, satisfying their customer, handling customer complaint promptly in order to achieve more loyal customers.

Declaration of Originality

I declare that this thesis entitled “Examining the Service Quality, Customer satisfaction and Loyalty in Online Banking Services of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China” has been composed by myself and has not been presented or accepted in any previous application for a degree. The work, of which this is a record, has been carried out by myself unless otherwise stated and where the work is mine, it reflects personal views and values. All quotations have been distinguished by quotation marks and all sources of information have been acknowledged by means of references including those of the Internet.

Chapter 1 Introduction

1.1 Overview

In the past twenty years, the pace of change in financial services sector has been dramatic. The development of computer technology and information network technology has introduced a new virtual economy based on the Internet. As the Internet provides new communication channels to banking industry, the number of online banking websites increased rapidly (Aladwani, 2001). Online banking, an important part of the Internet economy, plays an increasingly important role and still has tremendous potential for development.

Mols (2000) indicated that the introduction and customers’ adoption of online banking will bring a massive change in the relationship between retailing banks and customers. At the same time, the global and local competition between financial institutions has become more intense. As a result, building long-term customer relationships becomes ever more important as a part of financial institutions’ strategy. How to satisfy customers and gain customer loyalty has become one of the best means of obtaining competitive advantage.

Since China’s accession to the WTO, many foreign banks have begun to do business in China. They not only brought advanced management methods and business philosophy, but also made the financial market in China more competitive. As a consequence of this competition, China’s commercial banks lost a large number of high-end customers in a short period of time. Faced with the loss of customers and the future trend of the growth of profit changing from deposits and loans to intermediary business, China’s commercial banks began to recognize the importance of improving customer satisfaction and loyalty and stepped up their efforts to compete with their foreign counterparts (www.financialnews.com.cn).

Due to the increasingly competitive marketing environment, enterprises must be customer oriented (Kotler, 1997). With regarding to banking industry, the service quality is considered as the most important competitive weapon (Staford, 1996). Therefore, how to improve service quality and satisfy customer become a very important marketing strategy in banking industry. Service quality has been many researchers’ interest in recent years by the impellent of Parasuraman et al. (1985). There have been many researches identified the key factors impact on the service quality of traditional banks (Jun and Cai, 2001).

However, there are few studies on the customer perceived service quality of online banking services (Broderick and Vachirapornpuk, 2002). Customer loyalty even received less attention than service quality and customer satisfaction (Caruana, 2000). The concepts of service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty are linked together (Caruana, 2000). As illustrated by Caruana (2000:611), “service quality as an antecedent construct and service loyalty as an outcome variable of customer satisfaction”.

Therefore, it is important for banks to know the current performance of their services and understand the relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty. In Fecikova’s (2004:57) words: “Customer satisfaction has become an important issue for commercial and public service organisations.” The standards to judge a company’s win or lose are based on how many customers they can keep. Thus, how to satisfy customers and maintain loyal customers have become important marketing strategies of Chinese online banking industry.

However, no matter how well the services are designed and delivered, mistakes will happen. The majority of customers will participate in private word-of-mouth activities regarding their consumptive activities (Day and Landon, 1977). The valence of these word-of-mouth activities may be negative, neutral, or positive. When there is a difference between customer expectation and the actual performance of products or services, the negative feelings will result in complaint behaviour. Therefore, how to handle customer complaints, restore the confidence of customers and reduce the loss of customers has also been an important task to companies in the services process.

1.2 Research Objectives

There are some marketing and financial literatures on the services and customer relationship of traditional banks, but few researches are done on the services quality and customer loyalty of online banking. This study presents an analysis of the service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty of the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC), focuses on the relationship between services quality and customer satisfaction and loyalty, and how handle customer complaint influence customer loyalty.

This project has five objectives to achieve:

  • The first objective is to test whether there is a difference between customer expected and perceived service quality in ICBC online banking services.
  • Secondly, the study aims to examine the relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction in ICBC online banking services.
  • The third objective is to examine the relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty in ICBC online banking services.
  • The fourth objective is to examine the relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in the online banking services of ICBC, investigate the current situation and give some evaluations.

Finally, this study aims to find out how the dealing with customer complaint in ICBC customer service department influences customer loyalty of ICBC online banking.

1.3 Structure of Project

This project is divided into five chapters. Chapter 1 is the overview and introduction of the research. In Chapter 2, the writer introduces the development and history of online banking services and its development in ICBC. After that, the writer reviews the relevant theories of service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty, and customer complaint, explains how they were measured and the relationship between them, which are mainly based on previous findings.

Using these theories, Chapter 3 illustrates the research questions and methodology of this research, the structure of questionnaire was also introduced in this section. Chapter 4 explains the findings of this research, discussing the current situation of ICBC online banking services, examining the relationships between these variables and give some recommendations. In the final Chapter, the writer summarizes the research, discusses the findings and introduces a number of limitations of this study. This section also contains opinions and suggestions on developing the online banking in the future.

Chapter 2 Review of the Literature

2.1 Introduction

This chapter first introduces the overview of Chinese online banking services and the development of ICBC online banking.

Secondly, the writer clarified what the service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and customer complaint have been covered in the previous study, indicates which factors would affect them and what kind of methods were used to measure them. In this part, the characteristics of online services and customer’s adoption of online banking services are also addressed.

Finally, the relationships between these four concepts are reviewed. Bloemer et al. (1999) suggested that although the previous studies indicate that there are obvious relationships between service quality, customer satisfaction and customer loyalty, however, how strength the relationships are still not clear (Bloemer er al., 1999). Therefore, based on the literature review, the writer presents a research model for this study as well.

2.2 Background of Chinese Online Banking Services

2.2.1 Overview

Online banking services are broadly defined as the ability to carry out bank transactions electronically, usually via the internet. It is an important part of the Internet economy. All business transactions are done via the banks’ websites (en.wikipedia.org). Online banking refers to several kinds of services through which bank customers can gain information and services such as money transfer, bill payment, short loan, investment, buy insurance and so on, via a page on Internet without leaving their homes or organizations (Sathye, 1999).

There are several studies indicated that online banking services are the most profitable products to banks (Robinson, 2000). By eliminating the infrastructure costs associated with branch-based retail banking services. Online banking is able to offer instant service and lower service charges than their competitors. Online banking is the cheapest channel for banks to deliver services (Robinson, 2000; Giglio, 2002).

Research shown that the cost of an average online banking transaction is only 10 percents of the cost of a similar average branch transaction (Kolodinsky et al., 2004). Through provide services online, banks can reduce their expenditure on hard ware and staff in branch (Karjaluoto et al., 2003). At the same time, online banking service delivery channel can also help banks to retain current customers who use online banking services from any location. As Internet has become such an efficient and world-wide used communication medium, it has also become a widely used retail channel (Cho, M. and Park, S., 2001).

Furthermore, online banking provides banks opportunities to attract more customers from exiting Internet users (Rotchanakitumnuai and Speece, 2003). From the customers view, online banking services are convenient and can saving time compared with traditional retail banking services. Verma et al. (2004) suggested that customers are willing to pay more for online banking services to gain both offline value and online benefit. They can use online banking services when connect to Internet without the limitation of time and location.

As illustrated by Bainbridge (2008), Traditional banking was impacted greatly by the commercialization of the Internet in the early 1990s. As the Internet became more generally accessible, traditional banks began to realize its potential to deliver services to their customers while reducing long-term operational costs. Upon realizing this, they began to offer limited services online. In 1995, the first pure online bank, the Security First Network bank was founded in the United States. It provided services such as direct access to account, bill payment and check viewing, which are quite common today (Christopher, 2008). In the following twenty years, online banking services have developed rapidly and have now become a significant part of the business for commercial banks.

As in other countries, Chinese commercial banks are undergoing rapid change due to advances in information technology. Eight months after the first online bank founded in the United States, in June 1996, the Bank of China set up websites and started to provide Internet banking services to the community. One year later, China Merchant Bank launched the first fully online banking “All in one Net”. It became the first fully Internet bank in China (data.chinabyte.com).

Subsequently, more and more Chinese domestic banks have set up online banking services to penetrate the market and gain competitive advantage (Li, 2002). In 2000, the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China launched online banking business in 31 cities in China. As the nation's largest commercial bank, the opening of its online banking business aroused widespread interest. In 2002, HSBC launched its online banking services in China (data.chinabyte.com).

The number of costumers and the trading volume of online banking have increased rapidly. At the end of 2007, the trading volume of corporate online banking reached 245.8 trillion RMB, which increased 163.1% compared to 2006. In the total transaction volume, corporate online banking accounts for 93.6% which is 230 trillion RMB. However, the growth of Personal Online banking was even faster in recent years. The trading volume reached 15.8 trillion RMB at the end of 2007 which is almost four times of 2006’s 4.1 trillion RMB. The number of business customers reached 0.84 million and individual customers reached 65 million at the end of 2006 (iresearch.com.cn).

At the same time, the range of services provided by online banking has also increased. Before 2000, some of the banks only provided information services. Now they provide services such as enquiry, investment advice, money transfers, buying and selling of securities, online payments and, in some banks, small loans, housing mortgage loans and other credit facilities.

As the 21st century is a customer-oriented century, how to create and maintain customer has became an important part of marketing strategy of banking industry. As information technology advanced and communication channels diversified, customers can use a variety channels to acquire more complete information and choices, to achieve their own best interests.

As illustrated by, customer’s role in consumer economy has changed from the recipient to products or services to the decision maker. Most banks also aware that customers are becoming a dominant position, however, how to use information technology and limited sources to achieve the best and most efficient service quality to satisfy customers, gain loyalty customers, ensure the source of profit, these have became the focus of the operation of Chinese banks.

2.2.2 Introduction of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China

As the largest one of four big stated-owned commercial banks which dominate the financial markets in China. The ICBC is the leader in online banking services and is constantly introducing advanced online banking products and services to the public. The following figure illustrates its repaid growth in online banking.

Figure 2.1 ICBC Online Banking Trading Volume

We can see form the figure above, in 2000, ICBC's online banking trading volume amounted only RMB 2.03 trillion, in 2002 this number grew to RMB 8.77 trillion which is almost 4 times of 2000. In the following five years, the ICBC online banking trading volume kept a rapid growth rate. In 2005, it went beyond RMB 46 trillion, growing 23 times compared to that in 2000. By the end of 2007, ICBC online trading volume jumped to RMB 102.88 trillion, which is more than 50 times of 2000.

At the same time, the customers of ICBC online banking grew rapidly. At the end of 2007, ICBC Online banking has had 980,000 business customers and 39.08 million individual customers (icbc.com.cn). As illustrated in figure 2, the individual customers of ICBC online banking kept an continued rapid growth from 0.2 million in 2000 to 48.5 million in June of 2008.

Currently, ICBC online banking provides a variety of services; customers can transfer money, pay bills, buy stocks or bonds, change foreign currency and so on. It has been very successful and has won various awards in China. It is also widely recognized and respected in the international banking sector. In every year from 2003 to 2006, ICBC was granted the “Best Personal Internet Bank of China” award by Global Finance. All these have established ICBC as a leader in e-banking in China and have put it among the top financial players in the international arena (icbc.com.cn).

2.3 Introduction to Service

2.3.1 Definition of Service

According to Kotler and Keller (2006:374), “services are intangible, inseparable, variable and perishable products”. Therefore, services require more quality control than products. Financial services are services directed specifically at people’s money or wealth, they are concern with organizations, individuals and their finances (Ennew and Waite, 2007). Nowadays there are a whole range of finance services, such as banking services, credit cards, insurance, foreign exchange, stock and bonds trading and so on.

2.3.2 Characteristics of Service

In the earlier marketing literature, Gummesson (1987) suggested that “services are something that can be bought and sole but which you cannot drop on your foot.” Basically, services are process or experiences (Bateson, 1977; Bowen and Schneider, 1988; Parasuraman et al., 1985). We cannot own a bank account as we own a car, but we have the right to use the bank account doing various financial transactions on our behalf by banks.

According to Kotler and Keller (2006), services have for distinctive characteristics which are intangibility, inseparability, variability and perishability. Most services are intangible (Beteson, 1977). They cannot be counted, measured and verified before sale to assure quality. Thus the company may find it difficult to understand the consumers’ evaluation of service quality (Zenthaml, 1981).

Ennew and Waite (2007) suggested that services are heterogeneity because service performance different from customer to customer. The performance of services may be totally different from the customer’s perception. Those characters of services indicate that quality of services is more difficult to evaluate than products.

Although these are widely used in services marketing, many researchers have different thoughts. Loverloch and Gummesson (2004) argue that this framework has weaknesses, such as intangibility which is ambiguous, they suggested that many services also involve some tangible elements and outcomes. Vargo and Lush (2004) also highlight the inability of this framework to distinguish between goods and services.

2.4 Introduction to Service Quality

2.4.1 Definition of Service Quality

Marketing literature has provided many definitions of service quality. Before 1980’s, most research of quality focused on how to define and measure the quality of tangible products. As the service industry developed vigorously, more and more scholars did lots of exploration and study about service quality. However, due to the characteristics of intangible, heterogeneous, perishable and indivisibility, service is hard to define, measure and control (Crosby, 1979).

According to the American Society for Quality (Miller, C., 1993), “quality is the totality of features and characteristics of a product or service that bear its ability to satisfy stated or implied needs”.

Levitt (1972) suggested that services quality refers to the results of services can meet the standards set by the customers. Sasser and Olsen (1978) defined services quality from materials, equipment and personnel. This classification suggests that service quality not only including the final results, but also including the provision of services.

Gronoroos (1982) firstly proposed the concept of perceived service quality, he suggested that service quality generated from the comparison between expected service quality and the experienced service quality. According to Lewis and Boom (1983), service quality is the consistency of the transfer of service and expectations of service. Customer’s perceptions of quality usually come from their comparison between expected and perceived quality.

The result of this comparison is, when the perceived quality is higher than expected quality, customer will get good quality of service or satisfaction with it (Parasuraman, et. al, 1985). Six years later, they pointed out that service quality is a psychological assessment that is measured by customers according to the gap between the expectation and actual service quality (Parasuraman, et. al, 1991).

However, Stewart, Hope and Muhlemann (1998) suggested that service quality should be distanced by who provide the service and how they provide it. The former is evaluated after the service, while the latter is evaluated in the process of deliver service. Sarsser et al. (1998) argued that service quality should be defined through three factors which are materials, equipment and person. They suggested service quality not only include the results, but also include the provision of services. Service level and service quality are similar, service level can be divided into expected service level and perceived service level (Sarsser et al., 1998).

In recent years, the definition of service quality improved towards customer factor. Harrison (2000) described that service quality is basically concerned with meeting customer’s need and requirements and how well the service level delivered meets customer expectations. Zeithaml and Bitner (2000) argue that there are two levels of customer expectations, desired service and adequate service. The former is defined as the “wish for” level of service performance, while the latter is defined as the basic service expectations. According to Kim et al. (1998), financial institutions always provide generally undifferentiated services to customer. Therefore, service quality becomes the most important factor.

2.4.2 Dimensions of Service Quality

Marketing literature provide many views of the measurement dimensions of services quality. Sasser et al. (1978) suggested that there are three different dimensions of service performance: levels of material, facilities, and personnel. Gronroos (1982) divided service quality into two types: technical quality and functional quality. The former refers to what customers are actually receiving from the service , the latter refers to the process in which the service is delivered. Lehtinen and Lehtinen (1982) argued that service quality has three dimensions physical quality, such as equipment; corporate quality, such as company’s image; interactive quality, which means the interaction 74bb1v8140customers.

Parasuraman et al (1985) suggested there are ten dimensions of service quality, which are reliability, responsiveness, competence, access, courtesy, communication, credibility, security, understanding the customer and tangibles. After further study, they improved these to five dimensions: reliability, responsiveness, empathy, assurances, tangibles (Parasuraman et al., 1988). Figure 2.3 illustrates the structure of their finding.

Source: Parasuraman et al., (1985,1988)

Brady and Cronin (2001) presented a service quality model of three dimensions: interaction quality, physical environment quality and outcome quality. Interaction quality refers to the interaction between customer and employee in the process of service delivery. It is impacted by attitude, behavior and expertise. Physical environment refers to customer’s evaluation of physical facilities or building design. Outcome quality indicates the result of services (Brady and Cronin, 2001).

2.4.3 Importance of Service Quality

With the development of world economy and the pace of globalisation, most markets have been very competitive, in order to survive, companies need to provide good quality services to satisfy and retain loyalty customers (Fecikova, 2004). According to Broderick and Vachirapornpuk (2002), not only the technology changes overtime, customer expectation and perception of online services also changes continuously. Therefore, service quality will become a very important issue to online banks.

Nowadays, as the process of globalization has made the market competition in financial industry more and more intense. Customers have been considered as the most importance to service industry (MacDonald et al, 2000). At the same time, customers’ expectations of service quality are constantly increase, while their tolerance of poor services is constantly decline (Smith and Lewis, 1989). Therefore, it is increasingly difficult for the company to success in the competitive market.

Only the company which provide better services than others can gain competitive advantage in the market and gain more customers (Gronroos, 1990). Easingwood and Storey (1993) suggested that service quality is the most important factor for the success of financial industry. Therefore, providing high quality services to customers is important for a bank to success and survival in today’s competitive market (Wang et al., 2003).

2.4.4 Measuring Service Quality

As service quality directly relates with customer satisfaction, more and more company concern measuring service quality an important task. According to Baggs and Kleiner (1999:36), “The measurement of customer service is the most important variable that a company has to manage. Customer service includes the overall picture that an organisation presents to the public.” Due to the characteristics of intangible, heterogeneous, perishable and indivisibility, service is hard to measure and control (Crosby, 1979).

Gronoroos (1984) suggested that service quality should be measured by compare the customer perception and expectation of services. However, most of service quality studies have been focused on the development of instruments to measure service quality directly. Cronin & Taylor (1992) argue and change this method to a comparison of performance with ideal standards, or from performance perceptions only.

Their performance is mostly based on employees. Customers’ evaluation of service quality is influenced by their interactions with the employees. Recently, most researchers agree that services comprise of an outcome, which is an achievement of some end by the customer, and a process, which is the interaction customer-service provider (Blanchard &Galloway 1994).

Recent research suggested that to measure service quality, not only the performance of service should be measured, the process of the service delivery should be considered as well. To check the influences for service process to their perceptions; Rust and Oliver (1994) presented the three component model to indicate the influence of service process to service quality.

From the figure 2.4, it clearly be seen that there are three factors deciding the perceived service quality, they are service product, service delivery and service environment. This theory support the importance of service delivery, for actual outcome quality only one of the three factors.

SERVQUAL Model

SERVQUAL model is the most widely used method to measure service quality both in academic research and business analysis. Parasuraman et. al (1985) formulated a service quality model which highlighted the requirements for deliver high service quality. The model identifies five gaps that may cause unsuccessful services delivery.

There are five gaps in this model. Gap 1 is the gap between consumer expectation and management perception. Gap 2 is the gap between management perception and service quality specification. Gap 3 is the gap between service quality specification and service delivery. Gap 4 is the gap between service delivery and external communication. Gap 5 is the gap between perceived service and expected service.

Source: Parasuraman et al. (1985:44).

Based on this research, Parasuraman et. al (1985) identify ten factors which determine the services quality. These determinants were:

  1. Tangibles
  2. Reliability
  3. Responsiveness
  4. Competency
  5. Courtesy
  6. Communication
  7. Credibility
  8. Security
  9. Access
  10. Understanding the customer

Parasuraman et al. (1988) furthered the service delivery process and established a SERVOQUAL service quality analytical framework which includes five factors: Tangibles, Reliability, Responsiveness, Assurance, and Empathy(Zeithaml et al, 1990).

  1. Tangibles. All physical elements of the provision of service by banks. It includes the building, decoration, equipment, personnel, publications, visible materials, etc.
  2. Reliability. He extent to which repeated use of the product or service satisfies customers' requirements of it. It creates a level of trust by the customer in the services and products provided by banks and it directly affects customer perceptions of brand, economic strength, the levels of professionalism of staff and the quality of products.
  3. Responsiveness. The speed the company responds to the requirements of customer. Typically, this is a function of the willingness of bank staff to provide the necessary services when requested by customers. It not only embodies the attitude of a bank’s service and work efficiency, but also demonstrates the difference in quality compared with the inter-bank service.
  4. Assurance. This is the customer's feeling that bank staff are fully capable of dealing with problems in the course of their work.
  5. Empathy. This is a measure of the extent to which the supplier identifies the customers' problems as also being their own problems and the willingness with which they take those problems on board for resolution. Typically it would include providing customers with personalized product portfolios in line with their personal needs and aspirations.

Based on these five factors, they developed a 22 items scale to measure service quality. The following table illustrates the details.

ries. Carman (1990) suggested adding certain dimensions which are differentially important in different industry. Cronin and Taylor (1992) argued that SERVQUAL model was not appropriate in their study of banking and fast food industries. Another criticism is about the process orientation, meaning that the SERVQUAL focuses on the process of service delivery rather than outcomes of the service encounter. Richard and Allaway(1993) suggested that process and outcome is a better predictor of consumer choice than process.

Another attempt to determine service quality was that of Cronin and Taylor (1992), SERVPERF model. Cronin andTaylor (1992) support the performance-only measures, rather than the expectations-perceptions gap, and they state that performance explains more of the variation in service quality than does SERVQUAL. SERVPERF examines mainly the relationships between service quality, customer satisfaction, and purchase intentions and not service quality ( Baggs &Kleiner 1996). Cronin &Taylor (1992) who felt the expectations of the customer should not be considered when measuring service quality. The findings of Cronin &Taylor (1992) indicated that the SERVPERF method of measuring service quality to be the most accurate measure amongst the four tested.

However, Philip and Hazlet (1997) argue that the SERVQUAL conceptual framework has covered much ground in allowing researchers to derive a greater understanding of the concept of service quality and the factors that influence it.

Oppewal and Vriens (2000) suggested the use of conjoint experiments to measure retail banking service quality. They presented four dimensions which are accessibility, competence, accuracy and friendliness, tangibles.

In conclusion, both two models have the advantage and disadvantage and it is difficult to choose one of them. Although SERVQUAL model obtain many criticisms, it has been widely known and was thought applicable.

To survive in the highly competitive online banking industry, providing high quality services are very important to banks (Mefford, 1993). Therefore, banks are required to understand customer’ judge about the service quality in order to improve the service quality in order to retain and attract more customers to achieve the goal of gain more profit. Jun and Cai (2001) argued that there are numerous studies in service quality of traditional banks but very few in online banks. They divided online banking services into three categories.

  • Customer service quality.
  • Online systems quality.
  • Banking service product quality.

Josepy et al. (1999) presented six factors of quality in electronic banking services such as online banking service and ATM.:

  1. Convenience/accuracy
  2. Feedback/complaint management
  3. Efficiency
  4. Queue management
  5. Accessibility
  6. Customization

2.5 Customer Satisfaction

2.5.1 Definition of Customer Satisfaction

Customer satisfaction is one of the most important issues to most business organizations. Cardozo (1965) firstly defined customer satisfaction as customer perception of product performance, he pointed out that customer satisfaction will increase re-purchase activities. Cadotte et al. (1987) pointed out that customer satisfaction is a rational process of evaluation, they believes that before buying customers will create a standard according to the consumer experience.

After the purchase, customer will compare the actual product performance and the standard, draw a positive or negative feeling which will affect customer satisfaction. Oliver (1997) defined customer satisfaction as pleasure fulfillment. According to Kotler & Keller (2006, P144), “satisfaction is a person’s feelings of pleasure or disappointment resulting from comparing a product’s perceived performance (or outcome) in relation to his or her expectations.”

Customer dissatisfaction results when performance falls short of expectation. If performance matches or exceeds expectations, on the other hand, the customer is impressed. The level of customer satisfaction is determined customers’ views of an organization’s products and/or services in light of their experiences with that organization in comparison with what they have experienced or heard about other organizations (Szwarc, P., 2005).

According to the theories above, we can describe customer satisfaction from the following three aspects:

  • Customer satisfaction relates to and is generated by good products and/or services. It concerns all aspects of the product or service concerned.
  • The actual level of satisfaction is judged by customers as a result of the product/service matching or exceeding expectations.
  • Customer satisfaction does not occur until after purchase. Only when customers use the product/services can they make judgments about them.

The improvements brought by increased customer satisfaction include increased market share, higher profitability and better customer loyalty (Anderson, E.W. and Sullivan, M.). Generating customer satisfaction is not easy. Companies must ensure that they identify the specific features of their products or services which are considered most important by customers if they are to raise the level of customer satisfaction.

2.5.2 Benefit of Customer Satisfaction

Consumer satisfaction becomes the focus of interest because the role of the customers active response have been heightened (Cho, M. and Park, S., 2001). As the customers’ level of satisfaction is regarded to affect their purchase, more and more companies have focused on how to improve it (Oliver, 1980). Patterson (1997) suggested that the level of customer satisfaction is highly associated with customers’ repurchase action.

The higher customer satisfaction will result in a higher intent to repurchase behaviour (Rust and Williams, 1994). Satisfied customers are more likely to return to the company, however, dissatisfied customers are more likely to go to other companies next time. According to Kotler and Keller (2006), highly satisfied customers may generally stays loyal longer, buy more existing products and the new produces the company introduced. They may talks about the company and its products favourably, pay less attention to other competing companies and are less sensitive to price.

2.5.3 Measurement of Customer Satisfaction

Customer satisfaction is a key factor to retain customer. Companies must measure customer satisfaction if they want to achieve it (Ho, 1995). Nowadays more and more companies are measuring customer satisfaction regularly. As a critical factor in raising satisfaction levels, many firms have placed new emphasis on listening to their customers in an effort to better understand them (Griffin, A., and Hauser, J.R., 1993).

A common way to measure customer satisfaction is to subdivide satisfaction into different classifications and to measure by having respondents ‘score’ the level of satisfaction against each classification (Funston, R., 1992). There are several approaches to measure customer satisfaction. Customer satisfaction index is a product of the early 1990s, the main index is the Swedish Customer Satisfaction Index (SCSI, 1989), the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI, 1994) and the European Customer Satisfaction Index (ECSI, 1998). Later, customer satisfaction index was accepted and used worldwide.

According to Oliver (1993), effective dimensions and emotions have been included in recent models. Nowadays, more and more government and organizations have bulid up their own customer satisfaction index systems, such as Swiss Index of Customer satisfaction (SWICS), German Barometer, Korean Customer Satisfaction Index (KCSI) and so on. Although these customer satisfaction index models are similar in measurement model, they have obvious differences in structure and selected variables..

Not like traditional banks, the services provided by online banking are based on virtual economy. According to Jayawardhena and Foley (2000), Website factors such as design structure, download speed, content, interactive action and security have plays important influences on customer satisfaction.

The Swedish Customer Satisfaction Index (SCSI)

Fornell (1992) set up a systematic and long-term customer satisfaction index based on 1989 to 1991 Swedish National Satisfaction Survey, which is called the National Customers Satisfaction: The Swedish Experience, also known as the Swedish Customer Satisfaction Index. In SCSI, perceived quality and value were consolidated into one variable which is perceived value.

The American Customer Satisfaction Index(ACSI)

The ACSI model was launched in 1994 (Fornell et al, 1996). It was developed by the University of Michigan's Ross School of Business to measure the perceived satisfaction customers feel with companies, industries or national economies (Anderson and Fornell, 2000).  It shows the driver of satisfaction on the left side of the model and includes customer expectations, perceived quality, and perceived value. On the right side, it shows levels of satisfaction which include customer complaints and customer loyalty.

Each of these components requires several questions to be asked to enable evaluation of each section. Based on this model, we can relate the effects of the left side components to the levels of satisfaction on the right. The arrows in the model indicate the impact of each component on the others. By measuring the strength of the “impacts” from left to right, it is possible to choose the components which give greatest customer satisfaction.

Figure 2.6 The ACSI Model

The American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), (www.theacsi.org)

According to this model, it is necessary to discuss perceived quality and customer expectations. As illustrated by Zeithaml et al (1990), the factors which have an impact on quality of service can be divided into two groups, Perceived Service Performance and Expected Service Performance.

Expected Service Performance reflects the requirements of the customer; Perceived Service Performance reflects the experience of the customer with the products or services. Quality of service is essentially the extent to which the Perceived Service Performance matches the Expected.

The European Customer Satisfaction Index (ECSI)

Gronholdt et al. (2000) suggested that the ECSI model is a well-established instrument for measuring customer satisfaction and its related constructs. At present, this model includes the constructs of image, customer expectations, products and services, customer services, customer perceived value, customer satisfaction and loyalty. The ECSI divided customer perceived quality into two parts, product quality and service quality (Kristensen et al, 2000).

In this model, company image was supposed to have direct influence on customer expectation, satisfaction and loyalty. However, later research in Denmark suggested that company image only impact on customer expectation and satisfaction. In this model, company image is determined by the performance of company in the whole society not merely in market. That is, reputation is not only related to final reports, but more important. However, European nations have different opinions on the relationships among constructs though they have very similar models (Yang et al, ).

In SCSI and ACSI, customer expectation was supposed to have a positive influence to perceived value and quality. However, many evidence showed that expectation has limited effect on other constructs in the model. Therefore, ECSI did not posit any relations between them. In ACSI, customer loyalty was measured by post purchase behaviour. In ECSI, it was extended to include word-of-mouth.

2.6 Customer Loyalty

2.6.1 Definition of Customer Loyalty

Oliver (1999) defines loyalty as “a deeply held commitment to re-buy or re-patronize a preferred product or services in the future despite situational influences and marketing efforts having the potential to cause switching behavior”. Loyal customers provide more repeat business and are less likely to be tempted to other companies (Hamel, G.,1996). Peltier and Westfall (2000) argue that customer loyalty can be seen as from the attitude, intent and possibility of awareness, it should be measured by multiple indicators.

They also suggested that the possibility of re-purchase and recommendation are two important factors to measure customer loyalty (Peltier and Westfall, 2000). Palmer (2005) identified customer loyalty from measuring view as that a customer non-randomly repeats purchasing from a seller, with behavioral and attitudinal dimensions.

There are some factors suggested to impact on customer loyalty. Services quality has played a key role in loyalty, customer satisfaction, switching cost, company reputation and trust. Veloutsou et al. (2004) suggested that customer satisfaction, perceived quality and reputation are main drivers of bank brand loyalty.

As online banking provide services via internet, people consider company reputation and trust a lot when choosing online banking services. As illustrated by Andreassen and Lindestad (1998), company reputation is considered as a perception of quality associated with the name of the brand.

2.6.2 Benefit of Customer Loyalty

Fecikova (2004) suggested that customers’ loyalty is a function of satisfaction. Loyal customers are more likely to purchase your services again, encourage other people to buy and even spend more money on your services. They will bring long-term profit to the companies. Loyalty is considered as the most important factor in services marketing as it is the final effect on customers repurchasing behaviour (Caruana, 2000).There is a positive impact of customer loyalty on profitability (Storbacka, 1994).

Loyalty is important and more dominant in the service sector (Gremler & Brown, 1999) since service loyalty depends more on the development of interpersonal relationships as opposed to loyalty with tangible goods (Macintosh & Lockshin, 1998).

Loyal customers can be and should be the foundation for marketing strategy. Beyond the profit they generate, loyal customers provide the basis for brand development and improvement. The brand that losses sight of its loyal customers has lost its direction, and is vulnerable to losing market share (Reichheld and Sasser, 1990).

It is commonly accepted that there is a positive relationship between customer loyalty and profitability (Bowen & Chen, 2001). The findings of Reichheld and Sasser (1990) research should be mention as a classical example, which depict that when a company retains a 5% of its customers, profits increase by 25% to 85%. This is justified because new customer acquisition costs more than customer rention, and loyal customers generate more profits (Levesque & McDougall, 1996).Thus the firm can utilise potential customer relationship economic opportunities in a favourable way (Storbacka et al, 1994).

In the past, Lewis (1991) pointed out that the reasons consumers switched delivery channel from traditional to electronic self-service was the dissatisfaction with their present services. These might include the slow speed of service in branches, inconvenient branch opening hours or places and the small number of branch staff available to serve customers, etc. While a number of recent studies focussing on customer satisfaction with bank services, indicate that early adopters and heavy users of internet banking were more satisfied with this service compared to other customers (Polatoglu and Ekin, 2001).

2.6.3 Measurement of Customer Loyalty

The theoretical models of customer loyalty would be discussed bellow. Customer loyalty is difficult to define. Dick and Basu (1994:100) suggested that there are two main factors determine on customer loyalty, “a more favorable attitude towards a brand and repeat patronage”. They argue that low relative attitude with low repurchase behavior to a company will indicate low customer loyalty, but low relative attitude with high repurchase behavior will result in forged customer loyalty (Dick and Basu, 1994). They also point out that service quality is a recognized premise to customer loyalty because service quality will influence customers’ attitude a lot (Dick and Basu, 1994).

In general, there are three distinctive approaches to measuring loyalty: behavioral measurements, attitudinal measurement and composite measurements.

Behavioral measurements address consistent, repetitious purchasing behavior. It suffers somewhat from the fact that repeat purchases are not always the result of a psychological commitment toward the brand (TePeci, 1999).

Attitudinal measurements address the emotional and psychological attachment to the brand. This may result from public relations activity or from recommendations by word-of-mouth. They are concerned with the sense of loyalty, engagement and allegiance and there are instances where this exists in non-customers.

The third approach, composite measurements of loyalty, combines the first two dimensions and measures loyalty by customers’ product preferences, propensity to brand-switching, frequency of purchase, recency of purchase and total amount of purchase (Pritchard and Howard, 1997). The two-dimensional composite measurement approach has been applied and supported as a valuable tool to understand customer loyalty in several fields, such as retailing, recreation, upscale hotels and airlines (Pritchard and Howard, 1997).

Fonrell (1992) pointed out that customer loyalty can be measured by repurchase willing and the tolerance of price. Gronholdt et al. (2000) suggested that customer loyalty is composed of four indicators, including the customer’s willing to re-purchase, tolerance of price, recommend the company or products to others and their willing of cross-purchase.

However, Ingrid (2004) argued that customer loyalty is composed of three indicators, which are pay more money to buy the company’s products or services, encourage other people to bye the company’s products or services and believe the purchase of the company’s products are valuable.

In this project, the composite approach was selected to measure customer loyalty. For this study, loyal customers are customers who recommend ICBC online banking to others, continue use it, and regard ICBC as their first choice for new financial services products.

2.7 Customer Complaint Behaviour

Customer communication is considered as a very important factor in service marketing. The majority of customers will participate in private word-of-mouth activities regarding their consumptive activities (Day and Landon, 1977). The valence of these word-of-mouth activities may be negative, neutral, or positive.

When there is a difference between customer expectation and the actual performance of products or services, the negative feelings will result in complaint behaviour. In order to restore the confidence of customers and reduce the loss of customers, enterprises bound to act on the complaints to make up the deficiencies in the services process.

The research of customer complaint behaviour began in the 1979s, early scholars including Landon (1977) and Best & Andreasen (1977). According to Oliver (1987), customer complaint behaviour was considered as a mechanism that can be taken when customers are dissatisfied with the consumer experience, it can be used to alleviate the level of cognitive dissonance. Nyer (1999) suggested that complaint behaviour is a mechanism for customers to vent anger and frustration, and to seek the compensation of the failure of consumer experience.

Day and Landon (1977) proposed a two-level hierarchical classification of complaint behaviour. The first level is divided into action and no action. Then the action level is divided into public actions and private actions. Public actions including seeking refund from the company, restitution to the consumer association or court, private actions including boycott the company, word-of-mouth communication to relatives and friends. The following figure illustrates the structure of this model.

Day (1980) presented a different view of the second level. He suggested that customers can be divided into three categories in accordance with the purposes of their complaint. There are seeking compensation, expressing dissatisfaction and personal boycott. Singh (1988) argued that customers complaint behaviour can be divided into three categories: direct complain, complain in private and to a third party. Davidow and Dacin (1997) improved Singh’s classification, they suggested that customers complaints behaviour can be divided in two dimensions, one dimension is whether the complaints object is in their cycle, the other dimension is whether the complaints object are directly related to the purchase. They divided complaints behaviour to four types, complain to seller, complain to relatives or friends, complain to third party and boycott.

Deal with complaints is also called service recovery, it referred to when the service errors occur, the service provider taken some remedial actions to handle the customer complaints. Previous studies found that people rarely complain even they were dissatisfied with the services. However, they still would like to know how other complaints were handled. Sasser et al. (1990) proposed that remedial services is the way of companies to solve customers complaint and improve the service, if they did well, the negative experience of customers will be strengthened, but if they did properly, customers till establish the trust to company.

Tax and Brown (1998) defined deal with complaints as a management process, firstly the company should fine the failure services, analysis the reason, then take appropriate methods to solve the problem on the basis of quantitative analysis. However, the study of Bejou and Palmer (1998) about service failure and customer loyalty showed that no remedy to the failure of services will reduce customer loyalty.

2.8 Relationships among Service Quality, Customer Satisfaction and Customer Loyalty

According to previous marketing literatures, there is a high positive correlation between service quality and customer satisfaction and loyalty.

2.8.1 Services Quality and Satisfaction

Earlier studies found that customer satisfaction and service quality are linked together. Service quality is considered as one of the most important factors to drive customer satisfaction and repeat patronage intentions (Bloemer, et al, 1998). There is no doubt that excellent services would made customer more satisfied.

Boulding et al. (1993) found positive relationships between service quality and repurchase intentions and willingness to recommend to others. Bloemer, et al (1998) pointed out that measuring customer satisfaction can only tells whether the customer is satisfied or not, it can not tell enterprises what to do with it. However, measuring service quality can tell what aspects of service have problem and need to be improved.

2.8.2 Services Quality and Loyalty

Zeithaml et al. (1996) highlighted the importance of services as it is an important determinant factor of customer loyalty. Parasuraman et al. (1988) pointed out that service quality is related to customer behaviour, service quality determine the customer’s final behaviour. If the company provide excellent services, the customer will have positive intention. Otherwise, the customer will have negative intention (Parasuraman et al., 1988).

Abratt and Russell (1999) suggested that more and more studies support that service quality is a key determination of customer relationship and loyalty. Excellent service will bring customer loyalty to service companies (Reichheld, 1990). If a company can continually provide excellent services to customers, their willing to re-purchase will increase. This means the improvement of service quality can improve the possibility of re-purchase behaviour and the customer loyalty. Storbacka et al, (1994) argue that it is also possible to keep dissatisfied customers loyal due to high switching cost.

2.8.3 Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty

According to the studies of customer relationship management, customer satisfaction is regarded closely related to customer loyalty to a certain product and brand (Anderson et al., 1994). There is a positive relationship between customer loyalty and profitability. Fornell (1992) suggested that higher customer satisfaction will lead to higher customer loyalty. Completely satisfied customers are more likely to be loyalty than merely satisfied customers (Stauss and Neuhaus, 1977).

In many industries, managers are placing increased emphasis on customer satisfaction in order to strength customer loyalty (Yang and Chen, 2000). Reichheld and Sasser (1990) found that when a company retains just 5 percent more of its customers, profits can increase significantly. This increased profit comes from reduced marketing costs, increased sales and reduced operational costs.

The findings support the theory that customer satisfaction is related to customer loyalty, which in turn is related to profitability. The service profit chain (Heskett et al, 2003) hypothesizes that: Customer satisfaction - customer loyalty - profitability. As argues by Yi (1990, p104), “Many studies found that customer satisfaction influences purchase intentions as well as post-purchase attitude”.

However, the ability of customer satisfaction scores to predict such loyalty has not been adequately demonstrated (Higgins, 1997). Kotler and Keller (2006) suggested that the relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty is not proportional. They suppose customer satisfaction is rated on a scale from one to five. At a very low level customers ate likely to abandon the company and even bad-mouth it. At level two or four, customers are fairly satisfied but still easy to switch when meet a better offer. At level five, the customers are very likely to repurchase and good mouth about the company.

Service management literature argues that customer satisfaction is the result of a customer’s perception of the value received in a transaction or relationship. Loyalty behaviour, including relationship continuance, increased scale or scope of relationship, and recommendation (word of mouth advertising) results from customers’ beliefs that the quantity of value received from one supplier is greater than from others.

2.8.4 The Influence of Customer Complant

No matter how well the services are designed and delivered, mistakes will happen. According to a study of customer dissatisfaction, customers are dissatisfied with their purchases about 25 percent of the time but only about 5 percent complain. The other 95 percent thought it is not worth to complain or they are not sure how to complain (Kotler and Keller, 2006). Ganesh et. al suggested that customers whose complains are resolved satisfactorily always been more loyalty than customers who were never dissatisfied.

According to Bolton (1998), an effective solution to customer complaints will impact on customer satisfaction and loyalty a lot. He suggested if the dissatisfy customers experience excellent handling of complaints, they will be more satisfied and would like to come again. Bejou and Palmer (1998) suggested that if there are something wrong happened in services process, the companies excellent dealing with customer complaints can make customer fell reliable and result in higher customer loyalty.

2.9 Research Model of this Study

By comprehensive the previous literatures and the characteristics of Chinese online banking services, the writer presented a model of this study.

Figure 2.9 Research Model of this Study

Source: this study.

2.10 Conclusion

This chapter first introduced the overview of Chinese online banking services and the development of ICBC online banking. Since the duration of protection provided by WTO organization will finish, it is both an opportunity and a challenge for the most profit e-service bank--China construction Bank, More and more foreign banks will have the chance to share this daily bills payment market. ICBC will face more competitors from that time.

Secondly, the writer clarified what the service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and customer complaint behaviour have been covered in the previous study, indicated which factors would affect them and what kind of methods were used to measure them. In this part, the characteristics of online services and customer’s adoption of online banking services are also addressed.

Thirdly, the relationships between these four concepts were reviewed. Finally, the writer presented a research model of this study.

Chapter 3 Methodology

3.1 Introduction

In this chapter, the detailed methodology of this study is presented. The main purpose of this research is to examine the customer satisfaction and loyalty in online banking services of Industrial and Commercial Bank of China (ICBC). Firstly, the purpose of the study is introduced.

Then the writer discusses the research approach and type of investigation, as well as the research questions and hypothesis formulation. After that, the study looks at the measurement of variables and research instruments such as data collection, questionnaire design, as well as the pilot study and sampling attained with the key attentions of the chapter. Furthermore, the data analysis plan is also given.

3.2 Purpose of the Study

In the past twenty years, the development of computer technology and information network technology has change the financial services sector dramatically by introduced the online banking. Online banking services have shown improvements such as lower cost and convenience of use compared to traditional banking services as they have developed rapid in recent years. Furthermore, as the 21st century is a customer-oriented century, how to create and maintain customer loyalty has became an important part of marketing strategy in the banking industry.

The significant growth in both trading volume and customers in online banking services have also attracted researchers. Many researches have been done and positive results been in the fields of customer satisfaction and loyalty. However, online banking services in China only have ten years history. The researches into Chinese online banking services are very limited. Although ICBC is the biggest national owned commercial bank in China and famous for its rapid development of online banking services, the services quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty to its online banking services are still not clear.

As a result, the purpose of this study is to examine the service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty in ICBC online banking services. It will test whether there is a difference between customer expectation and perceived service quality in ICBC online banking services, examine the relationship between customer perceived service quality, customer satisfaction and customer loyalty, find out how the handle methods of customer complaint influence customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services, investigate the current situation and give some evaluations.

3.3 Research Approach and Type of Investigation

3.3.1 Research Type and Approach

As illustrated by Sekaran (2003:3), research is an “organized, systematic, critical, scientific, inquiry or investigation into a specific problem, undertaken with the purpose of finding answers or solutions to it”. Briefly, it is a process of finding solutions to a problem through analysis the factors and study (Sekaran, 2003). There are two types of business research, applied research and basic research. The former is used to solve a problem faced by the managers, while the latter is intended to generate new knowledge by understanding how certain problem accoutred in the organization can be solved (Sekaran, 2003).

Saunders et al. (2003:3) suggested that research has three characteristics, “data are collected systematically, data are interpreted systematically, a clear purpose to fine things out”. According to Ghauri and Gronhaugh (2002), systematic means that research is not based on researcher’s beliefs but the logical relationships. Easterby-Smith et al. (2002) argue that there are three distinctive factors of business and management research. First is the way in which researchers use previous knowledge; secondly, the reason that managers allow research is the commercial advantage; finally, the research always have practical results (Smith et al, 2002).

Saunders et al. (2003) introduce the process of research, after deciding to do the research, researchers should clarify the research topic, produce a literature review, choose the research approach and purpose, clarity the access, plan data collection method and collect data, finally, analysis the data in the research project.

There are two main approach to research, deductive approach de inductive approach. Deductive approach always been used to test a theory while inductive been used to building theory (Saunders et al., 2003). Robson (1993) presents five stages of deductive research.

  1. Using the theory as a source for deducing hypotheses
  2. Describe the hypotheses in operational terms to express the relationships between variables
  3. Verifying the hypotheses by testing
  4. Examining the outcome of the inquiry for correlation with the hypotheses
  5. Modifying the theory is necessary ( (Robson, 1993).

This study aims to examine the relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and handle customer complaint. Therefore, a deductive approach has been used. Five pairs of hypotheses have been formulated to explain the relationship between these variables. A questionnaire is designed to collect quantitative data as well.

3.3.2 Type of Investigation

The nature of researches could be either exploratory or descriptive, and also could e conducted to test hypotheses. Which type should be chosen depends on how the knowledge of the topic has developed. Exploratory study is used when the research topic is not known much and it is difficulty to gain enough information from previous study to solve the problem.

According to Sekaran (2003:121), ‘a descriptive study is undertaken in order to ascertain and be able to describe the characteristics of the variables of interest in a situation’. Hypothesis testing is always used to explain the characteristics of particular relationships or establish the relationships between variables (Sekaran, 2003). As illustrated by Sekaran (2003:125), “Hypothesis testing offers an enhanced understanding of the relationship that exists among variables”.

Based on the literature review of this study, a descriptive approach was chosen. Because the characteristics of service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty, customer complaint behaviour were known to exist, and this study focuses on examine the service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty as well as the relationship between these variables in online banking services of ICBC. Therefore, hypothesis testing is also used. The nature of this study is conducted to be both descriptive and hypothesis testing.

3.4 Research Questions and Hypothesis Formulation

Based on the research problems stated above, six research questions have been addressed:

1. Is there a difference between customer expected and perceived service quality of ICBC online banking services?

2. Is there a significant and positive relationship between perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services?

3. Is there a significant and positive relationship between perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services?

4. Is there a significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services?

5. Is there a positive relationship between handle customer complaint behaviour and customer loyalty?

According to these research questions, five pairs of hypotheses were formulated to examine the correlation of variables as below.

H1-0: There is no significant difference between customer expectation and customer perception towards service quality of ICBC online banking services.

H1-1: There is a significant difference between customer expectation and customer perception towards service quality of ICBC online banking services.

H2-0: There is no significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services.

H2-1: There is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services.

H3-0: There is no significant relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H3-1: There is a significant relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H4-0: There is no significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H4-1: There is a significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H5-0: There is no positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H5-1: There is a positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

3.5 Variables and Measurement

According to Sekaran (2003:87), “a variable is anything that can take on differing or varying values.” There are four main variables of this study: service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, and dealing with customer complaint. The definition and means of measurement of these variables are presented below.

3.5.1 Measurement of Service Quality

When measuring the quality of online banking services of ICBC, five dimensions of SERVQUAL model have been used. As suggested by Parasuraman et al. (1988), they are tangibility, reliability, responsiveness, assurances and empathy.

These five dimensions were defined as follows.

  1. Tangibility. Tangibility refers to all the physical elements such as service equipments, buildings and staff appearance. In this study, it is defined as the provision of services by ICBC online banking, including website structure and convenient to use.
  2. Reliability. This factor refers to the ability to finish the promised services reliable and accurate. In this study it will be measure by asking if the services of ICBC online banking are as efficient of high quality promised and accurate.
  3. Responsiveness. It refers to the employees’ willingness to help customers and can provide service promptly.
  4. Assurance. In this study, it refers to if the employees of ICBC online banking with professional knowledge and courtesy to make customers trust them. In addition, safety is a very important factor to online banking. Safety was also considered as a big obstacle for online payment (Wong et al., 2004). It refers to if ICBC online banking is secure and maintains the privacy of customers’ accounts.
  5. Empathy. It refers to the extent to which the company provides personalized services and individual care. In this study, it will be measured by asking if the ICBC online banking can meet customers’ needs of online banking services and provide personalized services。
  6. According Parasuraman et al. (1985), customer’s perceptions of quality usually come from their comparison between expected and perceived quality. In this study, the service quality of ICBC online banking is measured by the gap resulting from the comparison of customers’ expected service quality and perceived service quality

3.5.2 Measurement of Customer Satisfaction

In this study, customer satisfaction was generated by customers’ comparison of expected and perceived services quality. As suggested by Fornell (1992), satisfaction is an overall and general phenomenon so a single measure of overall satisfaction is reliable. Therefore, a single question of customers’ overall satisfaction of ICBC online banking services is used in this study.

3.5.3 Measurement of Customer Loyalty

Based on the previous literature, customer loyalty is defined as customer’s reliance or the goodwill of company’s products or services. Gronholdt et al. (2000) suggested that customer loyalty is composed of four indicators: the customer’s willingness to re-purchase, tolerance of price, recommending the company or products to others and their willingness of cross-purchase. However, in Chinese online banking industry, banks’ charge of money transfer fees or the interest they paid to customers are almost in the same level. Therefore, in this study, customer loyalty will be measured by three indicators.

1. Recommend to others. Loyal customers would like to recommend ICBC online banking services to other people.

2. Repetitious purchasing behaviour. Loyal customers may continue using ICBC online banking services.

3. Willingness to gross-purchase. When loyal customers need new financial services, they will consider ICBC as their first choice.

3.5.4 Measurement of Dealing with Customer Complaints

Before introduce how to measure handle customer complaint in ICBC, it is important to know how and where are they complain. Customers’ complaint behaviour is always generated from their dissatisfaction with the products or services. This study will investigate the various actions the customers may take when they are not satisfied with the ICBC online banking services. Based on the previous literature, the writer divided customers’ complaint behaviour to for types.

1. No action. When customers are not satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking, they are not going to take any action.

2. Private action. When customers are not satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking, they will complain to family member or friends.

3. Complain to the seller. When customers are not satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking, they will complain to customer service department of ICBC online banking.

4. Complain to the third party. When customers are not satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking, they will complain to other organizations, such as consumer association or the media.

When customers complain to the company, the company will take some actions to eliminate customer’s dissatisfaction. Effective dealing with customer complaint can bring high levels of satisfaction and loyalty to the company. In this study, ICBC’ dealing with customer complaints will be measure from their attention, processing and handling capacity.

3.6 Research Instruments

3.6.1 Data Collection

In the data collection section, there are two kinds of data which can be used: primary and secondary data. Primary data is collected by the researcher and is used in the research directly (Sekaran, 2003). The method of primary data collection will be the quantitative technique because this is required by the descriptive approach. In this case, the primary data will be mainly acquired by the distribution, completion and collection of the designed questionnaires through survey agency website and emails. Conversely, secondary data refer to information which can be gained from existing studies (Sekaran, 2003).

It includes documentary data, multiple source data and survey-based data. In this study, primary data was collected from many different respondents to measure there responses. Because this study aims to find out the relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction and loyalty, dealing with customer complaint of ICBC online banking. Therefore, a large number of ICBC online banking users view are needed to generate the reliable result.

There are several methods of data collection. The three mostly used methods are interviewing, questionnaires, observing (Sekaran, 2003). All these methods have both advantages and disadvantages. Personal interview can motivate respondents but will take more personal time of interviewers (Sekaran, 2003). Electronic questionnaires have facilities which make them easy to administer, save the cost of research and have fast delivery. However, the respondents of electronic questionnaires must have access to the Internet and be willing to complete the questionnaires (Sekaran, 2003).

The respondents of this study will be users of ICBC online banking, thus, all of them already have access to the Internet. Based on the research questions above, due to time and cost limitation, designing a questionnaire and delivering it via the Internet would be an appropriate approach to collect data from ICBC online banking customers.

3.6.2 Questionnaire Design

Primary data can be collected by using questionnaires. In case studies, the term Questionnaire has a specific definition. It describes techniques of data collection in which one or more respondents are asked to respond to the same set of questions in a predetermined order (deVaus, 2002). As illustrated by Hague (2006:34), “In quantitative research, a well-written questionnaire is vital”.

Based on the purpose of this project, a design questionnaire would be an appropriate instrument for the collection of the relevant data during current factors: The main advantages of this method are that completed responses can be collected in a short time, any doubt that the respondents might have on any question could be clarified on the spot and it is less expensive and consume less time than interviewing (Sekaran, 2003).

According to Hague (2006), the questionnaire method has been widely used in quantitative research, it can be finished by the respondents as well as the interviewers who distribute the questionnaires and collect answers. Data collected from questionnaire normally are quantitative and ideally offer a breadth of insight and information (Veal, 1997).

There are two main types of questionnaire, self-administered questionnaire and interviewer administered questionnaire (Saunders et al, 2003). The former is always finished by respondents while the latter is recorded by the interviewer. Self-administered questionnaires can be distributed and returned by using email or the Internet, postal or mail, or even distribute to respondents by hand (Saunders et al, 2003). E-mail survey is quicker and cheaper than postal survey.

The data can be collected more efficiently and it is possible to connect more respondents (Hague, 2006). Through Internet survey, the researcher can receive the data directly by using their computer, and it will make analysis more convenient (Hague, 2006). Based on these theories, taking time and cost limitation into account, Internet and E-mail surveys were chosen in this study.

A questionnaire is composed of a range of questions with possible responses (Hague, 2006). The design of questionnaire is very important and it will influence the reliability and validity of the collected data. Foddy (1994) argues that the questions must be “understood by the respondent in the way intended by the researcher”. There are two main types of question, open-ended question and close-ended question. Respondents can answer open-ended questions in their own way (Fink, 1995).

However, respondents are expected to chose choose answers already provided by researchers in close-ended questions (Saunders et al, 2003). As close-ended (such as multiple choice answers) questions are easier for respondents to answer and for researcher to collect and analysis, they will be used in this study.

Therefore, a structured questionnaire will be used to measure the service quality, customers’ satisfaction and loyalty, and dealing with customer complaint in ICBC online banking. This questionnaire is made up of six main sections and 34 items. Each of the questions is designed to collect data to examine the research questions and hypotheses. This questionnaire will be divided into six parts, ICBC online banking using details, service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, customer complaint behaviour and ICBC’s dealing with customers’ complaint. The method of the research will be quantitative research. The table below is the structure of the questionnaire.

Table 3.1 Questionnaire Structure

Section

Variable

Item

1. ICBC Online Banking Usage

How long?

1

How often?

2

2. Service Quality

2.1 Customers expectation

Tangible

3,4

Reliability

5,6

Responsiveness

7,8

Assurances

9,10

Empathy

11,12

2.2 Customers perception

Tangible

13,14

Reliability

15,16

Responsiveness

17,18

Assurances

19,20

Empathy

21,22

3. Customer Satisfaction

Overall satisfaction

23

. Customer Loyalty

Recommend to other people

24

 

The first section (Q1-Q2) of the questionnaire collects usage information of ICBC online banking. It helps to understand usage details such as how long the respondents have using ICBC online banking and how often they use it.

In the following sections, 5-point likert scale is used. Section 2 (Q3-Q22) is designed to measure the service quality of ICBC online banking services. Q3-Q12 are designed to measure customers’ expectation of ICBC online banking services, while Q13-Q22 are designed to measure customers’ perception of ICBC online banking services. The length of the questionnaire is considered an important factor and will determine the successful completion of the survey.

Rust and Kannan (2002) suggested that the fist rule in doing a customer survey is to keep it simple. Hague et al. (2004) suggested that one Golden rule of questionnaire is to use short and simple questions and make easy to complete. According to Saunders et al (2003), the shorter questionnaire has the higher chance to be finished. Thus, based on the previous literature, rather than use the 22 questions of the SERVQUAL model, the writer deleted some item such as service equipment and staffs’ wearing which are not appropriate to online banking, and combine some similar items. Also taking time limitation into account, at last 20 questions were designed to measure customer expected service quality and perceived service quality in order to make the questionnaire as short as possible.

In section 3 (Q23), one question is designed to measure the overall satisfaction of ICBC online banking services. Yi’s (1990) suggestion that a single overall satisfaction measure scored as this one is reasonably valid.

In section 4 (Q24-Q26), three questions are designed according to the composite measurements of customer loyalty which is mentioned in literature review.

In the flowing section 5 (Q27-Q30), four questions were designed to investigate which kind of actions customers will choose if they are not satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking. It can be divided into to main types, action and no action. Q27-Q29 indicated three main types of customers’ complaint action while Q30 indicates no action.

In section 6 (Q31-Q34), four questions were designed to measure the dealing of customers’ complaint in ICBC online banking. Firstly, the respondents would be divided into two categories depending on whether they have ever complained to ICBC and not. Respondent with the complaint experiences with ICBC are asked to finish Q32-Q34 to help the writer examine the relation between dealing with customers’ complaint and customer loyalty.

3.7 Pilot Study

Saunders et al. (2003) suggests that questionnaire should be pilot tested before distribute to collect data. Pilot test will help to improve the validity of the questionnaire (Mitchell, 1996). The pilot test uses a small sample of subjects drawn from the same groups as those to whom the final version will be administered. In the pilot test, the subjects will be presented with a draft of the questionnaire and will then be taken through the questions for a second time to check if the meanings are clear and unambiguous (Saunders et al., 2003).

It has been suggested that for most student questionnaires the number of respondents for a pilot study should be at least 10 (Fink 1995). Therefore, in this study, a non-probability sample of 17 respondents was chosen by sending questionnaires via email to 17 ICBC online banking users.

3.7.1 Validity of the Questionnaire

According to Sekaran (2003:425), validity refers to “the evidence that the instrument, technique, or process used to measure a concept does indeed measure the intended concept”. Through pilot study, each question of this questionnaire has been carefully checked for clarity of meaning. This survey was taken in China so the questionnaire had to be translated to Mandarin and it was important that meanings were not lost in translation.

Pilot study subjects were asked to give comments and indicate any ambiguities encountered when answering the questions. The results of the pilot study indicated that the questionnaire was easy to understand and can be finished within 10 minutes. However, two little grammar false have been corrected and the order of questions have been changed to make the questionnaire more logical.

3.7.2 Reliability of the Questionnaire

The consistency of responses to the questions gives some measure as to the reliability of the questionnaire. Sekeran (2003) stated that the reliability of a measure is a guide to the extent to which it is (un)biased and ensures consistency of measurement over time and between the various items in the questionnaire.

In this study, Cronbach’s alpha coefficient is used to test the reliability. The Cronbach's Coefficient Alpha is most commonly used statistic methods to measure the reliability of an instrument in the project (Ghauri and Gronhaug, 2002). In general, Alpha value less than 0.6 is considered to be poor, those in the 0.70 range are acceptable, those higher than 0.80 are good and indicate the reliability is preferable (Sekaran, 2003). The table bellow indicates the result by using SPSS 15.0.

From the table above, the Cronbach's Alpha is 0.815. This value is higher than 0.8 which means the reliability of this questionnaire can be considered good.

3.8 Sampling

3.8.1 Sampling Method

“Before beginning to collect data for a research project, the researcher need to know exactly who to include in the research (Hague, 2006:5)”. The population is the entire group of people or other objects that the researchers want to investigate (Sekaren. 2003). Therefore, the population of this study ideally should be all the ICBC online banking users.

It is necessary to gather data from different respondents when doing primary research (Hague, 2006). It is extremely important to select samples before collecting data. ‘Sampling techniques provide a range of methods that enable you to reduce the amount of data collect by considering only data from a subgroup rather than all possible case or elements’ (Saunders et al, 2003). The sampling techniques can be divided into two main types: probability sampling and non-probability sampling.

The most important feature of probability sampling is that each one of the target population has an equal chance to be a respondent (Hague, 2006). However, respondents of non-probability sampling are chosen from the target population due to certain qualities (Hague, 2006). By using non-probability sampling researchers are able to select sample more purposively and feel easier to reach people from target population (Saunders et al, 2003).

In this study, the non-probability sampling method is used. According to Saunders et al, (2003), it is not always possible to use probability sample method in many business researches such as market survey and case study. People in this research are self-selected.

The writer put the questionnaire on a survey agency (my3q.com), at the same time, the writer asked ICBC online banking users’ E-mail addresses by left messages on ICBC online BBS (service.icbc.com.cn/bbs/index.jsp), and then sent the questionnaire to them by e-mail. From 10th August to 20th August, 122 questionnaires have been collected.

3.8.2 Sampling Size

Sample size refers to the actual number of research objects which have been selected as a sample to present the population’s characteristics (Sekaran, 2003). Unlike probability samples, there are no rules in determine the size of non-probability samples (Saunders et al, 2003). However, Roscoe (1975) suggests that a sample size larger than 30 and less than 500 is appropriate for most researches. He also suggested that if the sample is broken into sub samples, it is necessary to have a minimum size of 30 for each sub samples (Roscoe, 1975).

Hague et al. (2004) suggested that when the sample becomes more than 30, the consistency of interviews improves; when it reaches 200, it is definitely meet the need of quantitative research. In the original SERVQUAL study, Parasuranman et al. (1991) used a sample size over 200 to measure service quality. Prayag (2007) used a sample size of 140 to measure tourists’ perceptions of service quality of an airline company.

Wong et al (1999) used a sample size of 155 participants to measure service quality in hospitality industry. Taking all these into account, due to time and cost limitation, a sample size over 100 will be appropriate for this study. The sub sample size of customers who ever complain to ICBC online banking is aimed to reach over 30 respondents.

3.9 Conclusion

This chapter presented the research method used at present. After describing the research purpose, the writer discussed types of research investigation to discover which methods are appropriate to this research. Based on research questions, five pairs of hypotheses have been formulated. Then the definition and measurement of variables were presented.

Following this, the writer discussed the sampling method and data collection method. After that, a questionnaire was designed for the preparation of test the hypotheses. Finally, a pilot study and reliability test were also conducted to check the feasibility of the questionnaire. The collected questionnaires were analysed and discussed in the following chapter.

Chapter 4 Analysis of Findings

4.1 Introduction

In this chapter, the writer presented the statistic analysis of the data collected through questionnaires from ICBC online banking services users. Firstly, descriptive analysis of each variable will be done through figures and tables. Secondly, the normality of the distribution will be examined to determine that whether parametric or non-parametric tests will be applied. Thirdly, the hypotheses will be tested to examine the relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and dealing with customer complaint. Finally, the finding of statistical tests will be analyzed.

4.2 Descriptive Analysis

In this study, a total of 122 questionnaires were collected from web survey. Despite the 16 incomplete and error questionnaires, at last 106 valid questionnaires were used for analysis. Descriptive analysis is used to provide a summery of variables.

4.2.1 Usage of ICBC Online Banking Services

In Q1 and Q2, the writer asked the usage of ICBC online banking services. We can seen from table 4.1 and 4.2, among 106 respondents, 13.2% of 106 respondents use ICBC online banking less than one year, 55.7% of them use it in one to two years which takes the largest part. 41.5% of 106 respondents use ICBC online banking less than once a month, 38.7% of respondents use it two to three times a month, 9 people occupied 8.5% use it more than five times a month.

Table 4.1 How long have you used the ICBC online banking services?

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulative Percent

Valid

Less than 1 year

14

13.2

13.2

13.2

1 year - 2 years

45

42.5

42.5

55.7

2 years - 3 years

29

27.4

27.4

83.0

More than 3 years

18

17.0

17.0

100.0

Total

106

100.0

100.0

Source: this study.

Table 4.2 How often do you use the ICBC online banking services?

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulative Percent

Valid

Less than once a month

44

41.5

41.5

41.5

2 - 3 times a month

41

38.7

38.7

80.2

4 - 5 times a month

12

11.3

11.3

91.5

More than 5 times a month

9

8.5

8.5

100.0

Total

106

100.0

100.0

Source: This study.

4.2.2 Mean Score Analysis of Customer Expected Service Quality

According to Sekaran (2003), mean score analysis can be used to give a general picture of the data set by measuring the central tendency. In this study, all of the variables are measured by five likert scale. In Q3-Q12, questions about customer expected service quality have been asked. Table 4.3 indicated the average score of ten questions based on SERVQUAL model.

The closer score to 5.0, the higher customers expect the quality of ICBC online banking services. The highest expected item is “secure and to maintain the privacy of my account”, which has an average score of 4.84. Followed by “efficient and accurate” and “understand customers needs”. The lowest average score is 4.39 from “website is well structure”.

Table 4.3

Descriptive Statistics of Customer Expected Service Quality (Each question)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

I expect the ICBC website is well structured and attractive.

106

3

5

4.39

.595

I expect the services on the ICBC website are clear and easy to use.

106

4

5

4.61

.489

I expect ICBC online banking to be reliable and to provide the promised services.

106

4

5

4.72

.453

I expect the services process of ICBC online banking to be efficient and accurate.

106

4

5

4.75

.432

I expect the staffs of ICBC online banking to handle my requests promptly.

106

3

5

4.40

.643

I expect the staffs of ICBC online banking to be willing to help customers.

106

3

5

4.51

.573

I expect the staffs of ICBC online banking have good professional knowledge.

106

3

5

4.63

.558

I expect ICBC online banking to be secure and to maintain the privacy of my account.

106

4

5

4.84

.369

I expect ICBC online banking can provide personalized service to different customers.

106

3

5

4.45

.664

I expect ICBC online banking can understand customers' needs for online banking services

106

3

5

4.64

.572

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

Table 4.4 Descriptive Statistics of Customer Expected Service Quality (Each dimension)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

ETagible

106

4.00

5.00

4.5000

.45251

EReliability

106

4.00

5.00

4.7358

.32519

EResponsiveness

106

3.50

5.00

4.4528

.54129

EAssurances

106

4.00

5.00

4.7358

.37294

EEmpathy

106

3.00

5.00

4.5472

.55001

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: This study.

Table 4.4 outlined the mean score of expected service quality based on five dimensions of SERVQUAL model. The highest mean score is 4.73 from reliability and assurance. The mean score of tangible is 4.50. Interestingly, the factor responsiveness has the lowest score which is 4.45. The overall average score of these dimensions is 4.59 which indicate that the customers of ICBC online banking have high expectation before using ICBC online banking.

The standard deviations of each dimensions are less one, showed that the respondent have similar expectations of service quality. The order of average score of five dimensions of customer expected service quality of ICBC online banking from highest to lowest is reliability, assurance, empathy, tangibility, responsiveness.

4.2.3 Mean Score Analysis of Customer Perceived Service Quality

Q13-Q22 were designed to measure customer perceived service quality. The closer the average score to 5.0, the better the ICBC online banking services performed in that area. The highest average score is 4.17 from “secure and to maintain the privacy of my account”. And the lowest average score is from “ICBC online banking can provide personalized services”. The overall average score of customer perceived service quality is 4.03, which is lower than 4.59 of customer expected service quality. That means there is a difference between customers’ expected and perceived service quality.

Table 4.5 Descriptive Statistics of Customer Perceived Service Quality (Each question)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

I feel the ICBC website is well structure and attractive.

106

3

5

3.94

.454

I feel the services on the ICBC website are clear and easy to use.

106

3

5

4.14

.467

I feel ICBC online banking is reliable to provide services as they promised.

106

2

5

4.15

.701

I feel the services process of ICBC online banking is efficient and accurate.

106

3

5

4.08

.603

I feel the staffs ICBC online banking can handle my requests promptly.

106

3

5

3.97

.467

I feel the staffs of ICBC online banking are willing to help customers.

106

3

5

4.04

.689

I feel the staffs of ICBC online banking have good professional knowledge.

106

2

5

4.02

.717

I feel ICBC online banking is secure and maintains the privacy of my account.

106

3

5

4.17

.543

I feel ICBC online banking

106

1

5

3.75

.659

I feel ICBC online banking can understand customers' needs for online banking services。

106

2

5

4.07

.759

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

Table 4.6 Descriptive Statistics of Customer Perceived Service Quality (Each dimension)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

PTangibility

106

3.00

5.00

4.0425

.40894

PReliability

106

2.50

5.00

4.1179

.57962

PResponsiveness

106

3.00

5.00

4.0047

.51407

PAssurances

106

3.50

5.00

4.0943

.48360

PEmpathy

106

1.50

5.00

3.9104

.63169

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

As illustrated in table 4.5, the order of average score of five dimensions of customer perceived service quality of ICBC online banking from highest to lowest is reliability, assurance, tangibility, responsiveness and empathy. We can see that the dimension empathy fell into the last position, which indicates that the customers’ perception of ICBC online banking can provide personalized services is lower than their expectation.

4.2.4 Mean Score Analysis of Customer Satisfaction

Table 4.7 shows the average score of customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services. The number 4.16 indicate that the ICBC online banking services have a high level of customer satisfaction. However, there are still some respondents are dissatisfaction.

Table 4.7 Descriptive Statistics of Customer Satisfaction

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

Overall, I am satisfied with ICBC online banking services.

106

3

5

4.16

.417

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

4.2.5 Mean Score Analysis of Customer loyalty

Three questions (Q24-Q26) were designed to measure customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services. Q25 got the highest score of 4.33, which indicate that the customers of ICBC online banking are willing to continue using the services. The gap between Q24 and Q25 indicate that some respondents who will continue use ICBC online banking may not recommend to other people or regard it as the first choice. So how to retain this customer and encourage them to prompt the online services is a new task for ICBC. The overall average score of customer loyalty is 4.12, which shows the customer loyalty of ICBC online banking is good.

Table 4.8 Descriptive Statistics of Customer loyalty (Each question)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

I will recommend ICBC online banking services to other people.

106

3

5

4.02

.647

I will continue using ICBC online banking services.

106

3

5

4.33

.530

When I need new financial services, I will consider ICBC as my first choice.

106

2

5

4.02

.768

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

Tale 4.9 Descriptive Statistics of Customer loyalty

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

customerloyalty

106

3.00

5.00

4.1226

.56965

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

4.2.6 Mean Score Analysis of Customer Complaint

Four questions (Q28-Q30) were designed according to four main types of customer compliant behavior mentioned in the literature review. The average score of “complain to friends” and “complain to ICBC” are higher than “complain to third party”, which indicate that customers are most likely to complain to friend rather than other institutions. The lowest average score is 1.82 of “no action”, indicates that most customer will complain if they are dissatisfied with the services of ICBC online banking.

Table 4.10 Descriptive Statistics of Customer Complaint

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

If you are dissatisfied with ICBC online banking services, you will complain to family member or friends.

106

1

5

3.48

1.026

If you are dissatisfied with ICBC online banking services,you will complain to customer service department of ICBC online banking.

106

1

5

3.56

1.070

If you are dissatisfied with ICBC online banking services,you will complain to other organizations, such as media.

106

1

5

2.69

.979

If you are dissatisfied with ICBC online banking services,you will never complain.

106

1

5

1.82

.993

Valid N (listwise)

106

Source: this study.

4.2.7 Mean Score Analysis of Dealing with Customer Complaint in ICBC

Before investigate customers’ feeling of the dealing with customer complaint of ICBC online banking, a question of whether respondents have ever complain to ICBC is asked in order to determine the size of sub-sample. As illustrated in table 4.11, in the total 106 respondents, 35 of them have the experience of complaint to ICBC.

Table 4.11 Have you ever complain to the customer service department of ICBC online banking?

Frequency

Percent

Valid Percent

Cumulative Percent

Valid

yes

35

33.0

33.0

33.0

no

71

67.0

67.0

100.0

Total

106

100.0

100.0

Source: this study.

Three questions (Q32-Q34) asked respondents about their feeling of dealing with customer complaint in ICBC. Q33 got the highest average of 4.14 indicates that respondents thought ICBC can solve their complaint promptly. Q32 and Q34 got the lower score 3.71 and 3.89. That means ICBC online banking need to improve their performance when dealing with customer complaint.

Table 4.12 Descriptive Statistics of Dealing with Customer Complaint in ICBC (Each question)

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

ICBC online banking takes customers complaint seriously.

35

2

5

3.71

.789

ICBC online banking can solve the problem promptly.

35

3

5

4.17

.707

The employees of ICBC have good professional knowledge to solve the problem.

35

3

5

3.89

.583

Valid N (listwise)

35

Source: this study.

The following table 4.13 provided the overall average score 3.92, which indicate that customers consider dealing with customer complaint in ICBC customer service department is OK but not very good.

Table 4.13 Descriptive Statistics of Dealing with Customer Complaint in ICBC

N

Minimum

Maximum

Mean

Std. Deviation

Dealing with customer complaint

35

2.67

5.00

3.9238

.58346

Valid N (listwise)

35

Source: this study.

4.3 Tests of the Hypotheses

Beyond knowing the means of variables, the relationship between variables will be examined as well. Hypothesis testing is widely used to examine the relationship between two or more variables. In this study, hypotheses 2-0 to hypotheses 5-1 were designed to examine the relationship between variables.

Sekaran (2003) presents the process of hypothesis testing: firstly, the null and alternative hypotheses should be stated; then the appropriate statistical method should be chosen according to whether the data are parametric or non nonparametric; followed by select the level of significance; and use computer to analysis. Pearson correlation matrix can be taken to indicate the strength and significance of relationships of variables (Sekaran, 2003).

4.3.1 Tests of Normality

“Before using many statistical tests, it is necessary to establish the distribution of values for variables containing quantifiable data “(Saunders et al, 2003:343). Table 4.14 shows the results of normality test by using Kolmogorov-Smirnov one-sample test. Large significance values (higher than 0.05) indicate that the observed distribution corresponds to the theoretical distribution. The Sig. value of service quality, dealing with customer complaint are 0.078 and 0.342, which indicate the scores are normality distribute. However, the Sig. value of customer loyalty is 0.01. According to Pallant (2005), if the sample size is very small, parametric test can be used even the scores of customer loyalty are not normally distribute. Therefore, Pearson test will be used in hypotheses test.

Table 4.14 One-Sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov Test

Expected service quality

Perceived service quality

Customer loyalty

Dealing with customer complaint

N

106

106

106

35

Normal Parameters(a,b)

Mean

4.5943

4.0340

4.1226

3.9238

Std. Deviation

.28446

.42108

.56965

.58346

Most Extreme Differences

Absolute

.124

.141

.189

.159

Positive

.087

.141

.189

.127

Negative

-.124

-.119

-.160

-.159

Kolmogorov-Smirnov Z

1.273

1.453

1.946

.938

Asymp. Sig. (2-tailed)

.078

.029

.001

.342

a Test distribution is Normal.

b Calculated from data.

Source: this study

4.3.2 Difference Analysis for Hypothesis One

In this part, Paired Samples T-test is taken to examine if there is a difference between customers’ expected and perceived service quality. According to Hays (1994), though the T-test has an assumption that the data are of normally distribution, this can be ignored without many problems even the sample size less than 30. The variables customers’ perceived and expected service quality of ICBC online banking services are both measured by ten questions based on SERVQUAL model.

H1-0 (Null hypothesis): There is no significant difference between customer expectation and customer perception towards service quality of ICBC online banking services.

H1-1 (Alternative hypothesis): There is a significant difference between customer expectation and customer perception towards service quality of ICBC online banking services.

Table 4.15 Paired Samples Statistics of Customer Perceived and Expected Service Quality

Mean

N

Std. Deviation

Std. Error Mean

Pair 1

Perceived service quality

4.0340

106

.42108

.04090

Expected service quality

4.5943

106

.28446

.02763

Source: this study

Table 4.16 Paired Samples Test of Customer Perceived and Expected Service Quality

Paired Differences

t

df

Sig. (2-tailed)

Mean

Std. Deviation

Std. Error Mean

95% Confidence Interval of the Difference

Mean

Std. Deviation

Std. Error Mean

Lower

Upper

Lower

Upper

Lower

Upper

Lower

Upper

Pair 1

Perceived service quality – expected service quality

-.56038

.44286

.04301

-.64567

-.47509

-13.028

105

.000

Source: this study

Pallant (2005) suggests that the significance value less than 0.05 indicates strong confidence of difference. According to the test results showed in table 4.15 and 4.16, the significant value is 0.000 (less than 0.05), which indicate that there is a significant difference between customers’ perceived service quality and expected service quality of ICBC online banking services. Therefore, hypothesis 1-0 is not supported and hypothesis 1-1 is supported.

4.3.3 Correlation Analysis for Hypothesis Two

According to Saunders et al. (2003), the correlation coefficient can indicate the strength of the relationship between two variables. This coefficient may take any value between -1 and +1. If it presents the value of +1, it indicates that there is perfect positive correlation between two variables; conversely, a value of -1 indicates a perfect negative correlation between two variables (Sekaran, 2003). The closer the value to +1 or -1, the stronger the relationship between two variables. Pallant (2005:126) presents the guidelines of correlation coefficient value as following:

“0.10 to 0.29 or -0.10 to -0.29 Small

0.30 to 0.49 or -0.30 to -0.49 Medium

0.50 to 1.00 or -0.50 to -1.00 Large”

Pearson correlation test is taken to test the following hypotheses:

H2-0 (Null hypothesis): There is no significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services.

H2-1 (Alternative hypothesis): There is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services.

Table 4.17 Correlations of Perceived Service Quality and Customer Satisfaction

Perceived service quality

Overall, I am satisfied with ICBC online banking services.

Perceived service quality

Pearson Correlation

1

.630(**)

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

Overall, I am satisfied with ICBC online banking services.

Pearson Correlation

.630(**)

1

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

Source: this study

Table 4.17 shows the relationship between customers’ perceived service quality and satisfaction. Firstly, it provides the significant value (2-tailed) 0.00 which is less than 0.05. According to Pallant (2005), two variables are related if the significance value is below 0.05. Therefore, the perceived service quality and customer satisfaction are related. In addition, the correlation coefficient value of these two variables is 0.630 which is higher than 0.5, indicates the relationship between two variables is significant and positive. Therefore, hypothesis 2-0 is not supported and hypothesis 2-1 is supported.

4.3.4 Correlation Analysis for Hypothesis Three

H3-0 (Null hypothesis): There is no significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H3-1 (Alternative hypothesis): There is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

4.18 Correlations of Customers’ Perceived Service Quality and Loyalty

Perceived service quality

Customer loyalty

Perceived service quality

Pearson Correlation

1

.697(**)

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

Customer loyalty

Pearson Correlation

.697(**)

1

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

Source: this study

As showed in table 4.18, the significant value (2-tailed) 0.00 which is less than 0.05, which indicates the two variables are related. The correlation coefficient value of these two variables is 0.697 which is higher than 0.5, indicates the relationship between two variables is significant and positive. This result indicates that there is a significant relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services. If the perceived service quality comes to a high level, the customer loyalty will change as well. Therefore, hypothesis 3-0 is not supported and hypothesis 3-1 is supported.

4.3.5 Correlation Analysis for Hypothesis Four

H4-0 (Null hypothesis): There is no significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

H4-1 (Alternative hypothesis): There is a significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services.

Table 4.19 Correlations of Customers Satisfaction and Loyalty

Overall, I am satisfied with ICBC online banking services.

Customer loyalty

Overall, I am satisfied with ICBC online banking services.

Pearson Correlation

1

.584(**)

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

Customer loyalty

Pearson Correlation

.584(**)

1

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

106

106

** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

Source: this study

Table 4.19 shows the relationship between customer satisfaction and loyalty. Firstly, the significant value (2-tailed) 0.00 which is less than 0.05. That indicates that the two variables are related. The correlation coefficient value of these two variables is 0.584 which is higher than 0.5, indicates the relationship between two variables is significant and positive. That means, the more the customer are satisfied with the services of ICBC online banking, the more loyalty they will have. Therefore, hypothesis 4-0 is not supported and hypothesis 4-1 is supported.

4.3.6 Correlation Analysis for Hypothesis Five

In this section, 35 questionnaires are collected from a sub-sample of respondents who have the complaint experiences to ICBC online banking. These data will be used to test hypothesis 5.

H5-0 (Null hypothesis): There is no positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty.

H5-1 (Alternative hypothesis): There is a positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty.

Table 4.20 Correlations of Dealing with Customer Complaint and Customer Loyalty

ICBC dealing with complaint

Customer loyalty

ICBC dealing with complaint

Pearson Correlation

1

.365(**)

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

35

35

Customer loyalty

Pearson Correlation

.365(**)

1

Sig. (2-tailed)

.000

N

35

35

** Correlation is significant at the 0.01 level (2-tailed).

Source: this study

As showed in table 4.20, the significant value (2-tailed) 0.00 which is less than 0.05. This indicates that dealing with customer complaints and customer loyalty these two variables are related. The correlation coefficient value of these two variables is 0.365 indicates the relationship between two variables is at a medium position and positive. This result indicates that there is a positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty in ICBC online banking services. However, the correlation coefficient of these two variables is in a medium position and is not as high as other three pairs of variables. Therefore, hypothesis 5-0 is not supported and hypothesis 5-1 is supported.

4.4 Research Findings

According to the analysis, both of the overall average scores of customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking are above 4. This indicates that currently the surveyed ICBC online banking users are satisfied with the services and loyalty to the company. But there are still some problems. The supported hypothesis 1-1 indicates that there is a significant difference between customers’ perceived and expected service quality of ICBC online banking services.

That means ICBC need lots work to improve their performance of online banking services. We can see from the mean score analysis of service quality: the highest expected item is “secure and to maintain the privacy of my account”, followed by “efficient and accurate” and “understand customers needs”, and the lowest average score is 4.39 from “website is well structure”. The ICBC website, security policies and services need to be improved to meet more customers’ needs.

With regarding to customer complaint behaviour, the average score of “complain to friends” and “complain to ICBC” are higher than “complain to third party”, which indicate that customers are most likely to complain to friend rather or ICBC rather than other institutions. The lowest average score is 1.82 of “no action”, indicates that most customer will complain if they are dissatisfied with the services of ICBC online banking. In the total 106 respondent, 35 of them have ever complaint to the customer service department of ICBC. Most of these 35 respondent think ICBC can handle their complaint promptly. But the average of “ICBC takes customers complaint score seriously” is lower.

The results of hypotheses testing 2-1 indicate that there is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services. According to Cronin and Taylor (1992), high service quality has a positive influence on customer loyalty. The supported hypothesis 3-1 certificate that customer perceived service quality and loyalty have a significant and positive relationship.

However, the service quality is not the only one determination. The supported hypothesis 4-1 indicates that here is a significant and positive relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services. This is consistent with previous studies (Oliver, 1999). Ganesh et. al suggested that customers whose complains are resolved satisfactorily always been more loyalty than customers who were never dissatisfied. In this study, the hypothesis 5-1 also certificate that there is a positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty in ICBC online banking.

Nowadays, the ICBC online banking faces many challenges. The trend of combination of industry and financial will be strengthened. With the development of capital market, the proportion of direct financing will increase. A large number of enterprises will set up their own websites. The customers of online banking will increase. This will lead to the combination of large enterprise and banks, they will work together to improve financial services online. Additionally, the globalization and international development of online banking services will become obviously. More and more Chinese banks will mainly depend on the development of online banking to increase customers, expand their business scope.

With regarding to these, the author would like to provide some recommendations:

  • Establish and improve the security and structure of network.
  • Strengthen the communication between employees and customers.
  • Develop new products and services in order to gain more new customers.
  • Improve the professional level of employees.
  • Do more promotion work. Introduce online banking services to people not familiar with computer skills and use marketing skills to attract them.
  • Continually measure the level of customer satisfaction and loyalty, change marketing strategy based on the research.

4.5 Conclusion

This chapter presented the statistic analysis of the data collected through questionnaires from ICBC online banking services users by using SPSS 15.0. Firstly, descriptive analysis of each variable was illustrated through figures and tables. Secondly, the normality of the distribution was examined to determine that whether parametric or non-parametric tests will be applied.

Thirdly, the hypotheses were tested to examine the relationship between service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty and dealing with customer complaint in ICBC. Then the finding of statistical tests was analyzed and recommendations are given to help ICBC improve their service quality to gain more customers.

Chapter 5 Conclusion

5.1 Introduction

The objective of this chapter is to draw a conclusion of this study. Firstly, the summary of the findings of data analysis will be concluded. Based on the findings displayed in the pervious chapter, the author gave some managerial implications for marketers of online banking industry. Then the limitation of this study will be pointed out. Finally, recommendations for the development of online banking services are given.

5.2 Summary of the Dissertation

With regarding to the banking industry, the development of network technology and it application of the banking industry has changed the external competitive environment, but it also provides new services channels, reduce operating costs, impels banks to improve customer relations, improve internal management and launch new products to meet the demand of customers.

From the banks perspective, the establishment of online banks can reduce costs and enhance competitiveness. This service delivery channels are considered powerful because it may retain the customer using the Internet from any location. Moreover, online banking offer an marketing opportunity to the bank to attract new customers from huge number of Internet users (Suganthi., et al., 2001).

In an increasingly competitive environment, companies must be customer oriented (Kotler, 1997). It is not surprising that more and more companies spend substantial resources to measure and manage customer satisfaction, especially the financial institutions.

This study is taken to examine the service quality, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty, dealing with customer complaint in ICBC online banking and the relationships between these variables. The writer took a descriptive approach in this research and designed a structured questionnaire based on previous literature such as the SERVQUAL and ACSI model. According to this survey, both of the overall average scores of customer satisfaction and customer loyalty of ICBC online banking are above 4. Although the customer satisfaction and loyalty are at high level, there are still come problems need to be improved.

The frequency of ICBC online banking usage was low. The ICBC website, security policies and services need to be improved. And there is a gap between ICBC online banking employees and customers. The writer also gave some recommendations. Establish and improve the security and structure of network. They should strengthen the communication between employees and customers, improve the professional level of employees, do more promotion work toward potential customers. Furthermore, they should continually measure the level of customer satisfaction and loyalty, change marketing strategy based on the research. As developing and retaining loyal customers has been recognized as a most important driver of long-term financial performance (Reicheld and Sasser, 1990). Financial institutions are suggested to measure customer satisfaction and loyalty level constantly, which will benefit them a lot in improving services quality and retaining customers.

Not surprisingly, the supported hypothesis 2-1 indicates that there is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services. The results of hypotheses testing 2-1 indicate that there is a significant and positive relationship between customer perceived service quality and customer satisfaction of ICBC online banking services. Fullerton (2005) suggested that service quality is the prime driver of customer loyalty. The supported hypothesis 3-1 certificate that customer perceived service quality and loyalty have a significant and positive relationship.

However, the service quality is not the only one determination. The supported hypothesis 4-1 indicates that customer satisfaction is an important driver of customer loyalty of ICBC online banking services, they have a strong correlation at 0.584 level. This is consistent with previous studies (Oliver, 1999). Ganesh et. al suggested that customers whose complains are resolved satisfactorily always been more loyalty than customers who were never dissatisfied. In this study, the hypothesis 5-1 also certificate that there is a positive relationship between dealing with customer complain and customer loyalty in ICBC online banking, they have a medium correlation at 0.365 level.

5.3 Managerial Implications

The findings of this study have many managerial implications. And these implications could help the managers of ICBC online banking better understand their customers and make more efficient decision. Based the results of this study, the managers of ICBC online banking may concern the ways to improve their services in order to meet customer needs.

Zeithamel et al. (1990) suggested that in order to satisfy customers, the company must understand the gap between customers’ expected and perceived quality of products or services. In order to satisfy customers, the managers of ICBC online banking must understand the customers’ needs and desires. Many kinds of communication channels could be used, such as telephone, email and website.

This study certified that there are high positive relationship between customer perceived service quality, customer satisfaction, and customer loyalty. There is also a medium positive relationship between handle customer complaint and customer loyalty. According to these, the ICBC online banking must establish a long term strategy to improve the perceived service quality, satisfy their customer, handle customer complaint promptly in order to achieve more loyal customers.

5.4 Limitation of This Study

However, there are some limitations of this research which may influence the validity and accuracy of findings. According to Saunders et al, (2003), “sample size and the technique used are also influenced by the availability of resource, in particular financial support and time available to select sample and to collect, analysis data”. As time is limited, the writer distributed the questionnaire through a survey website and email, only people received the website and email can finish the questionnaire. The sample size is too small and not large enough to represent all the ICBC online banking users’ opinion.

In addition, due to time limitation, the investigation process was simplified. Twenty questions were asked to examine customers’ expected and perceived service quality of ICBC online banking compare to the original twenty two questions in SERVQUAL model. Thus, there may have the possibility of missing factor. In addition, there is only one question asked customer satisfaction in the questionnaire. Therefore, the data collected for this variable are not easy to have normally distribution. However, parametric test was still adopted in hypothesis testing.

5.5 Recommendations for Future Research

The finding of this study may be useful for the managers of ICBC online banking to better understand customers before they make decision. The limitation and implication may also give some advice to future research. Firstly, due to time and cost limitation, the sample size is small in this study. Secondly, the future research should add more factors to the service quality model in order to make the measurement more precisely. Finally, it would be very to examine the relationship between specific dimensions in online banking services. The more specific, the more helpful for the mangers when they make decision.

5.6 Summary

In conclusion, as the global and local competition between financial institutions has become more intense, building long-term customer relationships becomes ever more important. How to satisfy customers and gain customer loyalty has become one of the best means of obtaining competitive advantage. At the same time, Chinese online banking will grow rapidly and become an industry with great potential and broad prospects. The customers and trading volume will continue to grow as well. The Chinese financial institutions should grasp these opportunities, try their best to satisfy and retain customers in order to improve their businesses.

References

Aladwani, A.M. (2001), “Online banking: a field study of drivers, development challenges, and expectations”, International Journal of Information Management, Vol. 21, pp. 213-25.

Anderson, E.W. and Fornell, C., (2000), “Foundations of the American Customer Satisfaction Index”, Total Quality Management, vol.11(7).

Anderson, E.W. and Sullivan, M., (1993), “The Antecedents and Consequences of Customer-Satisfaction for Firms,” Marketing Science, vol. 12, pp. 125-143.

Anderson, E.W., Fornell, C. and Lehamn, D.R. (1994), “Customer satisfaction, market share, and profitability: findings from Sweden”, Journal of Marketing, Vol.58.

Bateson, J.E.G., (1977), Do we need service marketing? In: P. Eligier, E. Langeard, C.H. Lovelock et al, Marketing Customer Services: New Lights. Marketing Science Institute Report No. 77-115.

Bainbridge,R., (2008), History of Online Banking, http://ezinearticles.com/?History-of-Online-Banking&id=270075, assessed 14/04/2008

Bejou, D.&Palmer, A. (1998), “Service failure and loyalty: an exploratory empirical study of airline customers”, Journal of service Marketing, Vol.12 (1), pp.7- 22.

Bloemer J., Ruyter K. de and Wetzels M., (1999), Linking perceived service quality and service loyalty a multi-dimensional perspective, European Journal of Marketing 33 (1999) (11/12), pp. 1082–1106.

Broderick, A.J. and Vachirapornpuk, S. (2002), “Service quality in Internet banking: the importance of customer role”, Marketing Intelligence and Planning, Vol. 20 (6), pp.327-335.

Bowen, D.E. and Schneider, B., (1988), Service marketing and management: Implications for organizational behaviour, Research in Organizational Behaviour, Vol.10, pp43-80.

Brady, M.K. and Cronin, J.J. (2001), “Some new thoughts on conceptualizing perceived service quality: a hierarchical approach”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. (65), pp.34 -49

Cardozo, R. N., (1965), “An Experimental study of customer effort, expectation and satisfaction”, Journal of Marketing Research, 1965,2( 3), pp.244-249

Caruana, A. (2000), “Service loyalty: The effects of service quality and the mediating role of customer satisfaction”, European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 36 (7/8), pp.811-828.

Chen, K.S. and Yang, H.H. (1999), “A new decision-making tool: the service performance index”, International Journal of Quality& Reliability Management, Vol.17(6), pp.671-678.

Cowling, A. and Newman, K. (1995), “Banking on people: TQM, service quality, and human resources”, Personnel Review, Vol. 24(7), pp.25-40.

Danaher, P.J. and Haddrell, V. (1996), ``A comparison of question scales used for measuring customer satisfaction'', International Journal of Service Industry Management, Vol. 7 No. 4, pp. 4-26.

Funston, R., (1992), “Great Expectations Improving Customer Service,” CMA Magazine, vol. 66, pp.24-29

Chen, K.S. and Yang, H.H., (2000), “A new decisionmaking tool: the service performance index”, International Journal of Quality and Reliability Management .

China Online Banking Research Report 2007-2008, (2008), http://www.iresearch.com.cn/html/Consulting/online_payment/Free_id_1124.html, assessed 14/07/2008

Cho, M. and Park, S., (2001), “Develop of electronic commerce user-consumer satisfaction index (ECUSI) for Internet shopping”, Industrial Management and Data Systems, Vol.101(8), pp.440-445.

Christopher, B.B., (2008), FDIC Banking Review, http://www.fdic.gov/bank/analytical/banking/1995summ/art3full.html, assessed 14/07/2008

Cronin, J J and Taylor, S A (1992) 'Measuring service quality: a reexamination and extension' Journal of Marketing56 (July) 55-58.

Crosby, P. (1979), Quality is Free: The art of making quality certain, New York: New American Library.

Davidow, M. & Dacin, P.A., (1997), “Understanding and influencing consumer complaint behavior: improving organizational complaint management”, Advances in Consumer Research, Vol.24, pp.450-456.

Day, R.L. and Landon, E. (1977), Towards a theory of consumer complaining behavior, in Woodside A G, Sheth, J. N. & Bennet, P.D., Consumer and Industrial Buying Behavior, New York: North-Holland, pp.425-437

Day, R.L., (1980), “Collecting comprehensive consumer complaining data by survey research”, Advance in Consumer Research, Vol.,3, pp.263-269

Dick, A.S. and Basu, K. (1994), “Customer loyalty: toward an integrated conceptual framework”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol. 22(2), pp.99-113.

Easingwood, C. and Storey, C. (1993), “Marketplace success factors for new financial services”, Journal of Services Marketing, Vol. 7 No. 1, pp. 41-54.

Ennew, C.T. and Waite, N., (2007), Financial Services Marketing: An International Guide to Principles and Practice, UK: Elsevier.

Fecikova, I. (2004), “An index method for measurement of customer satisfaction”, The TQM Magazine, Vol.16(1), pp.57-66.

Fink, A. (1995), How to Ask Survey Questions, Thousand Oaks, Ca: Sage.

Foddy, W. (1994), Constructing Questions for Interviews and Questionnaires, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Fornell, C. A. (1992), “National customer satisfaction barometer: the Swedish experience”, Jounral of Marketing, Vol. 56 (1), pp.6- 22.

Fornell, C., Johnson,M.D., Anderson,W., Cha, J. and Bryant, B.E, (1996), “The American Customer Satisfaction Index: nature, purpose, and findings”, Journal of Marketing, Vol.60.

Ganesh, Arnold and Reynolds, “Understanding the Customer Base of Service Providers: An Examination of the Differences between Switchers and Stayers”, pp.68-8.

Ghauri, P. and Gronhaugh, K. (2002), Research Methods in Business Study: A Practical Guide, (2nd ed), Harlow: Financial Times Prentice Hall.

Griffin, A., and Hauser, J.R., (1993), “The Voice of the Customer,” Marketing Science, vol. 12, pp.1-27.

Gronholdt, L., Martensen, A.& Kristensen, K. (2000), “The relationship between customer satisfaction and loyalty: cross-industry differences”, Total Quality Management, Vol. (11), pp. 509-516.

Gronroos, C. (1982), An applied service marketing theory, European Journal of Marketing, Vol.16(7), pp30 -41.

Gronroos, C., (1990), Service Management and Marketing, Canada: Lexington Books Press, pp.37-39

Ghauri, P. and Gronhaugh, K., (2002), Research Methods in Business Studies: A Practical Guide. (2nd ed). Harlow: Financial Times Prentice Hall.

Giglio, V. (2002), "Privacy in the world of cyberbanking: emerging legal issues and how you are protected", The Secured Lender, Vol.3/4, pp.48-60.

Gronholdt, L., Martensen, A., Kristensen, K. (2000), "Customer satisfaction measurement at post Denmark: results of application of the European Customer Satisfaction Index methodology", Journal of Total Quality Management, Vol. 11(7), pp.1007.

Gummesson, E. (1987), “The new marketing-developing long-term interactive relationships”, Long Range Planning, Vol.20(1), pp.10.

Hague, P., Hague, N. and Morgan, C. (2004), Market Research in Practice: A Guide to the Basics, Great Britain: Kogan Page.

Hague, P. (2006), Introduction to Market and Social Research, Great Britain, Karen Adams and Ian Brace.

Hamel, G., (1996), “Strategy as Revolution”, Harvard Business Review, July-August 1997, pp.69-82.

Hsu-Hao Yang and K.S. Chen, (2000), Managing Service Quality Volume 10 . Number 5. 000 pp. 273±278

Heskett, James L., Sasser, W.Earl,Jr, and Schlesinger, Leonard A., (2003), The Value Profit Chain. New York: The Free Press. P53-74

Higgins, K.T. (1997), “Coming of age”, Marketing News, Vol. 31(22), pp.1.

Ho, S. (1995), TQM An Integrated Approach, Kogan Page, London.

Howcroft, B., Hamilton, R., Hewer, P. (2002), "Consumer attitude and the usage and adoption of home-based banking in the United Kingdom", International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 20(3), pp.111-21.

Ingrid, F. (2004), “An index method for measurement of customer satisfaction”, The TQM Magazine, Vol. 16(l), pp.57 -66.

Jankowicz, A.D., (2002), Business Research Projects, (3rd ed). London: Business Press Thomson Learning.

Jayawardhena, C. and Foley, P. (2000), “Changes in banking sector: the case of Internet banking in the UK”, Internet Research: Electronic Networking: Application and Policy, Vol. 10 (1), pp.19-30.

Jun, M. and Cai, S. (2001), “The key determinants of Internet banking service quality: a content analysis”, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 19(7), pp.276-291.

Karjaluoto, H., Koivumäki, T., Salo, J. (2003), "Individual differences in private banking: empirical evidence from Finland", Proceedings of the 36th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences (HICSS), Big Island, Hawaii, p. 196,

Kim, J.K., Han, C.H., Choi, S.H. and Kim, S.H. (1998), “A knowledge based approach to the quality function deployment”, Computers and Industrial Engineering, Vol. 35 Nos 1/2, pp. 233-6.

Kolodinsky, M., Hogerth, M. and Hilgert, A., (2004), “The adoption of electronis banking technologies by US consumers”, The International Journal of Banking Marketing, Vol.22(4).

Kotler, P. & Keller, K., (2006), Marketing Management, (12th ed). US: Pearson of Prentice Hall, pp.144

Kotler, P.R. (1997), Marketing Management: Analysis, Planning, Implementation, and Control, (9th ed), US: Pearson of Prentice Hall

Kristensen, K., Martensen, A. and Gronholdt, L., (2000), “Customer satisfaction measurement at post Denmark: results of application of the European customer satisfaction index methodology”, Total Quality Management, Vol.11.

Li (2002), People Daily, available at: www.english.peopledaily.com.cn/business, accessed 16/04/2008.

Levitt, T., (1972), “Production-line approach to service”, Harvard Business Review,

Vol,50 (4), pp41.

Lewis, B.R. (1991), "Service quality: an international comparison of bank customers’ expectations and perceptions", Journal of Marketing Management, Vol. 7 pp.47-62.

Lovelock, C.H. and Gummesson,E., (2004), “Whither services marketing? In search of a new paradigm and fresh perspectives”, Journal of Service Research, Vol.7(1),pp.20.

McDonald, Roderick P. and Herbert W. Marsh (1990). "Choosing a Multivariate Model: Noncentrality and Goodness of Fit," Journal of Marketing Research, 22(February), 1-19.

Miller, C., (1993), “US firms lag in meeting global quality standards”, Marketing News, Feb.15.

Mitchell, V. (1996), “Accessing the reliability and validity of questionnaires: an empirical example”, Journal of Applied Management Studies, Vol. 5(2), pp.199-207.

Mols, N.P. (2000), “The Internet and banks’ strategic distribution channel decisions”, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 17(6), pp.295-300.

Online banking, (2008), http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Online_banking, accessed 16/04/2008

Oliver, R.L. (1980), “A cognitive model of the antecedents and consequences of satisfaction decisions”, Journal of Marketing Research, Vol.12, pp.460-469.

Oliver, R.L. (1993), ``Cognitive, affective and attribute bases of satisfaction response'', Journal of Consumer Research, Vol. 20 No. 3, pp. 418-30.

Oliver R.L., (1999), “Whence customer loyalty?”, Journal of Marketing, Vol.63, pp. 33–44.

Oppewal, H. and Vriens, M. (2000), “Measuring perceived service quality using integrated conjoint experiments”, International Journal of Banking Marketing, Vol, 18(4), pp.154-169.

Pallant, J. (2005). SPSS Survival Manual: a Step By Step Guide to Data Analysis Using SPSS Version 12, (2nd ed), Maidenhead: Open University Press.

Pan Chengde, ‘建立完善的客户服务体系’ translation: ‘Establish and improve customer service system’, http://soft.chinabyte.com/324/2607824.shtml, assessed 14/04/2008

Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V. A. & Berry, L. L. (1985). “A Conceptual Model of Service Quality and Its Implications for Future Research”, Journal of Marketing, 49(4), 41-50.

Parasuraman, A., Zeithaml, V.A., Berry, L. (1988), "SERVQUAL: a multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality", Journal of Retailing,, Vol. 64 pp.12-40.

Parasuraman, A., Berry, L.L. and Zeithaml, V.A., (1991), Refinement and reassessment of the SERVQUAL scale, Journal of Retailing, Vol.67(4), pp.420.

Patterson, P.G. (1997), “Modeling the determinants of customer satisfaction for business-to-business professional services”, Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, Vol.25.

Polatoglu, V.N., Ekin, S. (2001), "An empirical investigation of the Turkish consumers’ acceptance of internet banking services", International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol. 19 No.4, pp.156-165.

Pritchard, M.P., Howard, D.R. (1997), "The loyal traveler: examining a typology of service patronage", Journal of Travelers Research, Vol. 35 No.4, pp.2-11.

Reichheld, F., and Sasser, W.E. (1990), "Zero defections: quality comes to services", Harvard Business Review, Vol. 68, pp.105-11

Rotchanakitumnuai, S., and Speece, M., (2003), “Barriers to Internet Banking Adoption: A quality study among corporate customers in Thailand”, The International Journal of Banking Marketing, Vol.21(6).

Robinson, T. (2000), “Internet banking: still not a perfect marriage”, Informationweek.com, Vol.4(17), pp.104-106.

Roscoe, J. T. (1975), Fundamental Research Statics for the Behavioural Sciences (2nd ed), New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston.

Rust, R.T. and Williams, D.C. (1994), “Service quality: insight and managerial implications from the frontier”, Service Quality: New Direction in Theory and Practice, Rust, R.T., pp.241-268.

Sathye, M., (1999), “Adoption of Internet banking by Australian Consumers: An Emprical Investigation”, International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol.17(7), pp324-334.

Saunders, M., Lewis, P. and Thornhill, A., (2007), Research Methods for Business Students. London: Prentice Hall.

Sasser, W .E and Olsen, R .P. (1978), Management of service operations: text and case, Boston: Allyn & Bacon, pp.88 -97.

Sarsser, Olsen and Wyckoff (1998)

Sekaran, U., (2003), Research Methods for Business: A Skill Building Approach. (4th ed), New York: John Wiley & Sons. pp121-123

Stafford, M.R. (1996), “Demographic discriminators of service quality in the banking industry”, Journal Of Services Marketing, Vol. 10 No. 4, pp. 6-22.

Stauss, B. and Neuhaus, P. (1977), “The qualitative satisfaction model”, International Journal of Service Industry Management, Vol.8(3), pp.236-249.

Stewart, H.C.,Hope and Muhlemamt, A., (1998), “Professional service quality”, Journal of Retailing and Consumer services, Vol.5( 4), pp.209-222.

Storbacka, K. (1994), “A relationship marketing perspective on the link between service quality and customer profitability in retail banking”, International Quality in Services Conferences. Norwalk.

Swartz, Teresa A., Bowen David E., Iacobucci. Dawn, (1997), Advances in services marketing and management: research and practice. Vol.6, P112-116

Szwarc, P., (2005), Researching Customer Satisfaction and Loyalty: How to Find Out What People Really Think, http://site.ebrary.com/lib/surreyuniv/Doc?id=10096176&ppg=21, assessed 22/04/2008

Tax, S.S., Brown, S.W and Murali, C., (1998), “Customer evaluations of service complaint experiences: implications for relationship marketing”, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 62, pp. 64-76.

TePeci,M., (1999), “Increasing brand loyalty in the hospitality industry”, International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management, Vol.11, pp.223-9

The American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), (2008), ACSI Methodology, http://www.theacsi.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=48&Itemid=41, accessed 16/04/2008

The 2007 Financial Report of ICBC, (2008), http://www.icbc.com.cn/index.jsp, accessed 16/04/2008

Varge, S.L. and Lusch, R.F.,(2004), “The four service marketing myths: remnants of a goods based, manufacturing model”, Journal of Service Research, Vol.6(4), pp324.

deVaus, D.A. (2002), Surveys in Social Research, (5th ed), London: Routledge.

Veloutsou, C., Daskou, S. and Daskou, A. (2004), “Are the determinants of bank loyalty, brand specific?”, Journal of Financial Services Marketing, Vol.9(2), pp.113.

Verma, R., Zafar, I. and Plaschka, G. (2004), “Understanding customer choice in e-financial services”, California Management Review, Vol.46(4), pp.43.

Vilares, M., Coelho, P. (2004), "The employee-customer satisfaction chain in the ECSI model", European Journal of Marketing, Vol. 37 No.11, pp.1703-1722.

Wang, Y., Lo, H. and Hui, Y. (2003), “The antecedents of service quality and their influences on bank reputation: evidence from the banking industry in China”, Managing Service Quality, Vol. 13 No. 1, pp. 72-83.

Wong, X., Yen, D.C. and Fang, X. (2004), "E-commerce development in China and its implications for business", Asia Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, Vol. 16(3), pp.68-83.

Yang, H.H. and Chen, K.S., (2000), “A performance index approach to managing service quality”, Managing Service Quality, Vol. 10 (5), pp.273-278.

Yi, Y. (1990), "A critical review of consumer satisfaction", Review of Marketing, American Marketing Association, Chicago, IL, pp.68-123.

Webster, Frederick E. Jr (2000). "Understanding the Relationships Among Brands, Consumers and Resellers," Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 28(1), 17-23.

Zeithaml V.A., Berry L.L. and Parasuraman A., The behavioural consequences of service quality, Journal of Marketing 60 (1996) (2), pp. 31–46.

Zeithaml, V. (1988), "Consumer perceptions of price, quality and value: a means-end model and synthesis of evidence", Journal of Marketing, Vol. 52 No.July, pp.2-22.

Zeithaml, V., Parasuraman, A., Berry, L.L. (1990), Delivering Quality Service, The Free Press, New York

Zeithaml, V.A. (2000) ‘service quality, profitability and the economic worth of customers: what we know and what we need to learn’, Journal of Academy of Marketing Science, 28:1, 67-85.

Writing Services

Essay Writing
Service

Find out how the very best essay writing service can help you accomplish more and achieve higher marks today.

Assignment Writing Service

From complicated assignments to tricky tasks, our experts can tackle virtually any question thrown at them.

Dissertation Writing Service

A dissertation (also known as a thesis or research project) is probably the most important piece of work for any student! From full dissertations to individual chapters, we’re on hand to support you.

Coursework Writing Service

Our expert qualified writers can help you get your coursework right first time, every time.

Dissertation Proposal Service

The first step to completing a dissertation is to create a proposal that talks about what you wish to do. Our experts can design suitable methodologies - perfect to help you get started with a dissertation.

Report Writing
Service

Reports for any audience. Perfectly structured, professionally written, and tailored to suit your exact requirements.

Essay Skeleton Answer Service

If you’re just looking for some help to get started on an essay, our outline service provides you with a perfect essay plan.

Marking & Proofreading Service

Not sure if your work is hitting the mark? Struggling to get feedback from your lecturer? Our premium marking service was created just for you - get the feedback you deserve now.

Exam Revision
Service

Exams can be one of the most stressful experiences you’ll ever have! Revision is key, and we’re here to help. With custom created revision notes and exam answers, you’ll never feel underprepared again.